Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

Posts

How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#1

Steven Antonucci

How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

steven antonucci

I just finished my second weekend (2-day) "Intro to Woodturning" class. on day one, we did some basic spindle turning, covering wood, sharpening, and making sure that people could use a spindle roughing gouge and a spindle gouge. We took out 2-30 gallon pails of shavings.

After the class, we went back to the shop, where I did a demo on making hats for three guys who weren't commuting. I made mini hat that was about 7", and the three of them were also messing around on some more spindle stuff, so I decided we'd all make candlesticks the next morning. Started with the concept of design, and some thoughts around form and function, but the exercise was geared around methods of work and holding. 2 more 30 gallon pails. Left the shop at 10PM after 14 hours. Feet hurt so badly that I took an Excedrin from my travel kit that had an expiration date in 2008...

The next morning, back in the shop by 8AM cutting stock for 9AM. We started with the design exercise that we had done from the night before with the goal of producing a candlestick. In one day, the proficiency had gone from hours to minutes, and we got to focus on design and function. This lead to "Well, how do I do this?" and we were solving problems at the lathe for a good hour or so.

The afternoon was our first look at faceplate work, and we started with a small (4") bowl. I sit on the fence between "making stuff" and "learning stuff", because the class clearly had people who came to "make stuff" and by charging ahead, never got to "learn stuff". The folks that hung back and waited for the next steps learned a lot more, and ended up being the ones who started helping their peers, but I am wandering off point...

I think it was 4-30 gallon pails (I wasn't counting that closely)

Anyway, my original question is: how the heck do you keep up that pace, knowing that your probably going to double the efficiency every day? I was asked by the studio head if I would do it again next summer (yes) and if I would consider a longer class? The amount of energy (human) expended and the amount of wood consumed would be "overwhelming", and if I had to do it for 5 days, we'd be looking at a slow deforestation in the northeast...

I'm thinking 3 days for the beginner class next year, maybe 2X, and one beginner hollow turning class for 2 days to pace myself...

Back to reality.

S

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#2

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class

Jennifer Indy.USA

Steve,

My experience is you have to be really, really organized and have a plan but one that can change to fit the students you have. You never really know the skill levels of the students until you get there. Even if you are teaching an intermediate class, there will be some that should really be in a beginners class. That's just the way it is. Most schools don't have the capacity to screen students enough to know what level they really are. That's okay because when you're flexible you can adjust in a way that it won't take away from students that are already on their way. As far as chewing through a ton of wood...that's a good sign! Nothing teaches better than standing at the lathe and making shavings. One of the places I teach has a turning studio with a max of 17 students. When classes are full in a bowl class I can count on having each student go through a minimum of 2 blanks a day. That's approximately 170 blanks a week. Having two top notch assistants in those cases is the key to making those class run smoothly. It couldn't be done without them. I guess if I have any words of advice it would be, be organized, have a daily plan with demos in the late mornings. After lunch is a bad time for demos Zzzzzzzzzzz. Don't worry if you need to adjust those plans. For beginner classes I like to have assigned projects. Keeping people on track to make a specific something takes the guess work and challenge out of wondering and worrying about what to make. They can focus on technique and skill building to get to a certain goal. The main thing is to make sure everyone is having FUN!

Jen

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#3

Steven Antonucci

Some good advice

steven antonucci

17 students in one shop, huh? I'd have to pass on that...

I try to take a balanced approach. In simple terms, if the class is 16 hours, and there are 8 students, I WANT to spend 2 hours with each. The reality is that we probably burn 4 hours as a group discussing and demonstrating techniques, so I am down to 90 minutes per person. The shop assistant (which was a non-turner) kept us fed with wood, but really couldn't help at the lathe.

I struggled with "keeping everyone on the same page" and dividing my time equally. If I didn't spend more time with the folks who needed it, they got lost or so far behind. When things broke, I tried to catch them up by getting them back to where everyone else was by re-turning it for them. It was kind of funny watching their faces when I would do it, since something that they had spent 30 minutes on would get reproduced in under a minute.

