Managed to get most of the damaged wood out with a recip saw, and now I am on to the bigger problem, which is 'where is that water coming from?"
I put the ladder up on the chimney, and pulled out a bunch of ferns and small birch trees that were growing out of the side of the chimney (don't know why). Some of the silicon was shot, so I removed and slathered it with some new stuff. Still getting a little wet inside where the wood attaches to the chimney.
Any great ideas? I am trying to avoid having a large slug trail on the chimney...
"...pulled out a bunch of ferns and small birch trees that were growing out of the side of the chimney (don't know why)."
I'd bet that's a water incursion point. If it's a wood-clad chimney, the wood's probably rotten; and the wood got rotten because there was some failure to detail the area properly. If it's a brick chimney, your mortar joints aren't shedding water, have probably failed, and dirt has built up, establishing a wee garden there. Either way, I bet water's been getting in.
I'm always surprised by how many builders don't understand water control in building. My son reports to me regularly on construction details/decisions made by past builders that he is now repairing, and you have to conclude that some folks shouldn't be issued hammers.
I remember reading, years ago, that the trick is to think like a drop of water; and the associated idea is that ALL your exterior detailing should be designed to encourage the water to flow out, away from the wall.
Coupled with this, caulk is a supplemental line of protection to good detailing, NOT the solution. This is my major objection to modern nail-fin windows, which depend pretty well exclusively on caulk when installed by most carpenters (secondarily, I think they're ugly as day-old sin, but that's another conversation).
I agree: offer us some pictures, if you've got a digital camera. It may help identify the problem; although some water-shedding details (or water-encouraging details) are hard to capture in a two-dimensional photo.
Separate wood from masonry with sheet metal, aluminum, tar paper, or basement sealer. Flashings need to be made water-tight. Overlapping metal flashings should have a slicon or rubber caulking between them. I wish you well. Leaks can be very frustrating to locate and fix.
I agree with the others that this is nearly impossible without seeing it or at least good pictures.
Keep in mind that the water almost MUST be coming from above. I would check the top of the chimney and see if the cap or coping is in good shape. The interior of chimneys is supposed to be "solid" masonry, but a mason's idea of solid is somewhat different than mine. If water gets in the top it is pretty much free to run down the interior through a jumble of masonry and some out most anywhere.
Here is a shot of the inside, where you can see the 2x6 and how it interfaces with the internals. I removed all of the old spray foam down to bare wood/brick. There was some insulation in there, so I am pretty sure I got it all. I reapplied Great Stuff , and cut it down to what you see. I'll trim it a bit more before staining it to minimize it's appearance.
On the outside, it's harder to see, but the sunroom is aluminum and there is a "wrap" around the 2x6. The 2x6 sits against the brick, and there is silicon against the interface of the aluminum flashed wood and the brick. Not sure if the leak is coming from behind the silicon or through the bricks/mortar.
It's raining today, and if you look closely i the first picture, you can see the bricks are wet on the inside, but it doesn't appear that they are wet all the way up, which leads me to believe its in that interface and about that height...
if the brick is wet on the inside, your leak is at that height or above. Water can sneak around in multiple ways before surfacing, but most always downward.
How's your roof/chimney flashing doing?
Great stuff is good for air infiltration, but it's not a water excluder: it's open-cell foam, and will get wet.
I'll keep thinking.
You might consider drawing a deep breath and calling around to find a good remodel/repair contractor and spending actual money. Your situation looks moderately complicated.
I think I will do two more things to hopefull resolve the issue:
1.) Make the giant slug trail on the side of the chimney where the brick meets the sunroom. If it stops the water from coming in, then I have a mechanical solution to the water issue.
2.) Soak the chimney in water sealer. Same as above. Both are geared at isolating the cause of the water.
I have already been told that the brick needs to be repointed, and I suspected it wasn't an honest contractor. Perhaps they were after all, but chasing the water issue down will only cost me one more day and almost nothing $$$ since I have the stuff to do it. If it doesn't work, then I hire someone...