Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Posts

My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#1

My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Mike Jones in Redding Ca.

I've been mixing my own using variations of the Fairfield recipe for the last year or so. I got a quart of Waterlox last Xmas and this is what I did to keep it usable: First. I poured the entire quart into individual snap-top plastic 4 oz. bottles. I put a small piece of saran wrap over the bottle top,squeezing every last bubble of air out before screwing the top down tight.

I inverted each of the small bottles to keep a liquid seal against the sealed, gasketed, top. The lot of these bottles was then placed into a "Rubbermaid" type sealable cake box, and the whole kit-n-kaboodle went into my shop fridge to assure a "vacuum seal" of the Rubbermaid box.

I went through these bottles today and found every one of them partly gelled...and no longer usable. (Thanks to Russ Fairfield...I make fresh, small batches of perfect finish with tung oil, man-o-war, and turps...and never lose a single batch.)

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#2

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Carole Valentine

Never had success with plastic bottles. Think air passes through the plastic or the finish reacts with the plastic or something. Glass is much better. I have had success with small mason jars filled to the brim, sealed tightly and stored in a dark cabinet, but once they are opened, they never seem to seal tight enough again and you need to use that jar in fairly short order.

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#3

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

john lucas

That's why I gave up on Waterlox. I never used more than half a can before it went bad and that stuff isn't cheap. I do like it as a finish but apparently I just don't turn enough work that uses that finish and it goes bad on me.

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#4

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Jeff Willaford

From the Waterlox website....

"For proper storage, oxygen inside the Waterlox can must be displaced, by one or more of the following methods:

� Decant the product into a smaller airtight glass or metal container. DO NOT use plastic. If using a previously vacuum-sealed jar (e.g. pickles or baby food) use plastic wrap inside the lid to create an adequate seal.

� Use clean marbles or stones to raise the level of the finish and thereby displace the oxygen.

� With rectangular cans, squeeze the sides to push the liquid up and seal before the air returns into the can.

� �Float� the product with an inert gas, such as carbon dioxide or argon, or Bloxygen that is heavier than air."

If you'd only known....

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#5

Ric Taylor

There's Nothing Wrong With It

Ric Taylor

The Waterlox is still perfectly fine even though the surface has jelled. All you need to do is use a pipette (less than a penny each on eBay) to stick through the gell and draw the good Waterlox up from below.

I've been using the same Waterlox in a glass jar for two years using this method with no issues at all. The "old" Waterlox acts just like it came out of a fresh can and there is no difference in the characteristics of the finish.

Ric

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#6

Ellis Walentine

Baby food jars work great, and a reality check

Ellis Walentine

Mike, a few years ago, I had the sorry task of cleaning out my childhood home, after my mother moved to an independent living facility and we were preparing to sell her house. I happened to find several baby food jars full of Waterlox that I had put up in 1986. They were all as fresh as new. True story. My point is that you don't need darkness and refrigeration and all those other "over the top" contortions to keep the stuff from gelling. And the lids on baby food jars have built-in gaskets, so you don't need saran wrap.

I'm curious about one thing you said -- that all your little bottles have started to jell and are unusable. In my experience, if the air is coming in from the lid, the gelling process starts with the surface layers of varnish, gradually resulting in a leathery cap over the still-usable product below. If you experienced something different from that, I'm thinking maybe it was because you shook or agitated the bottles or that, as Carole suggested, air might somehow have migrated through the plastic. In any event, I suggest you try simply decanting the fresh varnish into 4-oz. (or smaller) baby food jars, cap them tightly and don't open them until you are ready to use them. Your downside at any given time is just what's left in the open jar.

Regarding your mix of tung oil, varnish and thinner, what you've made is essentially a "Danish" oil mix, which is a totally different animal from Waterlox, which is a varnish. Danish oils don't build like varnishes, and you need to wipe off the excess to keep it from getting gummy on the surface. Michael Dresdner (I was his editor for years) used to say that Danish oils are the least value for your finishing dollar, because you end up throwing it away after wiping it off your project. The main virtue of Danish oil is that it saturates the surface, brings out the grain nicely and doesn't collect dust, because you wipe it all off except for the tiny amount that sticks to the wood. Adding subsequent coats barely adds any build to the surface.

I suppose that if the main ingredient of your mix is varnish, with just very small amounts of tung oil and turpentine, it might behave more like a varnish and dry to a film, but I don't like to second-guess the formulators who designed that varnish in the first place. If the added ingredients were beneficial, they would have put them there themselves.