I also tried to get people to work in pairs. The goal was twofold: it helped me manage the crowd (by only having one person work while the others watched) and it showed me which people "got it". Unfortunately, I had 2 guys that "just wanted to make a bowl" (even though that was not in the course description), and I sort of had to "drop them" as they were consuming the other people's "90 minutes." I did get two guys who were there for the right reasons and already friends, and they worked together vey well. (I should have split them to work with the two "bowl makers" :) )

The other four people were all somewhere in between, but general went from having never been at the lathe to somewhat self sufficient.

But if you asked me to do that for 5 days with 17 people... I'd politely decline ;)

S

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#4

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class

David Walser

My wife and I took a week long "basic" course from Dale Nish in 2003. I'm not sure how he did it because we were both exhausted at the end of the week -- and Dale is 20 - 30 years older than we are.

Reflecting on that course, in response to your question, Dale did it by being extremely well prepared. He had several projects planned -- complete with handouts -- that he used to demonstrate the use of particular tools. During the course of the week, we made three bowls (one of which he forced us to cut in half on the band saw), a platter, a goblet, a box, an egg, a table leg, and a weed pot. IIRC, the order of the projects was as follows: Weed pot (using roughing gouge, spindle gouge, and parting tool), egg (roughing gouge, spindle gouge, and parting tool), goblet (roughing gouge, spindle gouge, and parting tool), two green wood bowls (bowl gouge), platter (bowl gouge), dry wood bowl (bowl gouge), and table leg (nothing but a skew and a spindle gouge for the coves).

Before each project, Dale would demonstrate making the project. He emphasized the proper technique for each tool we'd be using. He had other projects ready in case our skills or interests made those projects more appropriate. So, in my opinion, the answer to your question is a good lesson plan.

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#5

Re: Some good advice

Barry L Elder

Steve, our Club set up a class for beginners with the help from our local State College. It was a first time effort and was run by our Club President. While things went well, there were too many students, not enough organization (lesson plan) and not enough help. The second time around was better but still too many students. Everyone turned "something" and seemed happy that they could now do it on their own. I don't know if you are volunteering for this or if your students pay a contribution, but you have my sympathy if you are doing this on your own. Your students will be very happy with what they've learned and you will be exhausted, but consider that you have contributed a great service to mankind! Teaching is something that very few can accomplish!

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#6

How to teach a week long woodturning class

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve,

Here are some thoughts - some of which you may find puzzling.

1. Take Bob Rosand's class at John C Campbell Folk School in April and observe how a well-organized class flows when taught by a master. I assisted Bob at JCCFS and learned the value of being well-prepared.

2. Expect a diverse class, as Jennifer alluded to. Figure out ahead of time how you will deal with a newbie - who is probably in over their heads. They will need some skill-building exercises and will not try every project.

3. Identify the objective(s) of the course, and then devise a lesson plan to achieve that objective. You can't be all things to all people. Limit your objectives and realize that you are not trying to develop fast-track professionals, but are trying to teach the basics so that they can take what you give them and move forward on their own. It should not be an MIT course where one takes the proverbial drink from the firehose.

4. I had a newbie in my Ornaments and Boxes class who announced that she wanted to learn how to make candlesticks. She had been allowed in the class as a favor to her when her stained glass class folded. I took her aside and explained that I would help her learn to make ornaments and or boxes, but that I was not going outside of that curriculum in fairness to the others, and that if that didn't work I would help her drop the class. Do not allow someone to derail your course.

5. I prepare a plastic container which contains EVERYTHING they will need for the course, except tools, CA glue, drills, and finish. I provide a stack of sandpaper in each box with all the grits. They purchase this "kit" and have something to take their work home in. This wouldn't work for bowl-turning, but for ornaments it does very well. Each person gets their allotment of wood and no one needs to select the best pieces before anyone else arrives. It prevents a LOT of distribution problems. I remember taking a course at Arrowmont and bowl blanks were being cut. I was the last to go over to get my wood and you guessed it. Greedy people had taken two blanks and there were none for me. The assistant cut some more and confrontation was avoided.

