Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Hunter 5 on end grain...

Posts

Hunter 5 on end grain...

#1

Hunter 5 on end grain...

Garyg in Md

I should already know this, but I don't, so I'm asking...

I have a small, END GRAIN box elder bowl with a beautiful starburst of red ambrosia in the middle. The wood is dry, and it's very prone to tear out. I can't even shear scrape it (on the outside) without roughing it up. A real CUT is required. That's easy enough on the outside, but the method I use for hollowing on end grain is to stick the point of a spindle gouge in with the flute at about 10 o'clock and go from the inside to the outside. It works fine as far as removing wood is concerned, but I'm getting tear out on this piece. I don't have a hook tool or a Berger tool -- I guess those would be ideal.

But I do have a Hunter #5. So my questions is: will the Hunter #5 permit me to do a real cut on the inside of this relatively shallow, end grain bowl?

Please let me know if you've tried it. ...Gary

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

Mike Stafford

The answer is "Yes" but it is a qualified "Yes".

The Hunter tools all excel on end grain however they do their very best work on hard woods, the harder the better. They also respond well to speed.

I run my lathe at 2500 or better when I an using my Hunter tools on cocobolo, tulipwood, ebony, blackwood, verawood and the rest of the very hard woods I like to turn.

The qualification I will add is that you are wanting it to cut box elder cleanly. It may and it may not depending on the softness of the wood, your tool control and presentation to the wood.

Give it a try and if you are not happy try a short bevel 1/4" or 3/8" bowl gouge. They will work.

Soft woods can be troublesome with any tool.

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#3

Re: Gary- you don't remember that.....

JamieDonaldson

...I used my Hunter#5 for just such a cut during my demo for your club? It is ideal for this application, but draw cuts center out only, and at about a 45 degree angle to the L. If you have trouble making a clean cut, coat the tearout area with lacquer thinned with 1 "glub"(about 5~10%) of acetone, and when it dries try another light cleanout cut with the Hunter.

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#4

Thanks, Mike...

Garyg in Md

Yes, this is just the opposite -- extremely light and nearly fibrous. It's not palm, but it's not far from it. I'll certainly try the Hunter (per Jamie, below), but your reco to use a high-angle (i.e., flat-nosed) bowl gouge is very good -- indeed, "duh", I should have thought of that myself. I'll post how it turns out. Thanks. ...Gary

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#5

Now I do!  ;-)

Garyg in Md

Thanks, Jamie. Yes, right on.

I know about putting on shellac, thinned lacquer, paste wax, etc., and will certainly do so, but the important thing is getting a tool to actually "cut".

Mike's comment (above) about the bowl gouge is certainly valid for a shallow bowl like this (it's only about 4" in diameter). But I have the Hunter for a reason, and I like to use it whenever I can.

Just so I'm not confused, please explain what you mean by "45 degrees to the L". There are so many angles... What's the "L". Are you talking about a tool rotation angle of 45 degrees around the shaft, a tool shaft angle of 45 degrees in the horizontal plane with respect to the direction of the ways, or a 45 degree handle down angle? (Bearing in mind Bill G's 45/45/45.)

Thanks, Gary

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#6

Re: Gary- you don't remember that.....

john lucas

Ditto what Jamie said. Box Elder really has a tendency to tearout. The first thing I try after switching from a bowl gouge to the #5 or #4 is to put wax on the wood. That often works. If it doesn't then I go to the CA or Lacquer. If I'm in a hurry I'll soak it with thin CA. If not I'll use the thinned lacquer. If the tearout is bad you may have to take a couple of light passes and then apply some more lacquer.

The reason the tools work better at high speeds is simply that it's easier to let the tool do the cutting. It's all about the feed rate of the tool vs the surface speed of the wood. If you force any tool through the cut it will pull out fibers. You can either slow down the feeding rate of the tool or you can speed up the wood or both.

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#7

Good points, John

Garyg in Md

Actually, I forgot to talk about the higher speed. Yes, I'm undoubtedly turning this too slowly. I had it on only the second from lowest speed on my Jet 1236, even though it's only 4" in dia. I'll crank it up!

It's funny, because Paul Fennell just told me to use CA also. I thought the end grain would soak up too much (like a sponge), but on a piece this small, I should be able to do it.

I'm heading out the door to pick him up at the airport right now.

Gotta run, Gary

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#8

Mike Stafford

45 degrees to the left....

Mike Stafford

What Jamie is referring to is the presentation angle of the Hunter tool with respect to direction of cut.

Think about it this way. If the socket for the set screw for the carbide cutter on the Hunter is pointing at 12 o'clock on the clock face what Jamie is recommending (and so do I) is that you rotate the cutter counter clockwise as you sweep from the center outward with the socket pointed at about 10:30 on the clock face or about 45 degrees from vertical.

I will reiterate that speed is your friend when using the Hunter but you should never turn at a high RPM/speed if you are not comfortable and confident at that speed.

I cannot tell you how many gallons of CA I have used on soft woods trying to salvage them. When that CA dries you will be glad you have a Hunter tools as it will slice it cleanly.

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#9

Is Paul here for a demo?

Charlie Anderson

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#10

Re: Is Paul here for a demo?

Garyg in Md

Hi Charlie,

No, he's here for the big opening of the Bressler exhibit at the Renwick, and associated activities. As I understand it there will be a very large number of names you would recognize here for this.

Come on up on Friday. That's the public opening. There will be a "round-table" discussion at noon with the curator Nicholas Bell, Fleur Bresler, Norm Sartorius, Mark Lindquist, and Michelle Holzapfel -- and lots of good viewing.

...Gary

Re: Hunter 5 on end grain...

#11

Thanks, Mike...

Garyg in Md

I'll give it a try. ...Gary