It all was going fairly well: I was able to turn the piece between centers by first attaching a square piece of MDF to the top of the log. However, because of the corners of the MDF piece attached to the log by screws I could not turn the outside completely between centers. So I removed the MDF, cut the corners of the log with a hacksaw, put the piece into a chuck and tried turning it. As soon as I put the gouge to the log - BOOM! - one of the "shoulders" went flying about 10 feet across the shop and landed about a feet or two from a couple of people taking a woodworking class!
So I am not sure whether I feel sad about the piece blowing up or extremely lucky that I did not kill anyone. I guess both...
Well, the time I spent on this piece was not totally wasted. I think the main thing I learned is that the void in the middle must be much smaller relative to the diameter of the log to be able to turn it safely in a chuck. Plus I made some shavings...
On pieces like this you need to do a lot more shaping with a bandsaw, chainsaw, or whatever before putting it on the lathe. Then you need to figure out how to keep the tailstock engaged while turning those sharp edges. Think hot melt glue - I use it on Australian burl caps all the time.
Looks like the bottom can still be salvaged, though . . .
Wow Thanks for posting. I've always wanted to turn one of those. I do seem them from time to time when people are trimming the trees around here. Now I know that If I do I will have to make extra plans for safety sake.
My thoughts would be to figure out what will be the waste area of the top of the vessel. Then screw, glue, or somehow fasten a wasteblock to this. That will let you use the tailstock to turn the outside and will hopefully keep the forces from ripping the U shape of the inside apart. Might even consider using a chainsaw, grinder, or bandsaw to rough shape the outside to reduce these forces.
when the outside is done wrap it with stiff wire that forms a circle and hot glue this in place. This will allow you to turn the inside. I've done that on a smaller scale where the piece needed to have 2 sides missing and was very thin. It worked very well. With heavier gauge wire and more rings than I used it could be done on that scale.
Another thought would be to true up the flat sides before you start and glue on some boards with the grain running sideways across the opening. They would have to be thick enough that you would not turn through them while hollowing. This would make the outside easier to turn and would hold the wood together for turning the inside. Then you could remove these later. I think a good paper joint would hold it and would make the wood scraps easier to remove when your done. Of course it would require some care when flattening the surfaces. You could possibly hot glue the scraps on which would fill a poorly fitted joint but personally I trust the paper joint over the hot glue. Maybe because I simply haven't used that much hot glue where structural security was a necessity.
Just my thoughts. My brain won't shut up this morning and is going 100mph.
I am not sure whether there is any way to turn the outside complete between centers while having a waste block attached to the top with screws. Glue maybe, but I am not sure glue would be strong enough. If you use screws, they will have to be attached to the corners of the log that sooner or later would have to be removed, and I don't see how you can do it while still having the piece between centers.
Well, some food for thought definitely. I do have another similar log in my collection so I might give this another try.
Thanks for sharing. I'm glad you & everybody else are OK. It looks like you might yet be able to get a few fine pieces out of that still. I'm trying to work out some attachment issues with off center work. I've been wondering if I should reposition my lathe before I bolt it down. My wood stove and french doors are potential targets right now. Fortunately I don't have to worry about hurting anyone else...
Accidents do happen, don't let it discourage you though. Wish I had some advice for you, but haven't tried that kind of work yet.
I was thinking you'd have to change the shape somewhat so the scrap block put on top would be screwed and glued. I don't think I would trust just glue alone either. Of course changing the shape might not be an option either.
Perhaps you could turn most of the outside then put the wire supports on this area and remove the wooden faceplate. Don't know, just thinking outloud.