Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

The mystery of the expanding hole

Posts

The mystery of the expanding hole

#1

The mystery of the expanding hole

David Walser

I have a mystery I'm hoping you all will be able to help me solve. Yesterday evening, I prepped some bottle stopper blanks for turning. To do this I mount the square blank in my four jaw scroll chuck and drill a shallow recess in the tailstock end of the blank with a 1" Forstner bit held in a drill chuck mounted in the tailstock's quill. I then drill a 23/64" diameter hole about 5/8" deep. After preparing several blanks in this manner, I then mount my bottle stopper mandrel in the headstock, screw on one of the prepared blanks and start turning. (The mandrel I use is from Ruth Niles that incorporates a 3/8" X 16tpi tap for creating the threads. It's a great time saver.)

Anyway, here's the mystery: When I tried to mount one of the blanks I prepped last night on the mandrel, the mandrel's 3/8" stud/tap slipped loosely into the hole drilled by my 23/64" bit. The threads of the tap didn't even touch the sides of the hole when the blank was centered on the mandrel. Huh? This was the 2nd or 3rd blank I prepped out of five or six blanks. All the other blanks were drilled with the same bits (I never removed the bits from the drill chucks) and all the other blanks could be tapped properly. So, what happened? If it matters, the blank in question was African Blackwood (I think). The other blanks were from other exotics.

Re: The mystery of the expanding hole

#2

Steven Antonucci

a few thoughts...

steven antonucci

If you tailstock is out of alignment, it would cause the bit to wander a little.

If you didn't clear the cut, perhaps the shavings packed against the wall of the hole and burnished it a little. exotics are dense and oily, so I would only drill them 1/8" at a time before backing out.

lastly, 1/64" undersized seems kind of cutting it close. I usually cut them within 1/8" and then tap them by hand.

Steven

Re: The mystery of the expanding hole

#3

Drill runout

Ray - Middletown, IN

The bit probably followed the grain and moved to one side and drilled oversize. You can reduce that possibility by starting with a center drill.

Ray

Re: The mystery of the expanding hole

#4

Re: Drill runout

Carole Valentine

I think Ray hit the nail on the head. Using a stubby bit helps, but it can still happen. And be sure your TS is locked down tight. I find that drilling at a higher speed sometimes helps if I know the grain is likely to induce wandering.

Re: The mystery of the expanding hole

#5

Re: a few thoughts...

Terry Scott

Steven hit the nail on the head

Check your alignment

Re: The mystery of the expanding hole

#6

Re: The mystery of the expanding hole

Don Evans

Well I've drill lots of A. Blackwood and it could be alignment contribution but I'll bet it is heat causing expansion.

Blackwood takes a lot of slow drilling with the tolerance you are using. I think what is happening is the bit is expanding and drilling the hole larger than it is suppose too.

Did you notice how much of the wood stuck to the bit? Cloggs it right up didn't it?

That also causes more heat, you have to drill AF slowly with small advances bring the bit out completely and clean the flutes out every 1/4" or less depending on the blank.

If it drilled the other types of woods ok, then alignment is less likely the problem.

If you have compressed air handy, using it to clean out the hole while drilling will help friction and heat problems on any drill job but blackwood is so sticky you gotta use a piece of wood to clean out the bit flutes and very often.

Don

Re: The mystery of the expanding hole

#7

Thanks to everyone!

David Walser

I appreciate everyone's thoughts. You've all given me a lot to think about. I may never know for sure what caused my too large hole, but I think too much heat is the likely explanation. The blank did get noticeably hotter than the others and I noticed some small hairline fissures in the sides of the hole.