As a part time turner, sharpening has been a continuous learning process for me. As such, several of my original spindle & bowl gouges are no longer at an appropriate angle.
Comparing my spindle gouges to the new Thompson I just got was very "eye-opening."
I want to bring them back to alignment on my bench grinder and have a question as to how I should approach re-shaping the gouges. I would think that I should concentrate on the "tip" of the gouge to get the correct angle and then worry about shaping the wings with the jig I use (Tormek for the grinder).
Does that seem to be the reasonable approach? Am I missing anything that would be more appropriate?
Yep. That's the way I do it. Except I use a Wolverine.Takes away a lot of metal if you are drastically changing the shape and, in my case, it always takes some nerve to do that first grinding down of the tip to get the desired angle. It's looks so awful at first until you get the wings done!
The Tormek is going to be a difficult task to reshape your tools to get to the grind on your Tompson gouges. Using the gouge jig on the Tormek, insert a Tompson gouge with a good grind and extend it about 2 inches from the jig. Now set your bar that the jig moves on so that the angle of the bevel is very close to fitting the grinding wheel. Lock the extension at thie point. Now lay the gouge on its side and adjust the angle until you have the side of the gouge laying flat on the wheel. Now, check the bevel angle again and adjust slightly as necesary. If the second adjustment of the bevel angle is close. you are probably ready to grind and reasonably reproduce the Tompson grind.
It should be basically the same technique used to set up the Wolverine Jigs and if my memory serves me the method I just described is correct.
"Tormek for the grinder" Does this mean that you are using the tormek jig with a dry grinder?
After you get the tip squared away reset the distance the tool protrudes from the jig. You may find that the tip grinding has shortened the tool 1/4" or more. The readjustment will require some more attention to the tip. This may require that you adjust the length again.
The Tormek jig is the same jig that Sorby sold for a dry grinder years ago. That is the jig I have used for the past 12 years.
BTW the grind Doug puts on his tool is not necessarily the best for you. Being able to maintain the grind which works for you is the important thing.
I agree that his grind may not be the best for me (still figuring that out); the difference between the two grinds (mine and Thompsons) is what made me realize some reshaping is needed.
It's a spindle gouge which is a simple rounded nose ground at 40 degrees, not much more can be done. It sure beats Sorby, Henry Taylor, Crown and P&N who don't even try to sharpen there tools.
Show me your grinds on a spindle gouge so I know what's the best... I could offer custom grinds.
Another thing to consider is that you do not have to have the 'perfect' grind on your gouges. They can be off a little, and it will make almost no difference in how they cut. I do eyeball mine from time to time, and gradually reshape them a small bit at a time. Seems that I tend to sharpen one side more than the other. Being slightly more pointy, or round can be taken care of by spending just a bit more time each time you sharpen on the problem area. Bevel is probably more important than sweep, well, at least to me, but that is as much a choice of bowl design as it is personal preference.
If you intend to do major reshaping, you need a 30 grit wheel, and a high speed grinder for the rough work, then back to a normal grinder for the touch up work.
One item of consideration. How are you sharpening??
I have a "gauge" for my gouge. It is a piece of wood. I drilled a hole and epoxied a nickel in the bottom of the hole. I then took it to my table saw and carefully "shaved" the end until it was a particular distance. I can set my gouge in my holder quite easily. This is for my Wolverine.
I can consistently sharpen any gouges to this particular angle using this.