Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Exploring The New Tools Available *LINK*

Posts

Exploring The New Tools Available *LINK*

#1

Exploring The New Tools Available *LINK*

charlie belden

The Art World, but especially the Craft World, have adopted, adapted and exploited new materials, tools and techniqiues - after some initial resistance by the Powers That Be of course.

We're ten years into a new Millenium and a tenth of the way thru the Twenty First Century - and turning is still basically using 19th century tools, techniques and machines, VS and VFD motor drives and the use of more modern metals for our tools being a minor exception. This in spite of the fact that we live in the most technologically advanced country in the world - leading the Digital Revolution. OK, so the Japanese and Germans may argue that point - the French won't even bother to condescendingly poo-poo such an absurd statement.

We live in The Digital Age - yet our turnings are mostly from the Industrial Age - or even the Pre-Industrial Age.

It's not that we don't use newer versions of older technologies - electricity to heat wires to scortch, selectively burn, brand or vaporize patterns into our turnings - small variable speed motors with flex shafts attached to them, handpieces attached to flex shafts, small cutting burs, abrassive stones and sanding disks held by the handpiece to pierce, carve, and texture our pieces. We use sandblasters, pneumatic "scalers", chemical patinas, foil, gold and silver leaf, spray paints, modern dyes and finishes.

But when it comes to incorporating / exploiting available and affordable digital technology, a technology that is ubiquitous - we have digital TV displayed on digital Flat Screens, a digital cell phone on our person almost 24 hours a day, we drive cars with more computers on board than NASA used to get humans to the moon - and back, we use digital computers for all sorts of things - almost daily, our credit cards and debit cards hold digital data that gives us access to essentially digital money via digital ATMs - we don't seem to use digital technology to enhance turnings.

Maybe it's a demographics thing - a vast majority of turners came of age well before the Digital Age - and maybe those of us "over 30" can't, or choose not to, learn new tricks - "Give me my Victrola and my 78s and I'm satisfied and content.". But without New Blood, we old farts are gonna die off - and then what?

I stumbled on this YouTube video of a presentation that does a much better job of conveying what's possible now - and what is going to be possible - speech casting visible shadows, "negative space" becoming dynamic objects, objects mimicing curiousity. What if what you are looking at - could tell - and look back at you?

The presentation points out that artists have always adopted - and adapted - the technology of their time - geometry, perspective, cadmium yellow, pixellation (aka Pointalism), silk screen, lithography, photography. moving pictures, CGI - to their work The Impressionists were only able to do what they did - because of dramatic capabilities new chemical dyes brought to their mediums - that weren't there in the finely ground natural pigments mixed in oils of the older mediums. When will we turners begin adopting and adapting digital technologies to our turnings to expand our possibilities?

Just wondering. Are you?


Golan Levin makes art that looks back at you

Re: Exploring The New Tools Available *LINK*

#2

Re: Exploring The New Tools Available

fgvanatta

Let's see: I use lasers to determine wall thickness, Google Sketchup to develop shapes, and Google Image Search, Photoshop and CAD programs to conceptualize, modify, and finalize designs for embellishments on turned pieces as well as the final shape itself. I have found it is far better to create a dozen turnings on Photoshop and throw 11 away than it is to try and do it in wood. Much less expensive, also. So far I haven't found a way to cut wood with lasers or sonic generators or water jets, but I'm open to anything that will work.

That said, let me point out that I don't think it's helpful to try to use "technology" just for technology's sake - there are just some things that a chain saw does better than a computer.

Frank

Re: Exploring The New Tools Available *LINK*

#3

Re: Exploring The New Tools Available

charlie belden

People turn wood for so many reasons. For some it's the experience of the turning process - the result - merely a consequence.

For some the lathe is merely a means to an end - another tool to get from concept to reality.

I agree that the use of technology, merely because it's available, may not add much if anything to a piece, and in fact might detract from it. This is not unique to using technology. There are many turners who create things just because they can. A new tool or technique makes the difficult or impossible now easier or quicker - so the tool drives what is turned.