6. Plan your projects so that the skills for subsequent projects use the skills learned in the earlier ones. Rather than have folks learn long icicles early, I have a birdhouse ornament as the second project that has a short icicle on it. The first project is an acorn birdhouse ornament, which is simpler and has no icicle. I provide some oak for making a couple of icicles before making one from purpleheart that is placed in a sea urchin shell. Building is good.

7. I try to provide a detailed handout for each project with pictures and simple instructions. With their supply kit they get a plastic folder with 6 or 7 handouts. I asked my last class at JCCFS if the handouts were useful and got a resounding "YES!". The handouts are good enough that they can do a project on their own if they choose.

8. Don't be afraid to let folks work on their own. Sometimes they need to struggle a bit before they become receptive to doing it your way.

9. LISTEN to a student work. Often you can identify what they are doing wrong by the sound. Ask if they want you to help them adjust how they are having the tool meet the wood. Unless probable injury is likely, let them fail if they insist that they are doing it correctly. Then ask again.

10. An assistant is worth their weight in gold. I had a class where a fellow who had taught and assisted at JCCFS before and was there because his buddy was taking the class, said "I'm your assistant. I'll help you any way I can." And he did. If my class is full enough to rate an assistant, he will be the first person I call.

11. It is better if the student goes home with four excellent bowls they completed than with six average or mediocre bowls

Organize, and remember the computer adage, KISS.

Ed

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Some excellent points, Ed.

steven antonucci

Steve,

Here are some thoughts - some of which you may find puzzling.

1. Take Bob Rosand's class at John C Campbell Folk School in April and observe how a well-organized class flows when taught by a master. I assisted Bob at JCCFS and learned the value of being well-prepared.

In general, I think we were pretty well organized. I know the shop very well, and I had picked up some wet maple on the way up that we sawed for the class. We had almost everything we needed.

2. Expect a diverse class, as Jennifer alluded to. Figure out ahead of time how you will deal with a newbie - who is probably in over their heads. They will need some skill-building exercises and will not try every project.

Diverse is a very politically correct word. :) It was a true beginner class, with absolutely no prequisite experience in woodturning, so I designed the work to be aimed at skills, not projects. You run into problems when people can't get the skill from lesson 1 to be used in lesson 2. (like rounding a spindle blank with a SRG, which was lesson #1)

3. Identify the objective(s) of the course, and then devise a lesson plan to achieve that objective. You can't be all things to all people. Limit your objectives and realize that you are not trying to develop fast-track professionals, but are trying to teach the basics so that they can take what you give them and move forward on their own. It should not be an MIT course where one takes the proverbial drink from the firehose.

We started with a short discussion on this. The goal was to have them learn spindle vs face grain orientation, cutting down hill with the grain, and 4 basic tools (SRG,spindle gouge, bowl gouge and a round nosed scraper)

4. I had a newbie in my Ornaments and Boxes class who announced that she wanted to learn how to make candlesticks. She had been allowed in the class as a favor to her when her stained glass class folded. I took her aside and explained that I would help her learn to make ornaments and or boxes, but that I was not going outside of that curriculum in fairness to the others, and that if that didn't work I would help her drop the class. Do not allow someone to derail your course.

I feel better about this now that others are saying it. A couple of folks wandered off, and I let them. When they got to thir dead end, I knew that they'd have to wait for me, as I brought the rest of the class up to speed. There was some resentment, but I needed to stay on track.

5. I prepare a plastic container which contains EVERYTHING they will need for the course, except tools, CA glue, drills, and finish. I provide a stack of sandpaper in each box with all the grits. They purchase this "kit" and have something to take their work home in. This wouldn't work for bowl-turning, but for ornaments it does very well. Each person gets their allotment of wood and no one needs to select the best pieces before anyone else arrives. It prevents a LOT of distribution problems. I remember taking a course at Arrowmont and bowl blanks were being cut. I was the last to go over to get my wood and you guessed it. Greedy people had taken two blanks and there were none for me. The assistant cut some more and confrontation was avoided.

