DO WOODTURNERS AS A GENERAL RULE HAVE WAY TO MUCH TIME ON THEIR HANDS?
FOR EXAMPLE: A great deal of time is spent in this and other forums considering vague, unrealistic, concepts posed by the S. A.'s of the world on whatever. I come here to learn from the experiences of others about what works and what may not. I understand that all here is only opinion. I am savy enough to know that all of the thoughts expressed here come from experiences and are not necessarily "truths" about a procedure or product. May I suggest to all, that in my humble opinion, this forum be for the exchange of hands on experiences and not the vague S. A. ramblings I often have to sift through to get to the things that promote better woodturning experiences.
May I suggest that we not respond to this kind of post in the future. I would think that spending more time at the lathe and less time on vague S. A. topics here would gain a lot more ground for all.
I hear what you're saying but I really enjoy having the opportunity to get to know folks on the forum. I have enjoyed the details of someone raising some type of goat, someone getting a new puppy, or better yet, two puppies. I enjoy seeing pictures of snowfall in some areas and wildlife sightings in other areas. I enjoy hearing about the neighborhood kids, the grandkids, and the kids getting married. I enjoy being able to know those that ride motorcycles, bicycles, and classic cars. I enjoy the civil debate, and the sometimes "mostly" civil debate, of many topics; many that will not change my life. I enjoy hearing about who's packing heat and who cares about someone else packing heat. I enjoy knowing that some of us have day jobs and others have night jobs and still others have jobs for which they travel. I even enjoy reading the posts about too many OT posts. I don't post much here; or anywhere for that matter.
So, why is it that I enjoy the posts so much? I think it is because the folks that frequent this site make me feel welcome.
The best thing of all is that I can tell almost immediately if I wish to read a thread.
precisely because it is just the way it is. Yes there are days when I wish people would post more of their work, warts and all. I have learned so much from all of you people since I have started hanging out here. Bruce summed up why this is such a great forum though. O.T. stuff gets posted though because I think there are some things, non turning related, that only another turner can appreciate.
" I come here to learn from the experiences of others about what works and what may not. I understand that all here is only opinion. I am savy enough to know that all of the thoughts expressed here come from experiences and are not necessarily "truths" about a procedure or product."
So, info given about actual experiences is not necessarily a "truth"? I don't think I get that, either. If everything is just "opinion" and not useful facts, then why bother to read any of it????
One of us is a little addled here . . . I'm not sure I understand your point.
Don, there are certain people whose posts I never bother reading because I know it would be a waste of my time. Maybe you should start being more particular about whose posts you read.
Seems that in a public forum the "fun factor" is not only in the wisdom found but in the quest as well .... all the amazing tips I've ferreted out of posts that appeared to be of no value have shown their worth once examined.
This forum is a community...almost like a family, complete with the "black sheep", the "crazy uncle", the "eccentric cousin", etc. but rather than blood, it's the working with wood that binds us. Like some others I enjoy the social aspect of the forum and reading what's going on with the members ...even the OT things, or at least most of them. It's led to some close Internet friendships. Like Barb, I know that the "crazy Uncle" or "whiny cousin" are probably just going to irritate me with their posts so I don't even read them anymore. Filter, Don...filter!
I learn lots here. I get to meet vendors, and make buying decisions based upon what I think of their products. More than that, I get to know what kind of people are behind those products, and I can decide whether or not I want to recommend their products to the folks I meet.
I learn a lot about woodturning from the OT posts, Don. How about you?
Don I think there are a couple of things going on here. One is we don't have enough time to turn. If we did we wouldn't be on the computer as much.
Second is our jobs place us at the computer making it easy to check up on WC. My job for example requires downloading all the photos we shoot. As I go through all the labeling, editing, renaming etc, you have to wait for the computer to do it's thing. While that's happening I'll check up on the woodturning sites. I'm really not there more than 5 minutes but you can scan a lot of posts in that time.
3rd. I like these people. It's fun getting to know them, all the funny little quirks and attitudes and then sharing in their joys and hurts. I guess I would have met some like you and Doug and Mike Hunter at symposiums but since I can't go to many of them the only way we get to talk is on forums.
It is a pain sometimes when there are a million posts about nothing that I'm interested in but I can always click past those.
To me... the beauty of the internet is that I can choose what to read and what to ignore...just like I can change stations on my radio or TV. It's just a mouse click or not.
I'll always prefer a world where I can tune in or tune out based on my personal opinion rather than a world where my choices are restricted by someone with a view different from mine. Enjoy the diverse and open community of Wood Central while we still have the privilege.
