spindle elements
karl jr
Is there a typical arrangement of elements that are found on spindles? Something like filet-cove-filet-bead-filet-cove, or some such arrangement? Or details that are not usually grouped together?
KTK
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
spindle elements
karl jr
Is there a typical arrangement of elements that are found on spindles? Something like filet-cove-filet-bead-filet-cove, or some such arrangement? Or details that are not usually grouped together?
KTK
Re: spindle elements
john lucas
Karl What I did when I had the same question was to look at antiques. Everywhere I went if there was a turned item, finials on old desks and dresser, Victorian houses, stair rails, old clocks etc. I made notes and learned quite a bit.
Most details are connected with what I call a shadow line. This can be a very small detail but it divides the two details. A good example is what you mentioned, a small fillet between a cove and bead shape. Quite often there will be a narrow bead at the bottom of an ogee, etc.
Just look and make notes pretty soon you'll have some pretty good ideas of what you like.
Re: spindle elements
Russ Fairfield
The truth is that some shapes look good together and some don't. Other than that, you can ignore all of the old patterns. I don't know of any way other than a lot of practice on a lot of wood to tell you what looks good together and what doesn't.
Re: spindle elements
Rob Wallace
Karl:
You might want to look at some of Mike Darlow's books in which he explains various aspects of the design of turned spindles. I think his books are a good resource for the kind of information you seek. He does go through an analysis of historic turned forms with relation to the various elements of the spindle, and the relationships of the individual elements to one another. I suppose you could just practice random combinations of different elements and see what looks good to you (which could take a very long time), it certainly does not hurt to learn from the designs of the past or from other turners who have experience. Darlow's books have been touted as being "too technical" or difficult to read, but he does have a lot of information in them which can be valuable to the turner who makes the effort to learn from them.
Rob Wallace
Re: spindle elements
JL
John Kassay's book - "The Book of American Windsor Furniture: Styles and Technologies" is a collection of American Windsor styles.
It shows examples of various spindle turnings used in American Windsor works. If you can find a copy (interlibrary loan or spend the $60 for a new copy), it shows many examples of historical works - and a lot of spindles!
Dennis White's "Classic Profiles" is more about turning - it is a DVD.
Look at some of the old furniture catalogs and see what has worked.
Here's a good book on design elements *LINK*