Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Lacquer over oil?

Posts

Lacquer over oil?

#1

Lacquer over oil?

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi,

Friday night I did make an ash bowl, a blank that has been in the shop about five years, so it is really dry, it is also very stringy but it felt smooth enough that I gave it a walnut oil finish. Today I touched in a couple spots and it felt like the grain raised and looking it on daylight seems I did the wrong choice and should have given it a couple coats of sanding filler and a couple of lacquer. It is still on the chuck, so I could sand some and then do the lacquer thing.

Will it work or I am asking for trouble?

Thanks for your advice

Jorge

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#2

Re: Lacquer over oil?

Doug Trembath

Jorge, walnut oil finishes have so little actual oil in them, and they wick into the wood so much it doesn't have the opportunity to develop the oil film which would interfere with the lacquer, in my experience. We used to make our own instant finish by mixing oil and lacquer and applying it while the piece was running. If you have a barrier of oil, then apply lacquer, it can separate due to minimal or no bond between the surfaces.

I'm intrigued by the grain raising, though...

Even after seven years in my shop, then moving to my new shop, (gloat), I roughed out a piece of punky silver maple tonight, and when roughing the inside, found it pretty damp. It's tough to get a piece of timber really dry through and through...

I'd use a light grit sparingly, to remove the tiny whiskers, and continue...

Doug Trembath

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#3

Re: Lacquer over oil?

Jorge Casta�eda

Thanks Doug,

I was thinking too wiping it with acetone, and then sand lightly like you suggest

In the past I was in the habit of once I have the piece shaped and mostly sanded, go over it with a rag with alcohol, it raises the grain and evaporates, then back to finish the sanding after a few minutes.

I was rushing a batch of bowls that night and did not do this, I wish I did.

Sometimes the sanding does not sever the fibers, just lays them flat, when that happens I back up a grit or two, and then to the finer grits.

Thanks again, Back to the shop..

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#4

Walt Bennett

Re: Lacquer over oil?

Walt Bennett

Interesting that you had the grain raise from applying walnut oil. I've turned several ash pieces and used tung oil on them with no problem. This is a fairly large one at about 18" diameter.

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#5

Very nice!

Jorge Casta�eda

Walt,

Beautiful piece, thanks for sharing it, nice shape.

Your ash seems to have tighter grain, mine has big pores.

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#6

Re: Lacquer over oil?

Russ Fairfield

The answer to your question could be in the brand of the Walnut Oil. Are you using the Walnut Oil sold as a wood finish, or is it a Walnut Oil that is sold as a food product in the grocery store??

Not all food oils work as a finish because of how they are processed and things that are added to make them last longer in the bottle.

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#7

Re: Lacquer over oil?

Terry Scott

Jorge I do all the time ,I sand with oil then wipe over after a day with c 3 thinners then lacquer.Ive got numerous pieces here that no bleeding has occurred.My friendly paint chemist says lacquer has a drying agent that locks up the oil

Cheers

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#8

Thanks Russ

Jorge Casta�eda

Russ,

It is oil from the health food store, "Toasted Walnut Oil", nothing else, great in salads and it gives a wonderful soft glow to many woods, specially maple and walnut, dries fast. Product of France.

I does an excellent job popping up the grain in woods like quilted long leaf maple or curly maple or bird's eyes maple.

I learn about drying oils that don't go rancid from you Russ,

Thank you!

It has been very useful, as most of my production is utilitarian bowls and platters. and they are selling

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#9

Thanks Terry

Jorge Casta�eda

Terry,

Glad to hear and good to know, sanding with oil must minimize the dust too.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#10

Walt Bennett

Re: Very nice!

Walt Bennett

It's a fairly large piece, so the pores only look small, I'll bet.

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#11

Lacquer over oil?  Yep... if...

Allen Neighbors

Jorge, I've done a lot of pieces with lacquer finish over oil. However, there are a lot of variables.

I'm not sure I would try it with a non-polymerizing oil. Unless of course, you did as you mentioned... applying a coat or two of Acetone or Lacquer thinner to alleviate the problem with the non-polymerizing oil, first.

I've use Danish Oil many times, and after curing for a week or two (depending on the local humidity), I've applied lacquer finish. Nothing has ever changed the appearance of them, and it's been several years. I think the secret to it is letting the oil cure, or polymerize, before applying the lacquer.

Re: Lacquer over oil?

#12

Re: Lacquer over oil?

Carole Valentine

I would be a little concerned that over time there would be a separation of the lacquer layer. I saw some pieces in a gallery not long ago that the finish (looked to be lacquer) was starting to peel. Anyone ever had that happen?