Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Will I or wont I

Posts

Will I or wont I

#1

Will I or wont I   

Terry Scott



Last year I turned and carved this Coolibah 12inch Burl called Carmelia Burl.

It was sold into a collection and have just had an email asking if I am working on a bigger one by the same client.

I have a few problems

One finding a burl that is as sound as this was.Because the petals are very fine

Two Is that making something to order maybe a ticket to disaster

Three finding the time as I estimate 60 hours work

Four they want it 3 times the size but I doubt I will get 3 times as much

Five After all that work they then say they dont want it

The process to make this was to first turn and finish the out side .Turn the inside and then with dentist drill bits in a Dremel laboriously shape and cut the petals.The surface was then textured with a small ball bit making sure no flat shiny surface was left

What would you do take the risk and enjoy the Journey or say sorry no can do

Re: Will I or wont I

#2

Re: Will I or wont I

john lucas

I hate doing commissions for all the reasons you state. Mostly it's just worrying that something will go wrong with the whole process and I'll lose money. There in lies the problem. I often need the money so it's a big gamble and consequently a headache. I usually end up doing them. I tell myself this will pay for the car insurance and grit my teeth and go for it.

The time element is something I always hate. I like to do my own thing. I like to make what I want when I want. Working full time I don't have lots of time to spend in the shop anyway so I hate doing a commission and taking away that time.

Most jobs have turned out great and are rewarding both financially and aesthetically but some are just production work and a pain all the way around until the money hits the bank.

Re: Will I or wont I

#3

Re: Will I or wont I

Jorge Casta�eda

Terry,

Of the many variables, I can comment in a couple.

Works made on commission, within the last month, I made a 16" cherry platter and a 17" birds eye maple bowl, both commissions, fearing that they would not like them and refuse to pay, both were new clients, I asked for pay in advance, and I got it in both cases, then on delivery they were delighted to get what I made them.

About the price if a piece is 3 time bigger, the price is not x3, it is more like squared or even more as the work increases in geometrical proportion. Figure out the surface are of the original and the projected area of the new one and use that as a base, and then get as much as you can. Tell them you cannot afford to invest money and your time if there is not a hard commitment on their part.

Nice challenge you have in there, good luck locating the burl.

Have fun!

Jorge

Re: Will I or wont I

#4

Re: Will I or wont I

Ruth Niles

First, Terry, that is totally beautiful!

Perhaps initially tell them it will be 3 times the cost. Don't go into an explanation, that's your price.

Most likely you can not give them a finish date because of your reasons; finding the right wood in the right size, finding time and what happens if they don't like it, would you be able to sell it elsewhere.

I can not do this awesome type work, but, personally, commission work puts stress on me and it is just not relaxing, fun nor worth the money......of course, I don't get anything close to what 3 times this beauty is worth! : )

Just one non-artistic woodturners' opinion.

Re: Will I or wont I

#5

Re: Will I or wont I

Doc Green

If you make the diameter three times as large, the surface area will be NINE times as much. If you texture it to the same level of detail and work at the same speed, you can then expect it to take nine times as long to do the texturing.

If you then charge only three times as much, you would be working for only one-third your original wage.

You can get caught between a rock and a hard place if you aren't careful.

~Doc

Re: Will I or wont I

#6

Re: Will I or wont I

Barry Irby

Terry, first, that is really beautiful. And awesome piece of work. And, I could not do it if you held a gun on me or if you offered me a life of retirement in return. So neither positive or negative reinforcement would help me get that done. So maybe I am not the one to answer but here are a few thoughts.

I agree with those who pointed out that it is more like nine times as much work. Surface area of a circle increases in relation to the square of the radius and I think the surface of a sphere is related to the cube of the radius.

So, just based on that, its a lot more work. Or did they mean three times the surface area, not three times the diameter?

Also, I suspect the first piece of wood found you. One of your suppliers offered it to you, or you stumbled across is on a wood hunting trip. Very little time and effort on your part, either way, but to find a matching piece three times as big you might have to search the southern hemisphere and it could take years. Or can you just call up "Burls are Us" and have them send one over?

Another thing that makes this more work is replicating the first one. There must have been some sense of adventure in coming up with the design and technique and then applying them, wondering all the while if this was going to be as good and you thought? Even a little screw up here and there would have been design opportunities or modifications to the technique. Now you have to go back, repeat yourself, Carefully and not screw up, times nine.

Re: Will I or wont I

#7

Rob Wallace

Surface area of a sphere....

Rob Wallace

..... is 4 times pi [3.14159] times the square of the radius.

(BTW - cube of the radius refers to the *volume* of a sphere: 4/3 x pi x radius cubed )

If you are texturing inside and outside surfaces of a hemispherical bowl, this area approximates that of a sphere surface.