The Three Sisters set started out merely as pieces to experiment with - to try and work micro controlled components into turnings. But in the process I saw the potential - to convey more about each of the sisters - hints of their personalities and behavior - the fact that they are changing changlings, neither child nor adult. Static pieces just can't convey that state of changing. These first attempts are primitive exploratory steps. But even from just a few steps along this path I can see hints of interesting possibilities, promises of fertile soil in which ideas may grow to fruitiion - or not. Either way, the act of exploring can be rewarding.

Re: Exploring The New Tools Available *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

For some, the process > the end result

steven antonucci

Far from against the use of technology to advance anything, but for most woodturners that I know, it is the process that makes the do this, not the end result. we aren't really concerned with how long things take, or if some machine of technology will make the end result better, but if we, as humans, can master ourselves to produce our visions.

Over the past weekend, I was sitting with three other instructors (fine metals, painting, and sculpture) discussing the self publishing phenomenon. To each of us, we were excited by the potential that technology brought because it took something alien to us (making a book) and made it reachable. If we were people who handmade fine books, we would probably care much less for the advancements because we know how to do it at an elevated level and we enjoy the process.

I have no doubt that 10 years from now, you will be able to set a piece of wood on the lathe and turn it to a perfect form and uniformly thinly hollow it. When that is done, you will put it on a CNC machine with laser heads or high speed carving burrs to expertly pierce it and burn 3-D hollowgraphic images all over it. All of the technology exists today. A senior engineering student at a tech school could probably knock this out as a design project.

The resistance that you see if focused on the wrong things. It's not what people make, it's why they make. To some extent, I think What is more art related, and why is more craft related. Art doens't particular care "how", craft does...

Steven

Re: Exploring The New Tools Available *LINK*

#5

Risk vs Certainty

charlie belden

I think there are elements of Risk vs Certainty here.

What the misuse of technology CAN do is significantly or completely eiiminate the element of risk from the final steps of a creative process. By the time a tool gets to the wood, most or all of the creative decisions have already been detrermined. And once the process of removing wood begins, there won't be many, or any, creative opportunities to make adaptive changes to the "fixed" design - the outcome has already been determined.

The more automated the process, the less risk in the outcome. The less automated the process, the greater the risk for the outcome - but also the greater the opportunities - for creative changes to the original idea.

At "human speed" - with an attentive human on one end of the tool - there's visual, tactile and audible feedback from wood to human. And often there's time to see, feel and hear when something is wrong - a tool not cutting properly; a curve that just doesn't "look right" - with THIS piece of wood; a sound that tells you the tool is chattering rather than cutting. With that feedback, you can correct for them - OR - use what might initially seem a problem - and exploit it creatively. Chatter is normally BAD. But it can also be an opportunity to create a texture or pattern that can't be done with a well cutting edge used properly.

Since it's wood we are playing with, and each piece of wood is different to a greater or lesser degree, hand controlled cutting tools have creative advantages over automated cutting tools - in terms of opportunities to adapt to THIS piece of wood, and THIS shape or form. And that feedback from THIS piece of wood to THIS human can be the difference between a nice wooden object being made and a beautiful wooden object being made.

But it's not the use of hi-tech automated tools that I'm intrigued by - but rather the dimensions some of the avaiable hi-tech stuff bring to the creative party. LEDs add another light source to ambient light falling ON and reflected by the Outside Surface, adding transmitted light to reflected light. Small speakers, buzzers and vibrators bring the possibilities of sound to the piece and to those who experience the piece. What fascinates me though is the ability to add interactivity , to change the relationship from active viewer and passive viewee - to Two Active Participants in an experience - a dynamic interaction between two entities.

Perhaps what I'm after is that atavistic belief that all things are merely different manifestations of one thing - and am searching for ways to break down the Me, Not Me - Alive, Not Alive - illusion barrier. Or maybe playing with micro controllers and stuff to attach to them is just fun and interesting ; )