Hi John, I have been playing around with CA glue for a long time. I got to thinking about the icing on your muffins. What if you used real icing and after it dries out, soak it with thin CA glue? Have you tried this allready? If not, it might work.
It's worth a shot. There are also sort of a permanent icing but I haven't tried that yet. I think it's still kind of fragile it's just for show cakes that go on display. The Thin CA might work well on that. Should I use the medical grade so it's still edible.
I've looked at caulking materials. The have the right consistency and some of them have a sort of semi matte appearance. The problem with those is your stuck with whatever color you can buy. I don't know how to color the stuff. It sure would be nice to just stick a cake decorator tip on the tube and squeeze away.
John my X-wife messed around with ciramics and there was some stuff that could be used and if fluffed up like cotton. Can't remember what it was called but you may check a ciramic shop.
I forgot all the things you have tried but did you try any of the home made clays? I remember if you added too much water you could lift peaks with your hand trying to work it. It would air dry and color with regular food coloring. There was one type used to make colored beads to string.
I could look to see if I have info from my kids old crafts or they are probably on line. I know some are too grainy for frosting but the flour or cornstarch type would be smooth.
Gaylen I'm going to call my ceramics friend who is an instructor at the craft center and see if he has any solutions. I know you can get light colored clays so it might be possible to tint them.
I tried polymer clays and the were way to thick but I didn't try thinning them with water. If I still have them and can find where I put them I'll try that tonight.
Ellis Drywall compound works if you mix it from scratch poweder and don't make the parts thin. It's too thin if you get the pre mixed and it's too fragile if you make thin parts. I may play with it again because I may be able to alter the shapes of the decorations and not have a fragile area.
Your response about the fragility was important, John. If you want something really durable, how about some West System epoxy with enough filler or microballoons to make it stand up like whipped egg whites? It would take great detail and cure hard as a rock.
Ellis West systems is what I've been playing with. I tried several fillers and the only one that works is the 406 mixes up white. It takes a lot of it to make it thick enough for icing.
I have several problems with this stuff. It's very hard to judge the thickness. You think it's right and you squirt it out, it looks great on the cake and then as it heats up to harden it must soften some because it settles and doesn't look as crisp.
You have to be really careful with the colors I'm adding. Too much and it won't harden. Too little and it looks transparent, more like Jello. I haven't tried something like Transtint yet. Maybe that stuff will be more concentrated and take less color and won't change the curing of the epoxy.
Lastly is just the appearance. It's too glossy. I have been thinking about making the icing on a sacrificial piece so that the icing could be removed. Then I could easily spray it with semi matte or matte spray to give a more realistic look. I could then glue this onto the real cupcake.
I'll be doing some more experimenting in the next few weeks because I have plans for cupcake based piece that needs to be perfect.
I remember seeing iddy biddy cakes strictly for display made out of salt and whatever. Hard as a rock. Think they had to be baked. For what it's worth.