Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Almost had a fire in the shop today

Posts

Almost had a fire in the shop today

#1

Almost had a fire in the shop today

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Today I was well into day two of a three day class. We were working on the Robust and using the Moffat lamp to illuminate the bowl I was turning to illustrate the process for a natural edge piece. I smelled the faintest whiff of smoke. At first, I figured it was just my neighbor trying to burn his trash in the rain again. We can get smoke drifting by even though he is several hundred yards away. But the smell got stronger, and I looked up at my Moffat light, just as my student was telling me he saw smoke coming out of it!

I turned the light to see what I could see, and several decent sized chunks of glowing shavings dropped out and into the pile under the lathe! :O I started stomping on them, and hollered for my student to grab the fire extinguisher. He found it and had it over by the lathe in seconds. It turned out that I did not need it, but if those shavings had caught up and it would not have been there, I would be writing about how my shop turned into a smoking ruin this afternoon.

We stopped turning long enough to clear the shavings from the shop, putting them in my little shaving wagon outside the door. I don't know how many people here have seen shavings burn, but it is spectacular. I use them to start the fire in my wood furnace. They catch up almost immediately into a roaring fire. Big feet and the grace of God saved the day. I can safely say though, that I was glad for the fire extinguisher just in case stomping them out hadn't worked.

I have been using these Moffat lights for about seven or eight years now, and have never had a shaving catch on fire like that. But I have always had a fire extinguisher in the shop. I wonder, can everyone else here say the same? Are you prepared for something like this in your own shop? What will you do if your shavings pile catches on fire, or anything else for that matter? It is something to think about.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#2

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Nick Tuzzolino

Yes, Bill, I have three extinguishers in my shop and one in the lathe room.. Also, the BEST fire extinguisher you can have is to have a hooked up garden hose (with a good nozzle) adjacent. Even a hose in the shop is great. This is actually a legal and acceptable class A fire extinguisher in most locales.

I'm happy your problem was solved so easily.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#3

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Dan Oliphant

I must admit that I too have had chips start to burn in my moffit light, so now I make sure to blow out the fixture often while turning.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#4

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

john lucas

Bill I've had shavings start smoking in my Moffet lamps. Never anything serious but it did make me conscious of the danger so I blow them out often and of course never leave them on when I'm not nearby.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#5

Mike Stafford

I am wondering....

Mike Stafford

if you had the grill shields over the opening to the bulb like I have on my Moffatts? Shavings don't seen to make it past the clip on grills.

I am glad nothing disastrous happened and we all can learn from your experience by making sure we have a fire extinguisher in the shop. It is not enough to just have one; you also need to maintain it according to directions.

I think I will add another so that I have one on both sides of the shop....

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#6

Rob Wallace

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Rob Wallace

I've had shavings start to "smell" like they're burning in my lathe's Moffat light, but never any smoke or glowing shavings. Decided then this might be a future problem, so....

I have switched to daylight spectrum compact fluorescent bulbs (100 watt equivalent) and they do not generate anywhere near the heat that standard incandescent bulbs do.

I recommend trying CF bulbs, if only for the piece of mind that you hopefully will never again have an incident like the one you just went through...

Glad it worked out OK for you Bill. I just glanced at my shop's fire extinguisher - it's there and ready, but hopefully never needed....

Rob

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#7

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

From personnal experience a 2.5# extinguisher is not big enough to stop a real fire. I put out a parts washer fire with a 10#. It poofed its last as the fire poofed out. Do not let false economy cost you your shop. REMEMBER ANY PARTIALLY USED EXTINGUISHER MUST BE RECHARGED! The powder in the valve causes it to slowly leak down. Thanks that Five Barns is still there.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#8

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Rob: Do your CFLs create a strobe effect and "stop" the action of the lathe?

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Steve Kubien

Glad to hear nothing serious happened other than a raising of your blood pressure. I have a hose in my shop and enough length to run from back to front and back again. The tap is about 3 feet from the headstock.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#10

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Jeff Willaford

Good save, Bill. My feet aren't as big as yours so I best double check my extinguisher.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#11

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Nick, I would love to have a hose in, or even near the shop. The closest water source is the frost free faucet, which is over 100' away, downhill, and across the parking space. There is no practical way to run a hose out there, and underground plumbing would be impossible.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#12

Re: I am wondering....

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Mike, the grills are always on, if only to keep pieces from coming up and hitting the bulbs.

I agree completely with keeping them maintained. I was uncomfortable when I was without one for just a few days, when we used the one in the shop to put out a fire on my tractor (son-in-law doing some welding for me). The current extinguisher is a huge CO2 item.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#13

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Bill, the one I have in the shop right now is big enough to put you out if you caught on fire! :b

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#14

Rob Wallace

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Rob Wallace

Bill (T.) -

I don't perceive any strobe effect with the CF bulbs. I have one on my Jet 1642, and also in the Moffat lights I use for my "traveling" lathes (Jet Mini and Jet 1220). I've never seen a strobing problem with CFs in any of these, throughout the various rpm ranges on all of them.

