Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Bwaa-waa!

Posts

Bwaa-waa!

#1

Bwaa-waa!

Jorge Casta�eda


Sniff,

Rock maple 17" x 8", roughed it last night and this morning 3 mayor cracks and several small ones...

From a dead standing tree, cut and under cover 4 years.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#2

Re: Bwaa-waa!

Dick Coers

That major crack has the look of it already being in the wood. Standing dead can have those little "surprises". Too bad for you, sorry.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#3

What a Bummer !

Don Orr

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#4

Leo Cuellar

I feel your pain!

Leo Cuellar

My green wood turning experiment was a total loss, everything split no matter which method was used. I'm going to try patching a couple of the big ones with dovetail keys just for the heck of it though.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#5

Re: Bwaa-waa!

Fred Holder

Some Time back, several years I think, Wally Dickerman posted on using white glue and water to undo and seal cracks. I tried Wally's suggestion, three or four years ago on a 15-1/2 inch rough turned bowl that I had planned to make for a gift as a house warming present for a friend. When I went to final turn it, it had a couple of cracks like you bowl, one almost 3/8 inch wide. I soaked the bowl for two days and the cracks were still open. Disgusted I threw it on a pile of wood. A few days later I walked past the bowl and the cracks had closed up. I dried it some more and final turned it. The crack hasn't opened up again. It is worth a try.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#6

Rob Wallace

Been there, done that.....

Rob Wallace

.... numerous times.

This is just one of possibilities one must accept when working with green wood....

I usually call this kind of situation the making of a "practice bowl" to justify the time and effort put into it, since in the end, there will likely be no piece to show for your work..... Just don't "practice" too much!

Next blank!

Rob

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#7

Re: Bwaa-waa!

robo hippy

I have gotten a couple of trees that were dead standing, and noticed that bowls turned from them would crack very quickly compared to green trees. Also, the log sections when cut would do the same thing, almost over night, cracks clear through.

Maybe you should turn all the way, and don't leave it overnight.

robo hippy

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#8

Re: Bwaa-waa!

fgvanatta

Looks like a candidate for cutting out the crack with a bandsaw, smoothing the edges, inserting a contrasting strip of wood and/or veneer, then returning into a beautiful piece.

Frank

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#9

Re: Bwaa-waa!

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi Reed,

It felt dry and even dusty while turning, and by now the main crack is grown, almost split the bowl in half.

I have a commission to be delivered before the 12th and I have only one blank left, it is from another tree, but also dead standing I'll turn it to completion in one go, not even a brake.

I guess those old fellows have a lot of built in stress on them, having to compensate for enormous weights from huge branches.

That piece has lots of neat grain, now designer firewood.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#10

Next!

Jorge Casta�eda

Rob, you got the right idea, next!

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#11

Thank you all!!

Jorge Casta�eda

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#12

Re: Bwaa-waa!

j. paul fennell

Living in the desert with essentially 0% relative humidity, I've learned a few innovative tricks that may be of value to you. Whenever I rough turn a vessel (hollow form, mainly), I do two things:

(1) Coat the rough-turned form with medium CA glue. This minimizes any moisture loss through the outer surface. If it's a bowl, I'd coat the inner surface as well.

(2) Then, I place the piece in a clear plastic waste can liner, which is no more than 2 mils thick, tie it off and shelve the piece for several months. What you are doing is creating a miniature environment, so that any moisture loss is contained within the plastic bag. The moisture will escape the bag ever so slowly over time. If the piece distorts when losing mositure, it does so slowly, which I think lessens the tendency to crack. There are no guaratees, of course, but in the desert, where I live, salvaged wood is hard to come by, and worth all the extra effort as explained.

Now some may question the cost regarding using CA glue like this, but it's fairly inexpensive buying it in 16oz bottles from Starbond, and wood being hard to come by, this cost is reasonable for me.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#13

Re: Bwaa-waa!

robo hippy

Jorge,

You may want to sand and finish it at the same time as well.

robo hippy

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#14

Re: Bwaa-waa!

Jorge Casta�eda

Paul,

I live in an island in the Atlantic ocean, so my environs are the polar opposite of yours, moisture and high humidity most of the time.

Thanks for sharing your experience, I do coat pieces that I will not complete at once with lacquer sanding sealer, it stinks but it is fast and relatively inexpensive. Give it a try, it may be easier than the CA.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#15

Re: Bwaa-waa!

Jorge Casta�eda

Yes, of course.

Thank you.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#16

Wrap or coat the outside

David R Smith, Longview, WA

One of the things I discovered doing alcohol soaking research is wrapping the out side of a bowl nearly eliminates cracking. Paul coats the outside with CA glue. Wally has been applying paste wax to the outside for hollow forms and bowls for decades with great success. Even if you don't soak in alcohol, wrapping the outside with paper will induce the inside to dry faster than outside which puts the outside under compression and minimizing cracks.

I never assume a piece is dry and always soak a roughed out piece in alcohol and wrap it with paper. Wrapping or coating the outside of a bowl or hollow form is a small price to pay for insurance against cracks.

Dave Smith

Rain is getting colder, winter is not far off in Longview, WA.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#17

Re: Wrap or coat the outside

John Lucas

Thanks Dave I'll have to look at that as an option. I have had good success this last year by coating the endgrain portions both inside and out with endgrain sealer. They are stacked on the floor of my shop in a corner so they don't get much air movement.

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#18

Re: Wrap or coat the outside

robo hippy

While I don't do the DNA soak, I do LDD (liquid dishwashing detergent) soak. I was doing the paper wrap on the outside of the bowl, and found that to be superior to paper bagging. I started using the stretch plastic film to secure the paper to the rim of the bowl, which worked better than the tape. I eventually went to just the plastic film on the rim. Stretch it out so there is some compression on the rim, and I have almost 100% success, even with madrone with knots in it. This is on finish turned green bowls. Haven't ever experimented with twice turned/thick turned bowls though. Oh, yes, very important to round over the edges of the bowl rim.

robo hippy

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#19

Re: Wrap or coat the outside

Bill Howatt

I Anchorseal the outside end-grain portion of my bowls and leave the inside alone. I used to do in and out but it didn't work any better from my experience and took longer to dry.

Bill

Re: Bwaa-waa!

#20

Re: Wrap or coat the outside

Paul Singer

I also just coat the end grain on the outside only. This is the way Bill Grumbine shows it in his DVD's and it has worked well for me so far.