Just to help with surface area estimates.... ;)

Rob Walalce

Re: Will I or wont I

#8

Re: Will I or wont I

Mac Ray

Hi Terry,Thats a hard decision,only you can make......I dislike commisions....like to feel that being retired,my time is my own,of course,it's not.I used to use a Dremel for texturing and still do on some things,but have found that the Mastercarver Combo grinder and Burner is a much faster and more efficient tool to use for texturing,has more power,and is much more comfortable to use.......I would say it is twice as easy to do that type of work with........but you will need dust protection as it sends up quite a cloud when you wind it up..........it will use all the same cutters that the Dremel will,and more too.......I really like mine a lot......Jack V. turned me onto it and since then I see that Molly W. uses one also....would be interested in knowing if you take the job or not........it's always a hard decision to make......you might do as I do if you take the job,and ask for 50% up front.......and give yourself a wide window of time to complete it......also sending the customer a few pics of progress is always interesting for them......good luck.......

Re: Will I or wont I

#9

Re: Will I or wont I

George Guadiane

Terry,

IF (BIG if) yo decide you want to take on this project, I would go at it like this:

Do whatever math you like to get to a price at which you would be willing to do the search for material and the actual wood working.

Draw up a contract that outlines the following:

1. Final Price (packing and shipping could be extra or included).

2. You get a non-refundable deposit in the amount of $???. The only exception would be if you fail to get the materials and/or fail to complete the project.

3. Time is not a factor.

4. They have the right to refuse the finished product for any reason without further obligation.

Re: Will I or wont I

#10

Re: Will I or wont I

charlie belden

Terry:

I think you've answered your question already - and the answer is PASS - just too many unpredictables to waste your valuable time on.

And it's the amount of time that would be spent on Doing It Again - But Bigger. You ARE NOT a production turner. You have too many creative ideas and too many techniques to develop to make many of those ideas realities. In the two months or more spent Doing It Again - Only Bigger - you could, given your prolific creative track record, create a dozen or more unusual and amazing pieces.

Some turners settle on a form, style and technique and then repeatedly do variations of it. Marketers love recognized brands / products /logos / slogans / themes. Coca Cola has made a fortune on their brand.

But your work is not, and cannot be, targeted for a mass market, or even a limited edition Your work is valued not only for the skills and techniques you have, but mainly for their imaginative / creative / diverse uniqueness. And even though your pieces are very diverse in terms of woods, shape/form, finish and technique - each is quickly recongized by anyone who has seen just some of your work - as being a Terry Scott piece. I'm not sure HOW you pull that off - but you do.

Unless The Wolves Are At Your Door, and you really need the money, pass on Do It Again - But Bigger, and spend the time doing what you do best - push the boundaries, make your new creative concepts realities- and please continue to share what you discover on your wonderful journey (and by wonderful, I mean I Wonder What The Hell He'll Come Up With Next!?).

Re: Will I or wont I

#11

Re: Will I or wont I  reply to your comments

Terry Scott

Not very good with words ]

But Ill try and add an answer to youth reply's

I thought this additional to WC may well get the responses it did. So thanks everyone for your input

As I thought many of you have been in a similar predicament .I am fortunate in that Woodturning is my Hobbie (yes excessive and My wife says she is a woodturning widow ) I dont need the income from selling my work,demonstrations or to pay for my expenses (not luck a B lot of hard work )

As many of you have come to the conclusion I just enjoy creating playing with the millions of ideas I have floating around meeting people and having fun.

I do enjoy the challenge of a commission but much rather just play with what I want to .

I will never go full time as I go out in the shop when I want to and for as long as I want to .I see so many of my mates try to make a living and then they loose the spark and the creative juices.I have worked out that if I went full time after a few weeks id pack up my lathe and never do it again

So my answer to this collector will be I have many other pieces they can choose from and one day I may do another Camellia Burl and I will offer it to them first

This same person wants another Burl tree

as well

Another thing I like is to know is that a piece that I have put allot of myself into is going to be valued and appreciated Not end up in a cupboard along with a other corporate gifts

I always ask the customer what it is for if they say donated to a Museum or similar I refuse to sell .Why would I want one of my works to be hidden in the archives of darkness that Museums have or just become a tax right off

They can offer all the money in China I still wont sell. Money I can take or leave it ,I cannot make a piece of art every day and they are Unique

Well that was my Raving for the day

Cheers

Re: Will I or wont I

#12

Re: Will I or wont I

Terry Scott

George One big problem I have real trouble pricing finished work let alone a work that I havnt started and dont have any idea of the hours involved

In my trade and Business I price and quote daily , If you ask how much to build such in such I can normally come up with a price and it will be within 10 %

Woodturning I struggle maybe because in reality when I am turning I am under no pressure and enjoy the journey of each piece

You have made some good comments and be assured I will put them to practice