I don't mean to be sermonizing here, so don't take my comments wrong. I'd just like to suggest a solution to your initial problem.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#7

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

mark wollschlager

I may just be lucky, but my Waterlox has been good for quite a while, in the quart can.

I did not remove the metal 'seal' under the cap.

I punctured the seal several times with a small nail.

My preferred application method is wipe-on and I just dribble out enough for an application and screw the lid back on.

The can is a couple of years old and is still usable. YMMV.

Mark.

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#8

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Russ Fairfield

Pay attention to what Ellis says. Like me, he is one of those people who has used Waterlox for many years and he speaks the truth. Also pay attention to the Waterlox words that have been posted. I think Ellis has always lived in a climate where finishing products were easier to keep for a longer period of time because the local climate weren't so hard on stored finishes. Living in the hot and humid South, and the cold a wet Northwest were the most difficult climates to keep a finish for me. Now that I live in North Idaho where the humidity is less, and I have a heated shop in the winter and air conditioning in the summer, all finishes last much longer. I have always thought the reason was lower humidity and lack of condensed moisture in and on everything with changes in temperature. (Note that I may be scientifically wrong on this personal opinion)

One of the biggest problems with Waterlox and all other finishes is the climate and atmosphere we live in and where we use it. Waterlox and almost all other finishes only had a 2 (or 3 at the most) season life in North Florida where the humidity was close to 100% for most of the year, and the average shop temperature was in the 90's for most of the year, and varied between the 40's and low 60's in the winter. Neither condition was good for good for a finish after it was mixed, and I started making my own because there was a longer life when they were stored separately.

My biggest problem with storing a sealed finish in the refrigerator was taking the time to let it warm up to room temperature before opening the sealed jar. Opening a cool finish is the fastest way I know of to get it to absorb atmosheric water vapor, and that is a lot of moisture when the outside humidity is close to 100%

The problem with using plastic bottles is that the finishes are still exposed to air unless they are made from either medicinal or hair and beauty supply bottles. (Sorry I can't remember the type of plastic) They are available on-line and at beauty supply shops, I discovered the baby food bottles about 40 years ago when my girls were babies because they were easilly available, and their advantage for keeping the air out of the finish. I have used a lot of plastic bottles ever since and discovered that everything except the special formulations were about like leaving the finish in an open jar.

An old refrigerator has always been my best place to store finishes because the differences between nightine and daytime or working temperatures is reduced.

I know this may not be what anyone wants to hear if they no longer have babies to feed, but a lot of us have grandchildren and still have access to the Gerber jars. The other choice is either buying the right plastic jars from the scientific store or the beauty supply store. All other plastic jars are like having an open container, and their only advantage is takeing about 2X longer.

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#9

Re: Baby food jars work great, and a reality check

Mike Jones in Redding Ca.

Ellis, If I find gel in my bottle of mix, I know that the "formula" is upset, and I know that I would have an additional step of filtering to rid the finish of globules. Whether it is factual or not, I BELIEVE that the finish has been compromised and I won't use it. My mix is essentially varnish with oil to help it flow (makes it wipe-on) and turpentine to expedite drying. It builds like waterlox, and it seems to be superior to "Danish Oil" in every respect. (we might ask to Russ to comment on this.)

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#10

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Ed Heuslein

I have a container of Waterlox that is almost 3 years old and is as good as new. The secret is keeping air from contaminating the finish. Now, all you have to do is find a neighbor or friend who drinks wine and buys it in those boxes with a plastic bag insert. When you're done drinking the wine...er, I mean when your neighbor is done drinking the wine, pull the bag out, pull the spout off, and rinse the inside thoroughly. Let it dry for a few days. Now, pour your new can of Waterlox into the bag. Carefully squeeze the sides 'till you've removed all the air. Put the bag back into the box and you're good for several years. Just pour out a little at a time into a small container. I use a good paper towel for application and a little goes a long way. Please feel free to send me a private email if you have any questions.

Oh yeah. I've used the baby jars also. The old ones worked great. The ones out the past several years have different seals - make sure the top is screwed on straight. - Ed

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#11

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Carole Valentine

Ed, I've never taken one of those things out of the box. Is the spout easy to get off and put back on with out compromising the bag? Does the spout leak air after removal and re-installation? I have a "bag" that the wine is not fit to drink, so I may experiment with this.