No issues with this. We used plain maple, and we only cut it as we needed it to avoid hording.

6. Plan your projects so that the skills for subsequent projects use the skills learned in the earlier ones. Rather than have folks learn long icicles early, I have a birdhouse ornament as the second project that has a short icicle on it. The first project is an acorn birdhouse ornament, which is simpler and has no icicle. I provide some oak for making a couple of icicles before making one from purpleheart that is placed in a sea urchin shell. Building is good.

Square blank-> round stick-> round stick with beads and coves-> long thin spindle with beads and coves (yes, I make them turn a trembleur!)

This does a few things: 1.) builds, as you mention. 2.) conserves wood 3.) defocuses them on "making something" and focuses them on technique, rubbing bevels, staying sharp, not pushing the cut...

In the end, they all break their sticks, and also learn that failure is a part of the process. Usually takes 2-3 hours to do this, and about 30 minutes to do it again.

7. I try to provide a detailed handout for each project with pictures and simple instructions. With their supply kit they get a plastic folder with 6 or 7 handouts. I asked my last class at JCCFS if the handouts were useful and got a resounding "YES!". The handouts are good enough that they can do a project on their own if they choose.

I'm not a big fan of handouts. We use a whiteboard, and we whiteboarded anything that made sense to draw. One of the guys commented that I should hire someone to illustrate my classes, but generally he understood things :)

8. Don't be afraid to let folks work on their own. Sometimes they need to struggle a bit before they become receptive to doing it your way.

I had no choice. I would start on one end, observe, and work my way down the line, spending as much time as I could to get them back on cutting. By day 2, we had made progress, but I can't help feeling that I would have been able to make every one of them better one on one in my shop in about 2-4 hours.

9. LISTEN to a student work. Often you can identify what they are doing wrong by the sound. Ask if they want you to help them adjust how they are having the tool meet the wood. Unless probable injury is likely, let them fail if they insist that they are doing it correctly. Then ask again.

I agree 100%. I would hear a catch, and as I walked over, I knew what they had done. I did the CSI thing: reconstruct the scene, and see if they could figure out what they had done wrong. If they couldn't, I'd hint, and then finally show them. The exercises that I had built were built to create only a few basic issues, but they didn't know that...

10. An assistant is worth their weight in gold. I had a class where a fellow who had taught and assisted at JCCFS before and was there because his buddy was taking the class, said "I'm your assistant. I'll help you any way I can." And he did. If my class is full enough to rate an assistant, he will be the first person I call.

We didn't have the luxury...he cut blanks for me, but really couldn't help much at the lathe. Perhaps, I can work one of my buddies into the course next year as a shop assistant.

11. It is better if the student goes home with four excellent bowls they completed than with six average or mediocre bowls

I think I am probably the only turning instructor that promises that you will go home with nothing as my opening statement :) I try to set the expectation that I am trying to teach technique so that you can go home and make anything, but that the class is meant to build skills and not objects. I don't allow sanding, and the one guy that was sanding his bowl walked away as a complete failure (which really bothers me personally, since it means that I failed). To suggest that it was even mediorce would be kind, but he refused to take direction and I had to abandon him.

I would like to thak you for the thoughtful response, as I try to figure out how to work with some of these challenges for next year.

Steven

Organize, and remember the computer adage, KISS.

Ed

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Sort of got there the hard way

steven antonucci

There were a couple of time where I had to catch people op by doing things for them to advance the rest of the group. If someone got a catch or cracked their bowls... I might just make a few spares for the next one.

noted and added to the preflight checklist...

Thanks

Steven

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#9

Steven Antonucci

Another question: prep for the class

steven antonucci

Do any of you have "pre-flight" check lists?

Our shop is well equipped, and are usually ready for any situtation, but I was dumbfounded by this one. As people started arriving, I started looking at how they were dressed and I wondered if it wasn't obvious?

With a class of 8 people, only one had short sleeves. I would also guess that 2-3 had on 'dress shirts' (collared, long sleeve cotton like you'd wear with a suit).

