Anyone modify a chuck to add a set screw to keep it on the lathe in reverse? I have an older Axminster Chuck that I love and have used forever on my Woodfast. Now that I have a lathe with reverse, I find that sanding in both directions is definitely a good thing. I have been relying on friction keeping the chuck on, but I know it is only a matter of time before it decides to let loose. May have to actually use different chucking methods, but would prefer to modify this chuck. Just wondered if anyone has tried it before.
I have thought about it. It should not be hard to do if your insert has room to put one and a reasonably flat place to start the drill. You would just drill a hole and run a tap through it. If you've never used a tap there are some precautions to take to keep from breaking it.
My Vicmarc chucks now have a new insert that is longer and will take the set screws very easily. My older inserts I think will still take the setscrew.
So far the only time I've had my chuck come loose was when it was slowing down a large bowl. Apparently that was too much mass for the chuck to hang on unless it was really secured. I've never had them come loose when sanding.
I highly recommend using your set screw when sanding in reverse. I remember it about half the time. I've had my chuck, my vacuum chuck and my hand wheel come off. And every time I say to myself, dang, I should have used the set screw.
I used the set screw on my Nova chuck once. I turned a piece and did not get back to it for a few days. Did all the sanding and then tried to get the chuck off. Since I can be stupid at times I forgot about the grub screw.
Well after messing up the first thread on the spindle I remember the screw. I was lucky that it was not too bad and could be fixed with a file.
When I get a new insert now I toss the grub screw in the trash. I had rather have to chuck come off than mess up the spindle threads.
I used the reverse once to sand. I then took the bowl off and put on a new chunck of wood to start a new bowl. Man were my tools dull. I sharpened them and they were still dull. Boy did I feel dum, had to look around to make sure no one was watching.
That when I decided I would be safer not to turn that day.
I have two set screws in each of my Nova chucks. I position them in the adapter in such a way that they lock against the spindle behind the threads. This is on a Powermatic 45. That way if I forget to loosen them I won't damage the threads. The theory being I'll wake up before I trash the spindle threads.
now you all have me wondering if I should bother. I turned a couple more bowls tonight and sanded, using reverse, and had no issues. Maybe it isn't worth it. Certainly wouldn't want to trash the threads on my new baby.
but one of the auld British authorities used to recommend a heavy leather washer under the chuck. Apparently the combination of the "crush" and friction would be enough to resist spinning off under sanding pressure.
Again, never tried it, and some of the old techniques are not well known now for good reason.
Umm...well, you could get a Oneway lathe. The spindle is hardened and it has a groove to accomodate the setscrews on the Oneway chucks. I turn left handed on the outboard side of my lathe. I ALWAYS tighten the setscrews before turning. Well, once or twice I didn't and was lucky that the piece just wobbled a lot after I started turning but didn't become airborn before I managed to hit the stop button.
The shaft on my lathe still bears the marks of the one or two occasions where I used the set screws. Did not like it, quit doing it.
What I find is that if you screw the chuck or faceplate on and either hold the shaft with one hand on the hand wheel or lock the shaft and give the turning a bit of a snap for the last 1/4 turn it will seat and not come off from sanding. In fact, if I turn the piece and then sand without removing it, the effort of turning it will seat the Chuck or FP well enough it won't come off. Takes about the same energy to "unsnap" it. I think some of the production turners have been known to use the lathe to spin pieces onto the shaft quickly. I would not suggest that, you might find them nearly permanently mounted.
I have had two pieces unscrew themselves. One was a heavy piece I had just put on without the snap and the lathe was in reverse. It unscrews and sort of plopped onto the ways. Very undramatic. Another one started to unscrew and I turned it off, Screwed it on better and went on.
I've wondered about this too, since my chuck insert doesn't have a set screw either. It seems to me that you would also need to glue(?) the insert into the chuck or it could unscrew itself there even if the insert was anchored to the spindle with a set screw.
All my chucks (Nova) that have inserts came with a set screw to lock the insert and chuck together. You should always loosen or remove that set screw before you attempt to remove the insert, otherwise you will expend a lot of energy you didn't have to.
I have three chucks, all made by Nova. All of them have the set screws to hold the insert in the chuck, which I use.
But neither of them came with set screws to keep the chuck from coming off when reverse turning. I found out I could buy the inserts with the set screw already in them, but I figured if they could drill and tap a hole in the insert, I could too.
I drilled a hole and tapped it for a 1/4x20tpi set screw. The first time I put the set screw in, it marked the thread on my Spindle adapter (which is also held in place with a set screw). So, I really tightened down hard on the set screw... harder than I normally would have, and it really scarred the thread. I then used a small file, and dressed the thread where it wasn't a problem with installing and removing the chuck. It has worked for several months, now. I'm glad I did it, because now I turn in reverse, almost as much as I turn in forward, when I'm turning a hollow form by hand (without the captured rig).
I also marked the spindle thread on my little Vicmarc lathe (it has a dedicated chuck), and dressed the marred thread the same way. I've had no problems since.
All 3 of my Delta lathes have an unthreaded area at the bearing end of the spindle for the set screws to lock down on - no damage to threads. I have added allen screws to chuck inserts and face plates that did not come with them. I use a drill press and a couple of V blocks, drill and tap. No big deal and I reverse sanding between every grit change. Really improves the finish.