Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Bowl Gouge or.....????

Posts

Bowl Gouge or.....????

#1

Bowl Gouge or.....????

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Hi All,

As I continue my foray into the slippery slope of turning I was at Woodcraft picking up some supplies and began looking at bowl gouges as I do not have anything that resembles one or any hollowing tool that seems right or comfortable to me.The prices ranged from $39.99 for a WoodRiver to around $70 for a Sorby.While looking at the banner ads here on WC I clicked through to the Hunter tools.The #3 Hunter tools looks to be about the right size for my needs.Smaller lathe(Delta Midi) the tool is about the same size in length as my current tools ,direct from Harbor freight.The #4 Hunter tools is much larger as were some of the tools at Woodcraft which seemed too large for my scale of lathe/intentions.I like the replaceable carbide insert,less sharpening for me,etc.The inserts are not cheap but I would presume they will last quite awhile.

Is there any significant reason to not jump right to the Hunter tool vs buying a"standard" bowl gouge?

I realize it is more cost upfront but it seems to me that it could almost be used as a universal tool for bowls,hollowing,shaping ,etc.

Am I expecting too much of one tool?I am a novice at turning and not sure what is next but I'd like to try a small bowl or two and I am not comfortable with the few tools I have.

Thanks,

Andy

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#2

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

Dennis Ford

A Hunter tool works great for hollowing end grain, fair for side grain. I would not consider it a substitute for a bowl gouge. If cost is a concern, Benjamin's Best (sold by Penn State) is a good gouge at a very reasonable price.

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

Steve Kubien

The only experience I have with the Hunter tips is in my Jamieson Hollowing Rig. It does a fine job but there is no way I would give up my bowls gouges for plates, bowls and a myriad of other tasks. Get a bowl gouge and learn to use it. They're insanely useful.

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

Richard Allen

Bowl Gouge.

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#5

Thompson Bowl gouge

jake Niedling

I would buy a 3/8" bowl gouge from Thompson tools. You will be glad you did. This one size will do almost everything you need for platters,bowls,boxes and some spindle work.

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#6

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

robo hippy

For me, I would consider 2 tools as necessary for bowl turning. The bowl gouge (Thompson are the best), and a round nose scraper. I am a minority when it comes to using scrapers. Particularly when starting, a round nose scraper, on its edge (45 degree angle) is the best tool for removing tool marks from the wood. Once you learn fine control with the bowl gouge, your shear cuts with the scraper will become less and less. It also makes a handy roughing tool as well. The only other tool I would suggest is a parting tool, or sizing tool, or Bedan. Variations of the same thing, but used to make a mortice (recess) or tenon for using your chuck.

robo hippy

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#7

As a more experienced novice ....????

Henry (raleigh NC)

As a more relative novice I asked this same question a year or two ago. I had read about carbide tools and the concept of not having to sharpen was very attractive. The simple answer I rec'd then is the same answer that you seem to have rec'd in the posts above; it remains a valid answer from my perspective - buy a bowl gouge and learn how to sharpen. You'll never be sorry that you did.

I did exactly that, and I have basically learned how to both sharpen and use the gouge. Ellsworth's book was most helpful for me in learning the different cuts, especially the finishing cuts. My turning is improving so I am a more experienced novice. At this point the tool is not limiting my turning and I don't see a carbide tool in my immediate future.

Henry

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#8

Re: Thompson Bowl gouge

Bill Neddow

I agree.

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#9

Re: Thompson Bowl gouge

John Lucas

Me Too. Although I'm a fan of Hunter tools in my hands they are more of a specialty tool and excel at certain jobs. The Bowl gouge on the other hand is great at a whole lot of jobs. In my mind it's probably the most versatile tool out there.

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#10

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

Barry Irby

This has been interesting for me. I took a class from David Ellsworth about ten years ago at Arrowmont and have had one of his signature gouges since then. Its a half inch shaft. Its my go to tool. Do everything under the sun with it. Bowls, icicles, dowels, spindles, roughing, everything. I am still using the same one. I have no experience with Hunter tools except the one in my hollowing system from Lyle Jamerson, but have not felt eh need to buy one. (If I had some spare cash, I would buy one in a minute to play with it, but times are tough.)

So, my limited experience agrees with the others above. (Some of them have turned more bowls than I have even seen pictures of.) Get a bowl gouge, set yourself up to sharpen it and learn to use it. It is very versatile, long lasting, and you will like it.

I would replace my setup in a New York Minute. A slow speed grinder, an Ellsworth sharpening jig, and a premium Ellsworth gouge. There may be others that are as good, but that's what I have and I am sticking with it.

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

#11

Re: Bowl Gouge or.....????

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Thanks all for the advice.I went with the PSI set of bowl gouges.I figure I can learn/trash one and still have two others when I feel better about my skills.

Once again the resources at WoodCentral provide the help I need.

Thanks,

Andy