Do any of you have recommended attire for your turning student? I turn in jeans and a t-shirt, but I'm not sure if the older crowd can accomodate. I wore hiking boots, since I have stood in them with a 40 pound pack on my back (I know they are comfortable). We did have a female turnr, but she had shorter hair, so no ponytails... A pre-written list would be something I sent to the office for the next summer program.

What other 'non-obvious' things do you suggest that I suggest?

Continuous improvement...

S

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#10

Steven Antonucci

Gratis at my club, paid for this event

steven antonucci

I have done it for free at both clubs, so anyone that wants to complain, I will happily refund 2x their fees to me (usually, these events are pretty laid back in attitude, but chaotic in practice-25 guys making tools with one grinder for example.)

The course was paid, and I was paid for my time. I try to make sure that people get what they need, and hopefully, it matches what they want. Worst case, they get what they need...

My joke is "hey, if you wanted to buy a really expensive bowl, I've got to of themm down in the store, and your feet won't hurt and you won't find woodchips in your socks for a month afterwards"...

Thanks

Steven

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#11

Re: Another question: prep for the class

John Lucas

Steve Ed pretty much covered it. One thing I would highly recommend is floor matts. I think we would have died without them at the Folkschool. I stayed every night until 9PM. 13 hours with only meal breaks is a long day. As an instructor I tried to keep moving around the room. That gives your feet a break.

I've only done 1 week long workshop. Many weekend ones. I thought about everything that I needed and then added more because I was really worried about everyone having something to do for a whole week. It worked out. I didn't take very much back home.

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#12

Re: Some excellent points, Ed.

HeatherAinAK

I agree with stating the goal at the beginning. I have taken a class with Stewart Batty on 2 occasions. The first was when I was a pretty new turner and I did not understand that we would not be taking anything finished home. I kept wondering when we would start our "project". So much so that I did not focus as well as I should have on perfecting each tool technique which was the point of the class. The second time I knew the goal and did not care if I was the first to complete a spindle or bowl or whatever, I just tried to listen intently to the instructions and try to get each skill down. It was one of the best classes I have ever taken.

Heather

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#13

Re: Another question: prep for the class

Michael Mocho

Hi Steve,

I am wondering if you are aware of the teaching guide available FOR FREE to AAW members on the website at this link:

http://woodturner.org/Member/TeachingGuide.pdf

It is the result of several years of work in an attempt by the AAW curriculum committee to provide the �bones� of what goes into the organization of a turning class. While it is by no means complete for every situation, we hope that it will be a resource to those who are willing to take up the noble cause of woodturning education.

It is clear that you have the enthusiasm and energy for teaching, and sounds like you are off to a good start.

As most instructors will tell you, teaching can significantly contribute to your own skills and understanding of the variables that contribute to effective tool control, and be a great way to expand your own perspective for creativity while expanding your sense of community. It also tends to provide a new appreciation for the amount of energy it takes to organize a class or symposium, and all the many critical details involved.

I feel teaching is a craft in itself, and a skill I am committed to developing as much as I can. It is no small blessing that the vast majority of turners are so generous with sharing their insights, which has become the hallmark of the contemporary woodturning movement.

(Maybe I shouldn�t refer to it as a movement �� that has other implications that don�t smell as nice). javascript:insertTags(%22:)%22);

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#14

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class

Reed Gray

Steve,

For your feet, try www.medirub.com. It is a foot massager thing that I couldn't live without. If you are upstairs, it may drive those under you crazy, but I have it under my computer table.

robo hippy

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#15

Steven Antonucci

You are part of my course

steven antonucci

Every time we tighten all four chuck jaws at peters Valley, you get a nod...

I also borrow librally from Mark St. Leger (tongue/tung oil), Hannes (demoing hat making), JFEscoulen (trembleur turning), and Ellsworth (too numerous to count)...

I am a sum of my parts, and your visit to peters Valley (where I taught this past weekend) remains engrained.

Thanks

Steven

P.S. I did read the guide prior, and it's one of my parts too...

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#16

Mike Peace

Re: Some excellent points, Ed.

