Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Need suggestions and ideas

Posts

Need suggestions and ideas

#1

Need suggestions and ideas

Ted Evans

Hello all, I am soliciting some comments/suggestions about this project that I am working on for my wife. It will be a utility piece used as a fruit/vegetable bowl and I was thinking of using the middle, with or without a lid, for dip. Is this a good/bad idea, or would it be better to forget the idea and make a more conventional bowl?

Another question would be how would you treat the transition from the bottom to the middle section, if, you were to use it in that configuration?

Sorry for the fuzzy pics, since it is just in the roughing stage, I was too lazy to get the tripod.

It is slightly under 13� x almost 4� deep. I would really be appreciative of any suggestions and ideas that you would offer.

Ted


Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#2

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

Bob Macgregor

I've thought of making a similar tray, though shallower, with a place in the middle sized to hold a glass or ceramic cup for dip. Obviously, I think its a great idea.

Lovely wood you have there!

BOB

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#3

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

John Veerkamp

I like the idea of using the middle for dip, but If it were me I'd find a small pottery dish that fit your center depression for the dip. Much easier to clean a removable ceramic or glass than to get dried dip from the wood.

John

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#4

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

Barry Irby

I have made a bunch of these as chips and dip trays. I bought dishes to fit in the center. The dishes were two cup Pyrex with plastic snap on lids. (Kmart, used to be Martha Stewart, but now Identical but without the MS name.) I'm sure you can find similar dishes anywhere they sell dishes. I liked the Pyrex because you can heat it, freeze it, microwave it, whatever. You could provide two with each tray so they can have a spare already loaded. Two cups was slightly too large, but one cup was too small. The plastic lid was nice so you could load them in advance and put them in the fridge.

Mine were more like platters with the bowl mounted on a raised center. I turned the recess to fit the bowl and actually carefully fitted them. Then the wood shrank a bit and I turned them again to open the holes up a bit. If I were doing it again, I would turn them, fit the dishes, and let them sit for a month and check the fit, before I put the finish on them. Shop around and find the dish before you go too far.

I think I posted a picture of one of mine here about a year ago, but I'm not sure. Maybe a search would turn it up. I lost my pictures of it in a computer crash.

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

Keith Tompkins

Ted, such a great piece of wood...shame to use it for a utilitarian piece. I say BOWL! Anybody second that?

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#6

A second for bowl.

Dick Coers

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#7

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

ed hoxter

ted, it's going to make a great looking piece no matter which way you go with it. my personal opion is i would hate to see it all stain up with some kind of dip. waiting to see your finished piece. good luck ed

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#8

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

Ted Evans

A big thank you to all for your comments and suggestions. The suggestion for using a glass, bowl or cup is a great idea, I would have thought of that, :D it is just that it may have taken me awhile. :b :b

Some great ideas Barry, ones that I will use, even if I must find another blank.

Well thanks a lot Keith, Dick and Ed, now I must find another blank for the wife. :\ Actually, this started out to be a bowl but when I advanced the idea of the center container to my wife, she really liked the idea. The ideas and suggestions by all is what I was hoping for, so I think I will finish this one as a bowl, being that I like to use pre-cat lacquer on this type of wood and will get another piece for my wife. Then I can use the other great ideas on the next piece. :)

Ted

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#9

PS, Ted....

Barry Irby

Don't use a spectacular piece of wood for this. I did and it was pretty much wasted. The bowl is covered with stuff and no one sees the wood. So just use a nice piece. And buy the inset bowl first so you can start from the center out. The wood does not need to be that thick. 2 or 2 1/2" will work well. Use a shallow rim and put the center bowl up on a sort of pedestal and pile the stuff up against it.

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#10

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

Doug Trembath

Ted, I have used this concept very successfully with shallower dishes, with integral cups and with just a shallow recess to hold a crystal dip bowl. They were very nice, but didn't sell very well, unfortunately. My sense is that as deep (and beautiful) as this piece is, I agree with Keith that this piece would be better suited as a bowl. With the figure and grain as active as it is, the less embellishment the better. Let the beauty of the wood speak for itself...

Doug Trembath

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

#11

Re: Need suggestions and ideas

Ted Evans

I like the suggestion Barry, would you happen to have a picture? I do much better trying to copy something from someone who knows what they are doing as my design talents are lacking.

Hey Doug, if I am not over ruled by the chief of staff, I will follow the suggestion of using a different piece of wood for this project. As far as selling, that is a none issue for me since it is for the wife.

Thanks again to all. Ted