Here is my latest piece. The brown you see was the only truly solid bit of this spalted maple. The rest was all rotten to varying degrees. The collar, spalted maple dome and finial are all on piece. I intended to permanently affix the collar but messed upt the order of operations. 8" tall with the finial/lid and 7" wide with or without the lid ( )
About the finial, it appears to me that it is a tweener. A little taller and it would be more elegant. Shorter and wider and it would have been a nob. It just seems stuck in between. For my tastes maybe if it would have been thinner it would have been more pleasing to my eye.
I am not "sold" on the finial either. Luckily, nothing is permanent in that regard. I've got a bunch of cherry to rough out this week but I'll go back to the drawing board (and the lathe) after that.
It is a great looking urn Steve. Looks like a very fine final resting place.
The problem I have had with creating these (the majority of mine have been small chests and did not necessarily incorporate turning) has been making sure I understood what the owner intended to do with it. For instance I have had several people who wanted to put the cremains inside the opening while still in a plastic bag. That is fine as long as the bag will fit. Others wanted to dump the cremains in and seal the lid. For that reason I have made the opening in the bottom of the chest more often than the top. It was far easier to conceal the opening by having it on the bottom. One particularly troublesome project involved creating a chest with two compartments to accommodate a couple who did not want to be commingled in eternity even after having been married for over 50 years. I guess, enough is enough. To solve that problem I actually created 3 lids; an outer lid which was hinged over two inner turned lids.
There are a whole myriad of issues which could come up in making urns. To bag or not to bag, number of occupants, internment in a niche... I suppose I get around a lot of these by posting them for sale on my site or in a gallery and then folks commission a custom urn to suit their needs. All I have to do is tell them whether or not I can do what they want (physically or technically "do" it or want to go through the mental hoops to figure "it" out).
I've never made a flat-work urn/box. Judging by the prices some folks command for them, I have totally missed the boat. I guess some people figure that they can gouge others on price when it comes to things like this. I mean, I've seen mitered cornered (doweled and pinned together), basic boxes in bland walnut sell for $300. Why, because it is an urn? It's not much different than the covers people sometimes use for their boxes of kleenex in the bathroom. just because you CAN get a certain price for something, does not mean you SHOULD.
Sorry, going off on a rant here which could upset a lot of people.
Steve, I was a flat woodworker for many years before I started turning and as strange as it seems I started turning because I was searching for ways to embellish/decorate my flatwork boxes. I have made a number of cremain urns over the years and most resembled little block front chests. There was a lot of work involved in them and they were much more than mitered corners and dovetails. It seems that most people did want the cremain box to be constructed of walnut so you were right about that part.
As a turner I have turned two urns and I much prefer to build my chests which seem to have more permanence. The last turned urn I did was really just a large version of one of my boxes.
Sorry to hijack your thread but I cannot remember many previous discussions on the subject other than inquiries about the required volume.
My comment about the mitered and doweled boxes is only for many of the ones I have seen. Really, most of what I've seen is crap. The ones from the big companies aren't too bad, they just all look the same.