Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

Posts

Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#1

Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

In March of '09 I started the linked thread - about removing the frozen drive pulley from the motor shaft of my Nova 3000 lathe.

A year and a half later I have the same issue - the drive pulley set became misaligned over time, and it is "frozen" in place. Going through a number of belts finally clued me in to this.

There is a key in the keyway and the set screw is removed. I have used PB Blaster and wooden wedges in attempts to loosen it. I called Tim Geist the Nova service guy - the technician there suggested the route that I have tried (wedges, PB Blaster) and possibly heat.

The only ideas I have left to try are:

1. a gear puller. For this application the diameter of the center point diameter is too large to reach the shaft inside the pulley assembly, so I'd have to create a smaller diameter post to extend that center point. What I do not like about a gear puller is that it pulls up on the outside of the large pulley rather than pressuring the portion closest to the shaft.

2. heat the pulley (suggest by technician at Nova service center/TVGeist).

Any other ideas? The wooden wedges finally worked last time - but this time I have only managed to move it about 5 mm.

Thanks

Henry


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?pro=search;pmd=sread;srchid=129053mD6Sc4P6BxZkOA1284649068;spage=1;sanc=202175;sbid=2001;md=read;id=202175#m_202175

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#2

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move?

John Lucas

I had the same problem with my Nova. The problem is a burr that is raised on the shaft from the set screw. The burr blocks removal of the pulley. Select a drill bit that just barely fits in the screw hole of the pulley. Then run the drill and just barely drill down into the shaft. It won't take much. You should then be able to slide the pulley off. Use a file to clean up the shaft before reinstalling the pulley.

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move?

Leo Cuellar

Check the portion of freshly exposed shaft for any burrs or galling, remove if found and lubricate again. Then I would try knocking it back down the shaft again using the method that Bill Turpin described, and possibly a little farther if you have room for your wedges. Check the new exposed area for more burrs etc, & remove if found. Then try it again. If the pulleys are cast I would be very leery of using a gear puller. If they are turned steel then I would attempt it. Heating can be problematic that close to a motor bearing if you get the pulley too hot. Good luck, these kind of things are always a bit stressfull, Leo

P.S. When you get everything apart check it carefully for burrs & galling. Repair as necessary. I would invest in a new piece of keystock and carefully round the corners off the ends of it and dress it lightly with a file or very fine sand paper before reassembly.

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#4

Nova 3000 owners - You have this issue?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

I guess I posted too soon because just now I was finally able to free the pulley set from the motor shaft.

Nova 3000 owners - what do you do to keep the pulley set from moving? I tightened the set screw as much as possible. Does your motor get warm but not hot to the touch after use (like mine does)? Could this be part of the reason for the pulley freeze?

A combination of approaches worked here to free the pulleys. I first used a hair dryer to heat up the pulley; wedges between pulley and mounting plate did not budge it. Then I was able to slip the tangs of a gear puller under the large pulley (and with a long screw into the center to ensure the center post of the gear puller was pushing on the motor shaft) and gradually pull the pulley set off.

I guess I should make pulley realignment a periodic maintenance item - to keep belts in better shape and so that the pulley does not freeze onto the shaft.

Thanks

Henry

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#5

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Thanks. You answered a question I had but did not ask - replacing the key. I'll certainly do that.

There did not seem to be a lot of burrs there, on either the key or shaft, only the distinct impression of the set screw on the key.

Henry

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#6

Leo Cuellar

Glad you got it apart!!!

Leo Cuellar

There are different styles of set screws available, flat ends, pointed, indented etc. You might try drilling a small indentation into the keystock where the setscrew will sit before you reassemble. With a pointed set screw this might allow you to put enough pressure on it to keep it from wandering. Alignment on a stepped pulley is also critical to keep things from wandering. The motor might become slightly askew on its mounting over time, replacing lockwashers there might help. I have a variable diameter setup on my Grizzly, which sometimes springs the snap ring off the shaft, very exciting :D

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#7

Steven Antonucci

No easy answers.

steven antonucci

But yeah, it happens on mine too.

