Last night our Bluegrass Area Woodturners demo featured Ken Brooks and his treadle lathe. At the end we just had to try it out, which quickly turned into a Chinese fire drill. So Derrel Cone is pumping from the front while I try to make a cut, and John Keeton and B pope are offering advise! It was a very "educational" demo, and thank goodness for electric motors!
I remember at the WC gathering in GA back in 2006, some of us were trying to use a treadle lathe. Funny as heck...sort of like trying to rub your stomach and pat your head at the same time. At least you had some dedicated foot power and could concentrate on the cut!
In 1993, when I retired, I built a small spring pole lathe to use as a demonstration lathe at craft shows. Mine gave you three revolutions on the downstroke and it was fun when an experienced woodturner happened along and criticized the lathe. I just offered them an opportunity to turn on it. No one could. What I really found, however was using that springpole lathe was good for my tool control. It was significantly improved when I went back to the regular lathe.
If anyone is interested in building one, I can send you a PDF of the article on my lathe and how I built it. It was published in the third issue of More Woodturning, December 1996.
What your using is a spring pole lathe. A treadle lathe is easier to use because the wood turns the same direction all the time similar to what we use now. Spring pole lathes are challenging to use. I found that you need to sharpen your tools to a steeper or sharper angle. It cuts with less effort and leaves a better cut. When I demo with my spring pole lathe I get really tired of answering the question, I'll bet your leg gets tired.
I'm planning to convert my spring pole to a treadle lathe. I just simply goes faster and people enjoy seeing the turning more.
You can check out the video some students did of me working on the spring pole lathe and shaving horse.