Is there anyone on this site that would be willing to share some thoughts on buying a wood lathe and duplicator. I am building a Queen Ann Victorian Home and will need several hundred porch and stair baulisters and spindles. Curious if it would be worth starting a new hobby in turning.
Many of the lesser expensive lathes will not turn spindles long enough for porch balusters. Bed extensions can be purchased but add to the total package cost. Personally I would NOT like to turn several hundred of pressure treated spindles. The waste from that many of poisonous treated wood would be a huge draw back. Balusters, check local code, need to be some 35/36 inches long. My PM3520, 2HP, will turn 34.5" according to specks. By the time you include chucks or drives it is several inches less. Add chisels and the duplicator, YOU WILL NOT SAVE MONEY. The only thing that you will have is personal satisfaction. Even if you want a special pattern, you should be able to order them for less than you could make them.
There is a guy in our local club that is a professional turner. To him, to turn 100 or 200 spindles is all in a days work. Does most of it with a skew. He did a demo for us. Mounts the spindle, has a "story stick" with marks that correspond to the high and low spots and about two or three calipers. Turned the spindle in seven minutes. Finished, ready for paint. Can do it all day.
At that skill level a duplicator would be wasted on him.
If you were to buy a lathe and turn several hundred spindles, you still won't be that good and you will probably sell the lathe for anything anyone will pay. I would.
I agree with everything Bill said. With a little effort you can probably buy the spindles for abut what you would pay for quality wood.
Don't get me wrong, buy the lathe and enjoy it. There are dozens of people here who have slid down the slippery slope into the vortex of turning. It can be the fun-est part of wood working.
Thank you. I would much rather not burn myself out on volume. Love woodworking and trim carpentry. I'll wait to start turning when I have time to enjoy it.
Just like Barry says: I slid into the vortex also. My table saw, planer, mortise machine, and router have not been used for at least five years. I own seven lathes that spin daily. If you bought a lathe you might never finish that glory house.
I would advise a completely different tack. Contact the president of your local woodturning club and tell him why you are interested in woodturning. Ask him to help start you on your path. That path should include a basic woodturning class, followed by some mentoring.
You will discover if woodturning is something you want to add to your house or not.
The lathe? Buy a used Powermatic 2035B. Add a bed extension. Add a sharpening system and some spindle tools. Forget the duplicator for a while. If you make the spindles yourself you can turn the design of your choice instead of the design which are available. That may not be a big deal. But if you need a spindle a little longer than are offered at the local lumber yard you will be out of luck (or deep into the pockets).
Cost. Yea it will cost you some money. But you will be able to sell the lathe and tools for a fair price. If you make all your spindles you will save a LOT of money.
Pressure treated lumber. I am not sure why you would want to use pressure treated lumber. The victorians didn't use pressure treated lumber, they used paint.
With a bit of practice you will be able to make the spindles you want at a rate of 2 or 3 per hour.
Well I'll take a slightly different take. First of I agree with Bill. You can buy them cheaper than you can even remotely buy the equipment. Cheap lathes simply won't do the job.
Learning to turn long thin spindles is one of the hardest things we as turners do. Turning duplicates by hand is very tedious unless you have years of experience. You could expect it to take an hour apiece or more for the first 10 then you may get it down to 1/2 hr for the next 20 or so but it takes thousands of turning to get them down to 15 minutes. I've beenturning a long time and have turned a lot of spindles and I can't do it.
Now on the other hand with a good duplicator and very little practice with it you can easily turn them in 15 minutes or less. It's an very easy tool to use. However they aren't cheap and add to the total cost of doing all of this. The longer ones, just like a lathe are more expensive.
Now as far as the turning vortex goes. It's a gas but like the others have said it eventually consumes all of your time. I wouldn't give it up for anything but a good woman however.
Get a Jet 1642 EVS. You'll be able to turn 35+ inches. You would be advised to get a spindle steady (or make one). If your turnings have a minimum of beads or coves you should be able to turn them relatively quickly. The first couple will take a few hours. As you progress, they will take less and less time.