...I, as others, enjoy the variety of topics and information available here. This is my internet home-away-from-home. It's the first site I go to most every day. I certainly have learned and continue to learn a great deal about woodturning here, but I have also learned a lot about MANY other things that are also helpful, and interesting. The wide expanse of knowledge and experience here is invaluable to me. I know just where to go if I need help I can't get locally. Most of my web time comes at work since I have kind of an unusual job with a fair amount of slack time. At home I have a lot more to do than just turning. I sure wish I could get in the shop more though. I also have interests other than woodturning, amazing as that may sound.
Heck, even at woodturning club meetings we talk about more than just turning. The community of woodturning is about much more than just wood and turning. It would be boring if that was all we ever talked about, IMHO.
So Don, keep posting your thoughts and projects and hang out around the woodstove with us and shoot the breeze about whatever comes up. It's up to you to choose what you want to get out of this or any website.
I don't know what an S. A. is. I am as guilty as anyone of posting off topic posts, if that is the point.
To relate this to turning, there is a member of our local club that is as close to a master of the skew as anyone I have ever seen, and that list includes some very well known demonstrators. I have watched this guy closely. I can't figure out whether he has a better skew than I do (not) or better skills. (yes). It is a fact he is better with a skew than I am. It is also my opinion. He has years of time at the lathe with the skew in his hand. (He is a true professional and it is nothing for him to turn two hundred balusters and then do it again next week.) I am not willing to invest the time to practice. This is as much of a realization as fact. There is more to this than just facts.
Interesting pretty accurate responces "in my humble opinion".
Let me conclude this with these responces and clarifications.
Getting to know you. Absolutely! Great point. We all certainly benifit from O.T. posts of a personal nature.
I too, as a rule, do not post, read, or participate in posts that are vague ramblings placed there by the the "black sheep", the "crazy uncle", the "eccentric cousin", or "whiny cousin". I am just amazed at how many do and by doing so raising the question of some having "to much time on their hands". Just wondering out loud.
As to all being just opinion. I have learned over the years that opinions are usually stated as fact. A great deal of the time these opinion/facts are at the least partially or totally not accurate or true. Example, I have watched a professional woodturning demontrator claim that one tool, finish, or lathe is better than another (stated as fact although it was his or her opinion). To often many take this opinion as fact not realizing that when they used the they were having a bad day. Maybe they just made a mistake. It may not be the better. It is just opinion. I was please to get this persons feedback on a product or method but kept in mind that this was only opinion. Yes it does help to make an informed decision. A fact is does a tool have an HSS or carbide tip? Does this lathe have a 1 hp or 2 hp motor? Does this finish have a particular ingrediant in it? How these products worked when the person used them is an opinion.
I agree that there are often many opinions that are based on the tools, machinery, and the wood we use. Which one we chose and which one is best for us depends on a lot of things, including our experience.
The scientific truth is that the carbon steel, HSSteel, and Carbide tools have a potential sharpness that is in the order of their particle sizes, but often has more to do with the ability and grinding tools of the woodturner. The Carbon Steel has the potential for being the sharpest because they have the thinnest particles. They are followed by the HSS because the particles are larger.
The Carbide tools are the least shapness in a perfect world because they are the largest particles. The new Carbide tools are much sharper than they used to be because they are now made with much smaller particle sizes.
HOWEVER, HSS lasts at least 3X longer than the Carbon Steels, and the new Carbide lasts 20X or longer than the High Speed Steel. There is also less chance of damage to the HSS from too much grinding or from a clogged grinding wheel than with the Carbon Steel, and even less chance of heat damage to the Carbide wheels. There is also a big difference in that the new Carbides are sharpened in the factory, and the tool steels are being sharpened at home with a grinder, and by people with little to no skills with sharpening tools.
For me, the Carbon steels will always be the sharpest, but that is not necessarilly true for the less experienced woodturner. I use the HSS tools because they are more available and require less grinding, but I still use the Carbon tools when I want a very sharp tool and am willing to accept a very short time of use than can be just a few seconds.
All of these tools will have their advocates because of their personal sharpening skills and what they are doing with them. I have been using steel and HSS tools of some kind for my entire life, and I AM USED TO GRINDING THEM OFTEN AND QUICKLY. Most woodturners don't have that experience, and they need to learn it, or they can use the Carbide tools because they don't have to grind them at all.
I would add that this same question of ability and experience would apply to the use of the tools themselves. How many times have you obserned a skilled craftsman make a poor to fair quality tool look better than the best and then see great tool perform poorly in the hands of another.
Example: One of the tools that is the current rage is only demonstrated at trade shows on soft to medium woods. It would appear that the tool works better that any other in its field. When the user gets home and tries it out, unknowingly using it on a good hard wood, it does not work any better than the one he already has. And it truely does not. The old tool and your suggestion of a grinding lesson would have saved him several hundred dollars up front and a lot more over the years.
Example: I like Mike Hunter and his tools. Remember how when they first came out turners were talking like you could throw the rest of your tools out? This one did it all. After a while all the hype blew over and it became clear that it was great tool and wonderfully better than anything else for what it was made to do.