Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

***CHAT TONIGHT, and a SURVEY: Hollowing tools***

Posts

***CHAT TONIGHT, and a SURVEY: Hollowing tools***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***CHAT TONIGHT, and a SURVEY: Hollowing tools***

Ellis Walentine

Hi folks,

I'm doing some research for an upcoming survey of hollowing tool options for a mainstream woodworking magazine, and I'd like to draw on the expertise and participation of our online turning community for input and possible collaboration. Specifically, I intend to outline the types of hollowing tools available (with brand names of the major players and notable minor players), and I would like to discuss the way they cut, their tip geometry and anything else that differentiates them, including price.

The article is mainly about hand-held tool options, but I have insisted on a sidebar on the captive and articulating tool universe, so I'll appreciate your input on those tool systems as well.

If you would like to add your voice to the chorus, feel free to respond to this post as well. I would like to know what types and brand(s) of tools you use for which types of hollowing tasks and why. What distinguishes scraper-type tools from carbide insert cutter types and ring/hook cutters. If you use the ring cutter types, do you use a depth limiter with it?

This is going to be a fun project, and I will credit this group for any help you provide with my research.

Thanks, and I hope I see you tonightin the chat room at 9:30 EDT.

Ellis

Re: ***CHAT TONIGHT, and a SURVEY: Hollowing tools***

#2

Ellis Walentine

Excellent chat last night

Ellis Walentine

We had a packed house, with more than 20 people at times. I asked a lot of questions about hollowing tools -- types, sharpening angles, pros and cons, sharpening angles, etc. -- and got a lot of good answers. I will be editing the chat log for posterity when I get to it. Meanwhile, thanks to all who attended for your help.

If anyone would still like to respond to the questions I asked in the survey above, please do.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***CHAT TONIGHT, and a SURVEY: Hollowing tools***

#3

Re: Excellent chat last night

glenn roberts

Ellis, over the years I have tried various hand held hollowing tools for making fairly large hollow forms from predominantly very hard dry Australian burl, with quite small openings. I have made my far share of home made tools in the search of a better tool. IMO, you need an auxiliary side handle to resist the forces and let you know what angle the tool is. ( good if you start with the tool tip down and out of the way, inside the piece, and slowly bring it into the work) the side handle lets you do this. You also need the main and side handle to be firmly fixed to the tool shaft.

There is a huge difference between turning small diameter long pieces compared to larger diameter short pieces, the rotational forces on the tool, when doing large diameter pieces can be very substantial. Particularly when undercutting the top corners near the opening, as your tool has lots of overhang perpendicular to the axis of the lathe.

So, if you trying to have a small opening you need small headed and tipped tools. While a small opening is not essential, it is generally the intent with most hollowing. As any damage that the shaft makes at the opening often negates the whole hollowing process.

The Kelton hollowers are a good example of a tool that works with small openings. While they may not 'cut' the wood like some guarded design tools, they fit in and work. Simple as that! They are also one of the few that make small hollowers and they fit in their hollowing rig if you don't want to turn free hand. So there is a size available for all sizes of work, without having to change from one 'concept' to another. An often overlooked idea for novices. Keep it simple and consistent, rather than chasing 'quick fixes'.

For what it is worth, I have found any unguarded TC insert type hollowers very 'grabby' in Australian wood. Just too aggressive, unless the exact angle is found. I hope this helps. No doubt you will get many conflicting comments. LOL.