In contrast to magnetic-ballasted fluorescents (operating at about 120 Hz), CFs use electronic ballasts that operate around 30-40 kHz. As far as I understand it, finding harmonic frequencies at typical lathe operating speeds that would "stop" the motion of the lathe (=strobe effect) should be kind of difficult with electronic ballasted bulbs, but would be quite easy with magnetic ballasted tubes (120 Hz has many harmonics that extend through the 0-2500 rpm speeds of a typical wood lathe) which is why they are not recommended for use above the wood lathe. I'll have to dig out my variable strobe light and see if I can replicate any harmonic points on the lathe that would replicate a strobe effect situation if 30-40kHz rates are simulated.

Hope this helps...

Rob

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#15

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Reed Gray

It is habit for me to blow out the Moffat lamp whenever I am turning, especially if the wood is dry, which is unusual for me. It isn't the chips that go up inside the lamp that start to smoke, mostly it seems to be the ones that land on top. I do, now use the energy saving type curly bulbs. They are just as bright, last a lot longer, and don't generate the heat. I have 2 fire extinguishers in my 24 by 36 shop. Never really thought about the hose, but have a high pressure one about 25 feet from the door.

robo hippy

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#16

Steven Antonucci

can u change to CFC bulbs

steven antonucci

They don't get anywhere near as hot.

Just another way to reduce risk. My lathe light is a driveway floodlamp and it gets hot enough that I can't stand within 2 feet of it (not to mention that it blocks the light and defeats the purpose)...

When the little 300w torchiere lamps were all the rage, I used to get a nutty burning smell a couple of times per year. I'd go over and flick what was left of the bug that 'flew into the light'...

S

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#17

CF bulbs not always safe

Carole Valentine

I walked into my living room one night and smelled the acrid smoke of an electrical fire...scared me to death. Realized it was coming from the lamp by my chair. Threw the wall switch to off and checked...this is what I found. Apparently a defective bulb? Got hot enough to melt some of the glass and other parts.


Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#18

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

woodenleg

I have 2 FE's in my shop and have never used them but I have them checked every other year by a local fire saftey bus. I started this when my friends shop burned down and his insurance com. would not reimburse because the FE's were not checked regular. It costs about $20. for two. I also bought a fire can to put rags in.

IT's cheap insurance.

Dave

P.S. Make sure the FE's that you buy can be recharged, most plastic heads can not.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#19

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Ralph E Watts

I was worried about my lighting starting a fire because the glass cover shattered after some wet wood spray gave it a shock. I then stumbled across LED lights at SAMS club and promptly replaced my lathe light with one of them. They cost about $15 bucks but run very cool all the time and the light is brighter than incandescent or CFL. You can get spots or flood but the spot works for me. It even work as a see through light for very thin turnings. Highly recommended... Best regards, Ralph

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#20

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Interesting about a fire extinguisher.

I have a master switch near the door that kills everything electrically and then I have a bucket of water and a watering can outside for any emergencies!

In winter they go inside!

Glad you caught it quickly!

Regards Peter.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#21

Dick Hines

Re: CF bulbs not always safe

Dick Hines

Those are supposed to save the polar bears not burn your house down.

I just use the panters lamps. There is nothing to catch the shavings.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#22

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

Nick Tuzzolino

I wasn't thinking, Bill. I am in So Calif and never considered your location and climate.. Good luck in the future.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#23

Mike Stafford

That's a big fire extinguisher!!!!!

Mike Stafford


Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#24

Mike Stafford

Now your shop is contaminated with mercury....

Mike Stafford

You can expect a visit from the EPA..... :b

Has anyone tried any LED lamps. I happened across some on sale (nearly $20) and thought I would give them a try. Supposedly good for 50,000 hours....I hope I have that many hours left.

Re: Almost had a fire in the shop today

#25

Happened to me once...

Jack Savona

...when some of my shavings lodged by the open bulb in my 'magnifier light' from my old desk lamp and dropped embers into the pile of shavings on the floor. Fortunately I caught the smoldering shavings while I was still turning. Scared the **** out of me. Changed the bare light for a covered BBQ light.

My "studio" is in my basement. So I have a smoke alarm right above my lathe and another one at the top of the cellar stairs. Got an extinguisher and sink hose nearby, too.

Shavings are so ripe for fire. Lots of oxygen for a quick burn. Hope you all evaluate your own special situation so no fire accident can happen (and that includes used rags and paper towels).

Glad you were there to catch yours, Bill. Glad I was there to catch mine, too.