Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

What caused this mark?

Posts

What caused this mark?

#1

What caused this mark?

Charlie Anderson

A friend of mine took down a tulip poplar in his yard. Here's a cross-section.

Lightning?


img

Re: What caused this mark?

#2

Re: What caused this mark?

Joel

an over cooked cat?

Re: What caused this mark?

#3

It is not nice to make fun of cats...

A Cat


We disapprove of it

Re: What caused this mark?

#4

JL

Re: What caused this mark?

JL

Tulip poplar often has black/green areas. That is probably the most intense case that I've seen.

Possibly minerals in the area? I had one come down in my old yard that had some nice coloration like that.

Re: What caused this mark?

#5

Steve Kubien

Re: What caused this mark?

Steve Kubien

In my expert opinion, it's a severe case of "darned cool!"

Re: What caused this mark?

#6

Re: What caused this mark?

Jorge Casta�eda

Charlie,

Most probably a broken branch way up or a wind shake, then rain started getting into the hearth wood.

That's my theory and I'm sticking to it.

Re: What caused this mark?

#7

Re: What caused this mark?

Barry L Elder

God, Supreme Creator, Mother Nature, take your pick!

Re: What caused this mark?

#8

Re: Could have been lightning, or......

JamieDonaldson

..metal in the wood, or several other scenarios. But the results are excellent for you!

Re: What caused this mark?

#9

Re: What caused this mark?

ed hoxter

charlie, i wish i had a cross section of that. it would make a great wall hanging. ed

Re: What caused this mark?

#10

How large is this across?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Some wood species turn rapidly when first cut, due to the oxydation of the moist surface, but they may not be dark like this down in the wood after it is dry.

If this is a pretty large tree, sometimes the inner roots that supported the tree when it was smaller get smothered, and die. This looks kinda like that may have happened, and this is just the early stage of decay. After another 20 years or so, this wood would be rotted away, and hollow a few feet up the trunk.

Re: What caused this mark?

#11

Re: What caused this mark?

Dick Coers

I've always been told mineral stain. It will turn brown with UV exposure. If it was lightning, you would see something raidiate out to the bark. Well usually that is. That is really nice!

Re: What caused this mark?

#12

Re: What caused this mark?

Matt Birchfield

I agree with Dick.

I harvest a lot of Poplar from the West Virginia mountains... it's mineral staining that will unfortunately, and inevitably turn to brown. Even brown, however, it still makes a striking bowl!

Re: What caused this mark?

#13

Re: What caused this mark?

robo hippy

I would think equal parts mineral stain, and starting to decompose due to water getting inside the tree. If it smells sour, then for sure starting to rot.

robo hippy

Re: What caused this mark?

#14

Re: What caused this mark? - not lightning

Larry Litwin

When lightning hits a tree it superheats the sap turning it to steam and exploding at least part of the trunk. Mineral staining with possibly some fungal staining as well.

Re: What caused this mark?

#15

Re: How large is this across?

Charlie Anderson

The diameter at the ground was about 4 feet.

Re: What caused this mark?

#16

Re: What caused this mark?

John Jordan

Lightning is usually the cause of blue/purple colors in poplar. Really. :) Rude Olsolnik showed me examples, and I have one of his pieces turned from it. You can often detect a burnt smell.

John

Re: What caused this mark?

#17

Re: I was driving Rude to lunch....

JamieDonaldson

...in Berea one day when he saw such a lightning struck poplar log on a logging truck, and he made me follow that truck all the way to the mill so he could buy it. I don't remember if we ever got to eat lunch?

Re: What caused this mark?

#18

They are purr...ty

Don Evans

Re: What caused this mark?

#19

Re: What caused this mark?

Terry Scott

At a guess because the trunk has that crack water has got in reacting with the tannin and fungus spore

This maybe the first signs that the tree would have roted out in years to come leaving it hollow