When turning the pens shown in my last post, I noticed that my barrels were spinning true on the left side of my lathe, but had a slight hop on the right side. Last night in the shop I figured out why. The live center that came with my lathe does not spin true. When rotated by hand the center point makes a clearly visible circle in the air. So any suggestions for a quality live center? I prefer to buy things just once when possible, so I'm looking for quality over economy.
Searching the archives, I see several votes for the Nova set, has anything else come along that would be a superior choice?
I use the One Way live centre with the 60 deg cone point made specifically for turning pens.
Mandrel rod replacements are inexpensive as well, I change mine out as soon as I see a wobble or flex. Also when turning a pen I like to loosen my set up and rotate the blanks 90 degrees or so then re tighten, I can tell right away when I turn the lathe back on if I am out of round or not and use that as a guide to measure if my set up is true or not.
Thanks for the suggestion. While turning the pens, I kept loosening the tailstock, loosening the nut, and trying to reset, but the wobble wouldn't go away. I don't know why I didn't check the live center then, but I thought about it last night and went out to check. Sure enough. I'll double check the mandrel rod tonight as well.
If you can remove the mounting rod from your pen mandrel, one of the easiest ways to test it for bends, etc. is to simply roll it on a very flat counter top or a piece of glass. Anything out of true will be immediately apparent. I replaced one several years ago after testing the rod for run-out and bends in this manner.
I second the OneWay Live Center as I have one also. Also had a OneWay livecenter when I owned a Nova lathe (got oneway 2436 now). As mentioned Oneway makes a special point to go into their livecenter that is made of steel instead of aluminum, you pop these out of the center with the supplied rod that comes with the center and it will also be supplied with the aluminum pin, and a inside and outside aluminum cone's that screw on for other work. You'll have to go to the Oneway site to order the special steel pin. As the rods that are used in the pen mandrels are steel you'll soon ruin the aluminum pin that comes with the live center so buy the steel one and use it for steel mandrel contact and switch to the aluminum if you want when it will engage wood.
Also and this may also be your problem or part of it now.....
Some mandrels are not drill deep enough in the end and your livecenter pin hits bottom with just the sharp point, in other words the sloping side of the pin does NOT touch the sides of the mandrel slope. When this happens you can take a small drill bit and drill deeper into the mandrels recess at that end so the pin point doesn't hit first. You want the sides of the slopes, mandrel and pin, to engage each other not bottom out.
Ken what Rob said reminded me so something else that is commonly done.
That is over tightening the tailstock on pen mandrels and bending them sometimes not a permanent bend but one that is there until pressure is released.
After making sure pen isn't bottoming out in the end of the mandrel alway tighten the tailstock this way.......
Make sure the tailstock is locked down then advance the livecenter into the end of the mandrel and just before the two slopes make contact move that end of the mandrel back and forth slightly and keep doing that while you move the pin into the end of the mandrel. As soon as the sides of the slope engage and you cannot move the mandrel back and forth that is where you stop and lock the quill in tailstock.
Point is that is where the livecenter will hold the mandrel steady BUT not put pressure on mandrel towards the headstock.
Thanks for all the tips and suggestions. I just ordered the oneway live center with the pen turning tip. I'll also check the mandrel shaft before I turn the next run of pens.
I think a more accurate way to check if the mandrel is straight, is to spin it on the lathe without any pen parts. I bring up a pencil and let it lightly kiss the spinning mandrel. I tap it on the pencil mark, and spin again. You can get it within a couple thousandths this way. Also square pen blank ends is a primary concern. Just slightly off on the ends, will bow the mandrel when you tighten it up. If that is just slightly off, you can loosen the nut and rotate one of the blanks. You might be able to cancel the runout that way. The supreme way to turn accurate parts is to not use a mandrel at all. You can buy special bushings on the IAP site that let you turn one blank at a time. No bending or runout at all with that system. Here's a link to one of the members of the IAP who sells the bushings
Penn State offers a new product they call a mandrel saver. In short, it eliminates the live center in favor of a morse taper with a thru-hole the mandrel runs through. Instead of snugging up on the end of the mandrel causing possible bending of the mandrel, the pressure is on the bushings and the resulting force is transferred to the headstock.
I just received one and have used it on just two pens, but already am sold on the product. No more bent mandrels from jamming the tailstock tight.
Available in #1 and #2 MT Seems to be 7mm only, though. If you use Berea's "B" size mandrel, the Mandrel Saver will not work on this.
It would be very easy to build an adaptor for my Nova Live center that would work just like that. Turn a short #2 morse taper to fit the Nova center. Place this in your headstock #2 taper and center drill it to fit your mandrel. Taper the outside to whatever design you like and your done. You could make it out of brass, plastic, wood or aluminum. That's why I'm such a fan of the Nova Live centers.