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#12

Ellis Walentine

Almost tried that, Ed -- and a personal note

Ellis Walentine

I even went so far as to salvage the wine bag and rinse it out, but I had to cut the top corner of the bag off to do it. No big problem assuming I can figure out some way of clamping the cut corner of the plastic bag tightly closed. Meanwhile, I have been using other varnishes and never got back to the Waterlox experiment. It's good to hear that it works as advertised. I figured it would -- it's as simple of keeping air out of the product.

On another, important, note:

When you request e-mail notification of replies to your message on WoodCentral, it is imperative that you provide an e-mail address that is working and able to receive mail, otherwise the notice bounces back to me. I don't know if this is an Earthlink issue or what, but I am going to uncheck the box at the bottom of your message form that requests notification; I'd appreciate it if you would do the same next time you post, so your cookie will contain that new preference.

If you would like to be notified in the future, and your Earthlink address isn't working or will not accept mail from our server, you will need to use another address. You might want to get a g-mail account just for situations like this, and forward your g-mail to your Earthlink address, with all permissions in place, of course.

Anyhow, just a heads up. Sorry I had to post it here but there's no way to e-mail you.

Thanks,

Ellis

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#13

Ellis Walentine

Whatever works for you

Ellis Walentine

Couple things, Mike... I don't doubt that your homemade varnish-oil mixture does what you want it to, so by all means don't let me rain on that parade. I'd like to try your mix myself sometime, based on your recommendations. I just thought I would note that the way I've always understood a wiping varnish is made is to thin a regular varnish with the appropriate thinner. I still don't feel that the addition of the tung oil is important, if you're going for a true varnish film. I'd be worried that the additional oil would make the film softer and less resistant to abrasion, not to mention longer to dry.

I was wondering if you had tried thinning your Man-O-War without adding oil. I recently finished a couple pieces doing just that and it worked well.

Ellis

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#14

Re: Whatever works for you

Mike Jones in Redding Ca.

There are so many variables involved in the choice of finish or mix of finish....the size of a project could influence the use of oil with the varnish, the ambient atmosphere (as Russ mentions), as well as the type and m/c of the wood could influence the use of a solvent and of course, the desired appearance and utility of the completed project can influence every element of the finishing process.

What I have done, and what others report here, as to the measure one goes to to utilize a relatively expensive manufactured product, (see wine bag above) as compared to the simplicity, modifiablilty, control, and economy of small-batch home brew, and I simply could not justify continuing with Waterlox. (Even though it is my all-time favorite store-bought finish)

But then, I tie my own flies and make my own beer...so mixing my own oil/varnish may have a lot to do with my particular brand of personality aberration.

I think that you are right, Ellis, about the oil softening the varnish. This is not necessarily a negative factor.

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#15

Re: Almost tried that, Ed -- and a personal note

Ed Heuslein

Ellis, I'm so sorry. I changed email accounts a couple months ago and neglected to change my profile here. I've done that now (I think) and hope this will work.

As for your cutting the bag, I've done that also. I used one of the vacuum seal machines to seal it back up. My goal was to make the bag smaller. I was only mildly successful as sometimes tha bags leaked. So I just use the original unmodified. You really can just pull the spout off and push back on when done cleaning. I've done it dozens of times - all on friends bags of course. ;) Ed

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#16

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Ed Heuslein

Howdy Carol: The hardest part is getting into the box. Easiest is to just cut thru the top. Pull the bag out. Pull off the spout, wash the bag & dry, pour in the Waterlox, press all the air out, reinsert the spout (it really is pretty easy), and put it back into the box. I tape the top of the box closed. I've successfully used Franzia and Almaden wine boxes with success. My email address is heuslein@wildblue.net if you have any more questions.

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#17

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Ed, and a question about your bag trick

Ellis Walentine

First, thank you for getting your WC preferences straightened out. One less chore for me to deal with. :)

Regarding rinsing the bag just through the spout, how can you ever dry it before you put the Waterlox in, or do you just put it in the wet bag? Come to think of it, that might be okay, too. I guess any water left in the bag will just sink to the bottom of the bag, below the spigot and be harmless.

Ellis

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

#18

Re: My "over-the-top" Waterlox effort...(failed)

Carole Valentine

Thanks, Ed. I'll have to give it a try. How do you get the bag dry inside? Looks like it would take forever and a day for all the moisture to evaporate through the opening that the spout fits into. Of course I have not actually taken one out of the box and looked at it yet...maybe it's larger than I think.