Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

*** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

Posts

*** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

Ellis Walentine

I hope you can join us tonight at 9:30 EDT in the WoodCentral chatroom. We had a great time last week and I'm looking forward to yet another. In the absence of an official turning chat moderator, I will do the honors. (In case you're interested, applications for the moderator position will be gleefully accepted.)

In a recent thread begun by Terry Scott ("Plain Bowl"), I mused on the mysteries and challenges of critiques. Maybe tonight we can delve deeper into this topic. In fact, maybe we can try a live group critique of particular examples of each others' work. I think it will be good practice to view and discuss pieces in a constructive, non-judgmental way. Let's see if we can learn from others' perceptions of the same piece.

If you'd like to have something critiqued, bring along a link that we can follow to an image of your piece. If the image is not accessible from the web, send it to me and I'll send you a link that you can post.

Please join us!

Ellis

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#2

I was thinking about the tool grinds last night

John Lucas

I've had to work so much this week I haven't even been in the shop. Hopefully in the next few days I'll set up a light and get some shots of the tools. I know we talked about doing that at last weeks chat.

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#3

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

Stuart Johnson

Ellis, remember we had a start of some very good photo critique sessions a couple years ago until a few decided they didn't want a moderator or topic. At that time they said they couldn't do a proper critique from a photo.

I hope this time it works much better and if the same folks are in the chat sessions they will buy into it.

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#4

Ellis Walentine

We'll try, Stuart

Ellis Walentine

I've heard all the arguments before, Stuart, and the main reason that I've found people are leery of online critiques is that they tend to dwell on the fine points of what people don't like about a piece, rather than merely faithfully reporting their overall impression. Photography can also be an issue, but a good photo is usually quite adequate (in my opinion, at least) to view color, proportion, visual balance -- most of the important design parameters. Naturally, you can't pick up the piece and check its weight, or stick your finger inside to feel for wall thickness and uniformity, but it's okay to concentrate on the visible aspects to come to a general conclusion. Again, turners tend to see things in terms of their technical excellence. That's a legitimate component of the final verdict, but secondary to the overall aspect of the piece.

Critiques are always risky because people have a lot of their own ego and pride wrapped up in what they've created, and it doesn't take much to hurt feelings and/or ruffle feathers. Nor is there one final verdict on anything, as everyone's appreciation is different. The best you can do with a colloquy is to foster partial agreement. If you're lucky, everyone wins.

Like it or not, we all benefit from critiques. And, you don't need to be a certified expert, whatever that is, to venture your impressions of something. So, I'll be interested to see if we can help each other arrive at language and perceptions that are truly insightful and useful in helping us to become better turners. It's sure a great starting point for discussion and debate.

Ellis

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#5

sorry I had to miss it...

garyg in md

Crazy sked and not feeling well... ...GG

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#6

I tried

John Lucas

When I brought up the URL for the spinx piece it worked and I was able to click on that or the chat room tab and it would switch back and forth. When I tried to change the Spinx URL from 1 to 2 it locked up my computer. The first time I got back in using the Control Alt Delete procedure but the second time I had to shut down the computer.

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#7

Ellis Walentine

Technical hurdles

Ellis Walentine

Yes, John, if we're going to do critiques, we have to somehow deal with pictures. Dick Hines was unable to see even one of Frank's photos last night, so he was unable to participate. I think what we should do is hold off on more chat critiques until I have some better facility for uploads.

Actually, I am considering setting up a new messageboard just for critiques, so people can upload photos just like they do on this board. Then we can all keep two windows open -- one for the chatroom and one for the critiques board. If you set your preferences for that board to "Guestbook style", you will be able to see all pix posted on a single page. Comments may be added to each of the posted pieces.

Food for thought.

Ellis

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#8

Re: Technical hurdles

fgvanatta

I just did some experimentation with the chat room and the message boards - when you go into the chat room from the top of the message board screen it opens in a second window and the window for the message boards is still open, and it's easy as pie to switch between the two.

If we want to do critiques, it would seem that pix could simply be posted on the message board, then that thread referenced in the chat room so people could see the pix. You could have a special thread set up for critique pix only, or we could simply refer to the thread by name.

Seems simple enough to me.

Re: *** CHAT TONIGHT -- 9:30 EDT ***

#9

karl jr

Re: Technical hurdles

karl jr

Ellis, I think a board entirely devoted to crique is an excellent idea. If one posts there, there would be an understanding that it's the deep end of the swimming pool, so to speak; egos, preconceptions, or feelings will not be spared.

Cheers,

KTK