Mike Peace

I think good handouts can be a great learning tool. You may find the AAW Best Practices #051 & #052 helpful to some aspects of your teaching. Here is the link.

http://www.woodturner.org/community/chapters/practices/

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#17

Re: Some good advice

Jorge Casta�eda

Steve,

In the 90"s I was involved teaching joinery, yep, I was on the flat side, and it was a week long course, we had classes of several sizes, but by trial an error we settled on 8 persons, we were 2 instructors, so there was a lot more of the one to one feel and students walked out with a completed piece. We started from scratch and everybody choose his her own projects from a list and woods available, so the first day morning was like writing a syllabus for every project, of course a lot of the syllabus applies to all projects. Anyway having a written goal and step by step guide helped a lot.

You are lucky they are using only one tool, we had to deal with fully found wood workshop and wood mill (the area where rough lumber was converted to four sided boards, then to the shop where everybody had a bench and shared a couple tools like a table saw and a drill press, a router table and lots of hand tools.

It was rewarding see some people that walked in knowing little, walk out with a table, or a blanket chest or bookcases or whatever.

The main point is, less students, supervision when they are using the stationary tools a must, specially the jointer and table saw. And spending time with each, but keep moving so no one is left out. Another good thing happened when we let them come back to their projects after dinner, most of them were boarding at the school, but after hours they were on their own and could use only hand tools.

Good luck and enjoy it, I like teaching.

Jorge

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#18

One more thing

Jorge Casta�eda

As we had mostly boarders, early in the week at the dorm, after dinner they were able and encouraged to do so, to watch any of the tapes of master craftsmen, we had tons of them, there were tape players in every room and several in the lounge as well.

Towards the end of the week, they could go back to the shop and work by themselves with hand tools.

Now there are even more tapes, cd's and dvds you or your club can round and have them watch. That will help and reinforce what you are giving them.

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#19

Steve, I sent you an email.

Ed Moore in SW VA

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#20

Steven Antonucci

Saw it, but haven't had time to delve into it.

steven antonucci

thanks in advance for the insight, though!

Steven

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class?

#21

Mike Stafford

Re: How do you teach a week long woodturning class

Mike Stafford

I patterned my teaching after several really good instructors I have had over the years. I took the best each had to offer. Among those were Jamie Donaldson, Ed Moore and Frank Penta.

Jamie does a very fine square turning class that starts students out with simple projects that allows him to assess each student's turning skills and moves forward from there with each subsequent project building on the last. Individualized instruction is very important and Jamie does that very well. Having a good assistant is a luxury. In the class I was in with Jamie we had newbies and we had expert turners one of which turned over 20 pieces during the week keeping the assistant very busy cutting and preparing blanks.

In Frank Penta's class we were fortunate to have Alan Leland as his assistant. Between those two guys the class had some of the best technical turning instruction you could possibly want. The way Frank and Alan helped one improve their turning technique was done unobtrusively and one did not get the idea that their way was the only way. Frank provided excellent handouts. Frank offered lots of breaks for demonstrations of embellishing techniques, dyeing, texturing etc. so that people could take home more skills than the course description offered.

Ed Moore was exceptionally well organized with a nice plastic container with all materials which were of a very high quality. He also offered tools at reasonable prices that made some jobs easier to do. And he provided excellent handouts. The week I was with Ed he had the fortunate or some would say unfortunate pleasure of several other instructors making use of their resources to help Ed fill his class. Fortunately these instructors did not meddle in Ed's class and participated just as any other student.

The one common thing that all of these gentlemen possess in addition to very fine turning and teaching skills is exceptional patience which is needed when you are dealing with a mix of people. There will always be some who know nothing and some who know more than you and it is a challenge to accept the mix. The other thing that is important is that the teacher should not feel he has to spend most of the day demonstrating. Being able to spend the least amount of time at the lathe demonstrating while conveying the most essential information in an understandable manner is what makes a good teacher. Then following up with each student on an individual basis without doing the project for them seals the deal. Students come to learn and turn not watch you turn or have them do their project.