Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

"Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

Posts

"Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

#1

"Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

charlie belden

Theres a seven page article in the current (Oct, 2010) issue of American Woodturner titled "Sandpaper - The Nitty Gritty". We all end up sanding somewhere along the line - in my case EVERYWHERE along the line. And there have been many threads here and on other woodworking forums on what gritsto use, in what order, to what degree of fineness. Occassionally the questions like "CAMI vs FEPA sizes?" and "What's the P mean?" come up.

This article puts most of that information in one place - with plenty of comparison tables and even photos of results with different "papers" and "grits" with evaluations of those results. The author, Art Scott, spent a lot of time researching sanpaper and sorting out the Tower Of Babel of the terms and definitions used in the abrassives industry.

If you're a woodworker this article should probably be Required Reading. And if you want to know a LOT more about "sandpaper" - go to the link below, scroll down to "3M Handouts" and download at least the first two PDF files. And if you REALLY like details, download the Excel or Word files.


3M Abbrassives Handouts

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

#2

Joe Fleming

NM: "Sandpaper" Nice resources

Joe Fleming

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

#3

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue

Bill Neddow

I have not received my American Woodturner yet, but am pleased to hear about the article. I have spent about 10 years ferreting out information on sanding -- it has become a hobby. And, getting good sanding information is very hard. There are lots of opinions out there, but not much in the way of facts -- and the facts you do find are written for engineers with PhDs. It is great that so much information is being assembled in one place.

Those 3M documents you pointed us to are also great -- especially the CAMI 1 document. That should be essential reading for all woodworkers.

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue

Rob Wallace

I also enjoyed reading the article - I've been giving a presentation to woodworking clubs on this topic for a number of years, and Art Scott's article distills most of what I think is important for woodworkers to know, and communicates it clearly.

I do wish that the title of the article were just a bit more accurate - it should have preferably used 'coated abrasives' in the title as opposed to "sandpaper", since the "sandpaper" produced today really never uses 'sand' as the abrasive material; also, use of "paper" as a backing is restricted to a relatively small subset of the abrasive materials produced today. A nit to be picked, perhaps.

I disagree with some that have complained elsewhere that 7 pages is "too much space" to be devoted to this topic. I think the article was well written and well presented editorially, and deserves the space in American Woodturner.

Rob Wallace

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

#5

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue

john lucas

I agree with Bill and Rob. It's an interesting subject. I still have questions to answer when you change from "sandpaper" to other medium like Steel Wool and abrasive pads and polishing abrasives.

A good example is I've never found where the Green compound bars fit in an abrasive scale with the White,Red, Black and other colors. They use vague terms to describe what the bars are used for but not an actual abrasive grit size or hardness.

I also haven't found a good chart than compares steel wools to abrasive pads. The abrasive pads are listed by color but I've found they change if you buy "off brand" vs 3M.

I went through this same thing with Knife sharpening. As long as you stay with one brand or style of stone it's pretty straight forward. If your trying to compare oil stones to water stones and ceramic stones it gets pretty confusing. I resorted to using a microscope to look at the scratches and since I don't have a good one with reticles it was hard to compare.

Re: "Sandpaper" Article in Current Issue *LINK*

#6

Optical Loupe With Scale

charlie belden

John:

Most sewing stores will have a folding optical loupe that has a scale on it. Used to count threads in Warp & Woof (sp?). Camera stores also carry something similar. They're usually 10X power.