Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER ***
garyg in md
So many woods, so little time. Only one choice? Almost impossible. Depends on project needs and feelings at the time.
Many nice local woods here -- black cherry, many maples, birch, black walnut, dogwood, Bradford pear, white and red oak, black and honey locust, several hickorys, ash, sweet and black gums, osage orange, mulberry, box elder, even yellow pine, and more... Yes, we're spoiled. I have turned just about all of these, and enjoyed most of those.
If I had to pick only one, I guess it would be spalted and/or ambrosia red maple. It cuts well wet or dry, doesn't tear out too badly when dry, dries without too much cracking even in billet form, and can take on a wide variety of spectacular visual aspects.
A very close second would be black cherry for many of the same reasons, but the final products don't have as much visual impact. There is a nice contrast between sapwood and heartwood when fresh, but that difference largely away as it ages.
Birch is also nice when it has some white spalting. I think dogwood is a very under-appreciated wood for smaller objects. I also like spalted oaks, unlike many people, although it's like turning stone when it's dry. The color and grain patterns of mulberry are quite nice, and it's fun to watch it change color over the years from yellow to a golden brown. Red-flamed box elder provides spectacular images, but tear out is a problem when dry. Bradford pear turns like butter and holds its bark well, but it has very little visual interest -- good for carving and burning. Black walnut is unique -- it's dark but can be beautiful, particularly crotches.
I'd say I prefer variety rather than any one particular wood.
...Gary