Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Spalted maple bowl

Posts

Spalted maple bowl

#1

Steve Kubien

Spalted maple bowl

Steve Kubien

Just over 12" x 4". Originally I could not get a decent cut on this so I tossed it aside. The tearout was over 1/16" deep! A month or two later I put it back on the lathe and accidently turned it on when the speed was up around 2000rpm. That is way faster than I would normally go and scared the stuff outta me. Weird thing was, there was NO vibration in the lathe. Zero. So, faceshield firmly in place I had at it.

When I was done I started sanding at 220 grit. Amazing.

Let me know what you think.


Re: Spalted maple bowl

#2

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Barry L Elder

Methinks you have learned a secret that many of the old pros have learned: Speed kills! Either the bowl or the problem is killed!

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#3

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Lynn Taylor

Thanks for the tip. I will try speed on the several set aside bowls with tear out.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#4

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Jorge Casta�eda

And sometimes the turner...

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#5

Re: Tearout varies greatly .....

JamieDonaldson

... with the moisture content of the wood, as well as speed and a few variables, including the turner! :D

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#6

A famous turner replied when asked

Ray - Middletown, IN

how fast do you turn. Speed it up until it scares you then back it off 10 RPM. I think it was Batty or Mahoney but darned if I can remember which.

Ray

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#7

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Terry Scott

Hi Steve Nice shape

My way of turning is if there is vibration I turn up the speed until I find the sweet spot

There is a word for it but slipped out of the computer for know

Some of you that have seen me turn my winged vessels take a step back ,I find the faster I turn the better the cut especially on our softer timbers like kauri

About 1800 to 2000 is the norm for a bowl spindle work right on the top knotch on the Stubbies dial

Just make sure you are never in the throw zone as if something comes apart it happens fast

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#8

Steve Kubien

Jamie, you are so right

Steve Kubien

I have no doubt that lots of you could have gotten a silky smooth surface by spinning this piece at 100rpms but not me. This piece was REALLY dry and was a little soft to. I'm not sure I want to turn this way all the time because it can be un-nervingbut it's nice to know I can to it without killing myself.

Cheers.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Steve Kubien

Right you are. I was apprehensive about this but I made sure I was out of the direct line of fire. Yup, I know bad things can happen and flying wood may not respect "line of fire". As I said elsewhere, I won't be doing this on every piece but it is nice to know it is in my bag-o-tricks if need arises.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#10

Steve Kubien

Yabut Terry...

Steve Kubien

...we already know you are nuts. Brilliant, of course, but.... :D :D :D

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#11

Re: Spalted maple bowl

john lucas

Steve I used to turn much slower than most turners. Scared of what could happen I guess. Over the last 5 years I've been experimenting a lot with how well a tool cuts. During that time I've noticed that I am turning at faster speeds than I used to.

I think it's simply because I have been turning a lot more. Consequently I'm more comfortable with the lathe, reading the wood, and better tool control. I've had only one piece blow up in that time. Fortunately it followed the proper trajectory of line of fire and I was standing out of it. You can't do that all the time. To really see the shape of a piece you have to look at it from side and in that case I'm directly in the line of fire. Usually by the time I'm at that stage the I'm taking really light cuts and the piece has already been subjected to the harder cuts so I feel at least reasonably safe.

I like the shapes of your last 2 bowls. I cut up a blank last night so that I can do one similar. I probably won't get around to roughing it out for several weeks but I do plan to do it.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#12

Re: A famous turner replied when asked

Doug Trembath

I seem to recall David Ellsworth saying in an interview with FWW magazine decades ago, that as soon as he got on a lathe he turned it up as fast as it would go. Memory is never as it should be, but that's my recollection.

I believe that the faster you go, the smaller the bite taken by the gouge, which in spalted or punky wood especially, reduces the opportunity to pull the grain. The orientation of the edge to the wood also makes a dramatic difference in the quality of the cut.

Nice bowl, and even nicer to realize your capabilities are stronger than you thought. Don't get real cocky, though, and as others have said, stay out of the throw zone...

Doug Trembath

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Keith Tompkins

Nice work Steve. Speed can make a dramatic difference....try this: sand a bowl with 80 grit at your slowest speed, and look at the results. Then, speed up the lathe, and sand with thd same grit...much finer finish. I feel it's the same with cutting, faster speed CAN make a cleaner cut. Sharpness and presentation are important as well. BTW, same effect on tool grinding....higher speed with the same grit stone results in a finer finish, and a better cutting tool. (just my opinion)

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#14

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Lyle Jamieson

I teach turning at the highest speed possible. Faster is better. There are rules to keep you safe, like holding methods, that need to be followed no matter what speed you turn at. But sanding is a different ball game. I want to s l o w the speed way down to sand. Sanding fast just skips over the surface without cutting cleanly. It will take a lot more time and effort to sand at high speeds. Sanding generates heat, not good!! Sanding fast will make the sandpaper dull in a flash. Add up dull sandpaper with excessive heat and you have burnished the surface of the wood. Not good!! I want to cut cleanly with sharp sandpaper at a slow, cool, speed.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#15

Steve Kubien

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Steve Kubien

Lyle, what about the speed of the sanding disc? How fast are you spinning that? I use a variable speed drill and I am guessing I usually have it around 800-1000rpms (strictly a guess) and the lathe at either 200 or 350 rpm.

I know there are differing viewpoints on sanding speed from people I respect a great deal (yourself and Bill Neddow in particular) and I do like to hear them out.

Cheers,

Steve

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Keith Tompkins

Hi Lyle, I didn't mean to imply that we should sand at high speed, I just wanted to show the effect speed can have on the surface. At a crawl, 80 grit will tear the surface, while at a higher speed, it's much smoother.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#17

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Lyle Jamieson

I use a variable speed drill for sanding disks. And feather at slow speed for both the lathe and the drill. Also very important...I only use the drill and disks for course grits only. Any sanding higher then 220 I do by hand held sandpaper with the lathe slow. Can you imagine a 600 grit piece of sandpaper on the drill?? About 5 revolutions of the drill and the paper is toast. From that point on the dull paper is heating up and burnishing the surface. How many of you have melted the velcro backing?? You end up with a blotchy finish no matter what you put on it after that damage.

Vince Welch from vinceswoodnwonders.com did a sanding demo at the IndyFest. He is very well versed in sandpaper. I learned a lot from his talk. He showed the sweet spot of sanding that can be found. When the speed is just right you can feel the "pull" against the grit to show you are cutting and not just skipping by the wood inefficiently. That sweet spot you will find at a very low speed and changes as the grit changes.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Lyle Jamieson

Im not taking your comments personally, I hope you can do the same. I have not used 80 grit for many years. And that is a whole new topic in using sharp tools and good techniques. The courser grits are over kill and do more damage then they help. I saw a guy once shaping his platter with 17 grit on a auto body sander, so there are a lot of different ways to get the job done. With 80 grit at high speeds the sandpaper is dull very quickly and will not cut very efficiently when it is dull. So my guess is that is why you had better luck at the fast speed. The sandpaper was not cutting. Then the next grit has to work harder to clean up all the damage done with dull sandpaper and the cycle repeats itself. At whatever speed you want to sand, the key is to use sharp sandpaper.

Re: Spalted maple bowl

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Spalted maple bowl

Keith Tompkins

Hi Lyle, Nothing personal at all....I don't use coarse sandpaper at all, just using it as an example of how speed affects results. I agree with you completely....high speed will burnish a surface, and overheat and distort it. Maybe I used a bad analogy?