Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT new woodturners forum

Posts

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#26

Re: OT new woodturners forum

Nick Todd

I would be glad to address this question on the other forum. Fill free to post this question their. This question will also be addressed in our resently asked questions post some time tomorrow.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#27

Ellis Walentine

E-mail addresses and privacy

Ellis Walentine

John, you are not required to show your e-mail in your posts, but only registered members are able to see posted addresses. I don't share addresses with anyone, and unless you post your e-mail in your message, even web bots won't find it.

This may be a case of one of our registered members manually going down the page and copying addresses. That would be very troubling to me.

Ellis Walentine

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#28

Re: E-mail addresses and privacy

Sean Troy

i would think e-mail addresses were gathered from the AAW member book?

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#29

Re: E-mail addresses and privacy

JohnKyler

Sean,

You may be correct with that. I just dont like people signing me up for for something... They did'nt email inviting me, just that I had been signed up already. And to keep telling people to come over to my site and I will answer you is wrong IMHO.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#30

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Thanks Stuart,

It will be nice to see through the fog and read some clear thoughts in an appropriate place on the matter.

take care,

Jim

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#31

  Did you just call me a weenie?

George Guadiane

:D

You can post a LINK to a picture of your OT Birthday Present.

(just a thought)

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#32

Please Ignore Me If

George Guadiane

you don't agree...

I don't know if anyone asked permission to make the original post of this thread (that would have been nice).

I don't see a problem here, in the grander scheme of things reaching out to a larger community who might be interested in conversing about the politics of AAW, something that is not really allowed on that site (or this one, for that matter).

I have been to the site, and have not felt a burning need to add anything at this point, mostly because I think we are too few in numbers and not well enough organized nor represented in terms of what would be good for woodturners in that organization.

Whether you agree with their/our/my views isn't really relevant, what is important (in my mind) is that there is a place where people can say what they believe without fear of being banned from other aspects of the site.

As to the self identity thing; If you are not proud enough to put your name on it, don't say it?

In the end, that site may not be of significant value till the next culture clash/social uprising/political conflagration... I feel comfortable saying that one of those is pretty much inevitable, based on the "changes" being offered so far.

In the mean time, it's good to know that freedom of speech lives.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#33

Re: Please Ignore Me If

Russ Fairfield

I tried to answer a question on their site that would have some interest to the greater readership, but I have been unable to get permission on posting anything yet. I sent my answer to the writer of the original suggestion about the AAW Journal and asked them to do that for me if they though the answer was worthwhile.

I hope that time will prove me wrong with my conclusion that they only want to hear from those whose messages they want to hear.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#34

I Hope You're Wrong Too!

George Guadiane

On the one hand, on the other, you might consider that "your side" already has all of the AAW site to romp on.

(That was intended as a JOKE)

I hope that you hear back and manage to have a voice on that site... If one is going to engage in arguments, one should engage with those that present a challenge. You do that.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#35

Re: Please correct your e-mail address, Juergen

Juergen

It's corrected! Interesting, the my Email is correct in "My Profile" however the Email address in the "Preferences" section had a typo. It might be useful to have a cross check here, or is the intention to permit multiple email addresses?

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#36

Re: OT new woodturners forum

charlie belden

Stuart Johnson wrote:

"IMHO AAW's forum is the place to discuss AAW politics.

It would be nice but the last time this was tried the forum administrator removed all threads and postings. Real criticism or dissent of the BOD or their policies is not allowed to continue on the AAW forum. "

I followed that "discussion" in the AAW forum and I believe most reasonable folks who followed the "discussion" would agree it got just a teeny tiny itty bitty bit WAY OUT OF HAND. Speculation, accusations and rumors were flying everywhere. Folks were questioning other's ancestry, their ethics, honesty, forthrightness, legitamacy and apparently there were some unsolicited an "unpleasant" e-mails sent to folks. And this went on for two or three weeks or more and deteriorated into almost junior hight school play ground behavior, and a host of Conspiracy Theories that even the X-Files writers wouldn't have come up with flew about like shrapnel on Shock And Awe Night in Bahgad. Long standing friendships were destroyed or severly strained.

At some point, a forum moderator is charged with stopping Flame Wars - and IMHO - the moderator bent over backwards to let the "discussion" run its course. But when the normal rules of behavior spelled out in the forum's rules were being violated severly - he finally took some action and had to delete some posts.

As for all traces of the "discussion" disappearing, I believe the moderator posted that all posts that met the Rules of Behavior criteria would be archived and available for review by members - but no additional posts would be taken.

To state or imply that criticism of the AAW BOD was not, and is not, permitted is, at best, a tad misleading.

It's easy to be AGAINST something. A bit more work to come up with things you're FOR and even rarer, to have the diplomatic and statesmanship to cause them to happen.

Personally, after observing the current BOD being pilloried - I can't understand why ANYONE would want to be a board member.

I trust you've sent in your ballot for the upcoming Board Elections and have actively campaigned for you chosen candidates.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#37

Re: OT new woodturners forum

Stuart Johnson

Charlie,

I agree things got out of hand and maybe more than just a bit. I would have no problem with the forum administrator locking all of the threads but I do oppose the removal. Many of the deleted threads started off very well and then moved into ugly accusations. In my opinion a good administrator would have locked each thread once it got out of hand. Much has been lost, not so much the content but the demeanor of those posting. My respect for some on both sides has dropped based on how they responded.

You asked if I have cast my ballot yet. The answer is no. I have selected one candidate, ruled out one and still undecided on two. Being able to search the forum to see how they handled any postings regarding the issues would be helpful.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#38

Ellis Walentine

No cross check

Ellis Walentine

The e-mail address field in the message form is for you to put whatever address you want other registered users to see when they prowl the boards. In fact, you can leave it blank if you prefer. Each time you post or preview a message, a new cookie is set (for that board only) that records the new e-mail preference. As long as you still have your profile intact, you will be accorded all the privileges and abilities of registered members, regardless of what e-mail you use to post.

I know it sounds tricky, but it's pretty straightforward.

Ellis

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#39

Re: OT new woodturners forum

John Lucas

I'm still going to read posts on the site for a while and try to contribute when I can but from reading the other posts I got the distict impression that if you post anything pro AAW you will get flamed so I may not stay there long.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#40

Re: OT new woodturners forum

Stuart Johnson

John, a major effort is underway to try and tone down things a bit. I think there has been a bunch of frustration type venting. Hopefully that is done and now maybe some constructive work can begin.

Re: OT new woodturners forum

#41

Re: OT new woodturners forum

john lucas

Stuart I got that impression today when I was there. I will try to be constructive as well. It doesn't do anyone any good to continue the battle.