S

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#8

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

This is very interesting. We do not get year-old threads very often. Some more information. Brake fluid makes an excellent penetreant and removes paint also. Make sure that your new key is a SLIP fit. File the corners off the key. File any burrs off the keyway. Make a flap sander with a 3/8" dowel, split the dowel, use 400grit paper, chuck in a drill, and polish the pulley bore. Spin the motor and polish with 400 grit paper. The pulley and key should be a slip, no struggle fit. Replace the set screw. The end is probably rounded over so that it does not cut into the key. Do not leave WD40 residue when re-assemblying.

If using heat to separate: try putting tip of an old style 250 watt Weller solder gun to pulley hub. Try to heat the hub, not the shaft. Wrap a damp paper towel around the shaft between the pulley and the motor.The purpose is to expand the pulley...increases the diameter of the bore, just a few thousandths. Try a torch if it does not come off.

Never-Seez (sp?) compound (various brand names) is a mixture of hi-temp grease and graphite or powdered copper or aluminum will stop all this from happening in the future. Coat the key, shaft, screw, and pulley bore. It is available at automative stores.

Remember: if you can't remove it easily immediately after installation it will not come off after time, moisture, corrosion, stress, etc have done their work! :)

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#9

Leo Cuellar

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move?

Leo Cuellar

Hi Bill! How're you doin'? I didn't recommend anti-seize because his problem begins with the pulley creeping. Although I have always had excellent results with it, especially on outdoor equipment, even with taper lock bushings. Perhaps drilling & tapping for an additional set screw would help with his initial problem?

Leo

P.S. Your post came through to me for some reason :D

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#10

Re: Anti-seize compound on Pulleys/shaft?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Yes Leo the initial issue is/was the pulley creeping under use.

However, if I could re-align the pulley set simply by releasing the set screw and shifting it (rather than remove the motor and whack in wedges, spray in PB Blaster and get out the gear pullers), I'd be more inclined to realign as soon as I noticed anything. To date I have been guilty of ignoring it too long because it is such a pain. I'd rather turn wood than carry on with that routine.

Anti-seize compound sounds like a good idea to me - would you agree?

Henry

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#11

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Leo: In my 22 years in an industrial plant, we NS everything that we ever planned on taking apart again. If the shafts are parallel and set screw and key are proper they should not move. The slick'um will not over come the burr created by a good set screw in the key. If it moves then the NS will help to get it apart next year. We all carried small squeeze tubes of the stuff in our tool pouches. I would also recommend doubling the set screw in the same hole. Unfortunately a setscrew 90� from the key puts a burr on the shaft that then requires a puller.

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#12

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move?

Ace Foster

And if you do double the set screw, leave yourself a note about it. Otherwise, the next time this comes around on the guitar, you'll loosen the setscrew you can get to, try to move things and end up using intemperate language before you remember the hidden set screw that's still holding things in place. DAMHIKT.

Ace

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#13

Leo Cuellar

Re: Anti-seize compound on Pulleys/shaft?

Leo Cuellar

Henry, in that case go for it. As I had mentioned to Bill, I have never had issues that were caused by the anti-seize. If there is room to get a wrench between the motor and pulley, you might also consider getting an extra long set screw and putting a nut on it to lock it down. It won't work in all situations, but is also worth investigating. When you put it back together, check the alignment with a straight edge across the faces of the pulleys to make sure it is all straight & square. Being fussy about that step is what keeps everything going until your belt dies of old age :D Leo

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#14

Re: how to check parallel shafts?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Ok Bill you may have hit on a cause for the shifting pulley: non-parallel shafts of motor and headstock.

Is there a best or an accepted way to check this "parallelicity"?

A straight edge on bandsaw wheels to check co-planarity makes sense to me, but I'll admit to never having read or even thought about how to check two shafts for being parallel. Measuring and comparing their separation on both extremes hardly seems like sufficient accuracy. Please enlighten me.

Are there other potential causes that you would suggest I check?

Many thanks for everyone's input

Henry

On my way to purchase a new key and some anti-seize compound (I've heard of LocTite before, but never this stuff)

Re: Pulleys frozen onto motor shaft - How to move? *LINK*

#15

Re: how to check parallel shafts?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Use a straight edge that will touch all four edges of the pulleys. All four must touch. Modify the straight edge to fit in the hole. Keep it for future use. This will prove lining up the pulleys and the parallelity. Be sure you are referencing the belt surface. Pulleys with different casting thicknesses will need to be allowed for. Do not reference to the hub, but to the pulley flanges if of identical thicknesses.

The three straight lines are your continuous straight edge.