Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

It was fun for me...(long)

Posts

It was fun for me...(long)

#1

Leo Cuellar

It was fun for me...(long)

Leo Cuellar

to build my own hollowing tools. I've been refining the shape of them over the past week, and I spent a couple of days making charcoal. Lots of fun, glad I'm rural! Made enough to fill a 55 gallon drum. Tonight I fired up a small forge (that a friend loaned me), for the first time. First I had to take the curve out of the metal done with an anvil constructed from a section of railroad rail. Back into the forge to harden, then quench & temper. The tools were made from 3/8" leaf spring steel that finishes out to 11/32".



I've seen pictures of Kelton's hollowers, but only from the top. I haven't seen what the grind actually looks like, so I've been sneaking up on what works. The middle one cuts mediocre, but does not catch, at all. The other 2 cut very well but will catch, but without disastrous results. The flat bottoms seem to help a great deal with control.My idea is that once I've got the bevel right I can just sharpen the top, like one of the Sorby Spindlemasters. Which is working well so far.



Since I've been on an eccentric kick lately (some would argue that I AM eccentric :D ) I made a three sided handle that fits my hand pretty well. I've got 2 more cocobolo blanks to do up tomorrow, but I'm going to make the ferrules longer this time.



I flattened out a couple of extra blanks for some shear scrapers to replace all of the file steel tools. I was surprised & pleased with how little charcoal it took to do this!

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#2

Different Grind

Doc Green

Leo, I've made numerous small hollowing tools from Allen wrenches and have found that a different shape for the cutting tip works best for me. This photo shows the basic shape.


Viewed from the top, the angle between the facets is very nearly 90 degrees. The sharp tip reduces the width of the cut to about 1/8" or less. The best cutting action occurs when the tip is moved into the wood in a direction parallel to one side of the tip. If you move the tool point first, straight into the wood, the width of the cut will increase as the tool advances, and you will soon get vibration, a grabbing action, and a very rough cut.

What I've found is that a round tip, as shown in your photos, takes a cut that is too wide. The result is vibration and chatter, which is not good.

The pointed tip is good for removing wood but it leaves a fairly rough surface unless you are very precise in moving the tool through the wood. For a finishing cut, a rounded tip is much better, but you must take a very light cut.

Obviously, the tool shown in my photo has not been given the final sharpening, which I do by simply grinding each facet. Also, for small work, I will grind most of the lower bevel away. The bevel angle where the cutting takes place is about 85 degrees, which is pretty steep. In use, the tools show no tendency to grab or catch.

Have fun! ~Doc

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#3

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

Terry Scott

You've had your fun know lets see what becomes of those bits of wood you have been saving

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#4

Steven Antonucci

Forging is almost as much fun as turning!

steven antonucci

Maybe even more ;)

If you hardened the entire length, I would recommend that you temper it. I wouldn't want the whole length to be hard (and brittle) because you run the risk of breaking the tool if you aren't careful (or you drop it). I would only harden the tip.

At that size, you don't even need a forge. I used to do it with a MAPP torch, since I only harden the cutting area and not the whole shaft. I also think that you'd want to avoid using files in general, as they have a lot of stress in them and easily break. I forge them into small knives instead!

Steve

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#5

Re: Forging is almost as much fun as turning!

John Lucas

Since I make my tools with round rod and install HSS cutters I just bend the rod by hand without heat. Keeps me from having to fire up the forge which in my case means hauling it outside along with the Anvil.

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#6

Leo Cuellar

Re: Different Grind

Leo Cuellar

Thank you Doc. I really appreciate the info. I'll definitely give that a try as I want to make some smaller ones as well. I'm also not completely married to my tip design either, just a thought I had to pursue after looking at others.

Leo

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#7

Leo Cuellar

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

Leo Cuellar

I'm getting to it! :D Next project is a Longworth chuck. Just found the information I needed. Then I'll be able to work on getting the bottoms right.

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#8

Leo Cuellar

Yes it is...

Leo Cuellar

Steve! I think I have more fun building the jigs, tooling, and incidentals than doing the actual project. The forge is a permanent loan from a buddy who never used it. He got a radial arm saw that I never used.

I only hardened & tempered the ends of the tools. I didn't want them brittle, and I thought I wanted to polish them up at some point in the future. That is a great idea for recycling the old tools, I've got some Bocote and Ziricote scraps that would make nice looking grips for knives. Although I've never had a file tool break... they do chatter during use and they would never handle these kinds of stresses which is reason enough to cycle them out.

Leo

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#9

Leo Cuellar

The one thing I forgot...

Leo Cuellar

John, was to get a bag of marshmallows to toast while I was waiting for the steel to heat :) My first tool was out of drill rod. which I heated and bent in the wrong direction. I had already ground it. So I bent it back the other direction. Of course I HAD to try it out right away so didn't anneal it and broke it. It was inside the hollow so it was completely unspectacular. I still do like your idea on this though and think that is just what I need for a heavy rough out tool. Have you ever tried a ball mill like Russ suggested in his articles?

Leo

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#10

Re: The one thing I forgot...

John Lucas

I have not tried the Ball mill or the modified drill bit yet. For hollowing inside vessels I don't see an advantage for me. It might work out well for vases and boxes where the inside finish is more critical.

Re: It was fun for me...(long)

#11

Leo Cuellar

Got 'em "handled" finally...

Leo Cuellar

actually it took me several days to remember to grab the SD card from my reader & put it back in the camera. :D

I did 3 different styles of 3 sided handles for the hollowers. Didn't go beyond a 150 grit finish as I will most likely be doing a little reshaping to fit my hands. The 2 with the larger ferrules were drilled out to 5/8" for most of the length and filled with #10 lead shot. This was reclaimed shot purchased at a small local sporting goods store for about half the price it was available anywhere else!