Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Giant tree, no wood...

Posts

Giant tree, no wood...

#1

Giant tree, no wood...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

So I am at the shooting range blasting away with a couple of new pistols. In between volleys, I was removing my hearing protection to pick up spent casings for reuse later on. While I was scouring the ground, and wondering where one of my shooting buddies and sometime woodturner had gotten to, I heard a very loud cracking noise that sounded like a whole bunch of guns going off at once. I looked around the corner of the berm, and saw this.

Photobucket

A HUGE tree had come crashing down, trapping me on the wrong side! There is a stream on one side, a huge berm on the other, and me on the wrong side of the tree, and my chainsaws at home. I assessed the problem, and walked down to the groundskeeper's residence. The good news was, he was at home. We started in on clearing some of the brush, but it is going to be at least a day before my truck is free. The bad news is, it is willow. It is rotten in the middle too. It's no good for turning, no good for burning. It's just a big rotten tree in the way.

Here is a view from the other side. Lots of soft rotten wood. :( At least it will give me some stories to tell.

Photobucket

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#2

Steven Antonucci

Making you a "weeping BIll-O" 

steven antonucci

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#3

As with bad drivers,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

it's better to see that kind of sight in front of you than right up close to you.

Someone's shot go astray and break the last bit of sound bark?

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

Dennis in Southern Oregon

uh, Bill what was bore of the pistols you were using? :\

Dennis

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#5

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

I returned to the scene this morning after dropping SWMBO off at work. The guys who assembled yesterday evening after I left managed to get the road clear enough to drive. There looks to be some good wood further down (good for willow that is) so I think I am going to make some bowls for the guys who did the work. It wasn't just for me that they cleared the road, but I was the immediate beneficiary.

The main bole looks to be around 30", but the leads crossing the road where they cut through are only about 18" and 12". There is a lot more work to do, but traffic can now pass.

Steve, that pun was awful, even by my standards.

Bill, I was very happy to see that at far away as I did, I can tell you that! There is a law enforcement officer on another board where I participate, and he has a dash cam picture of a tree falling just in front of his car, and him throwing it into reverse at high speed to get away from it. That's too much excitement.

Dennis, you laugh about that. I had transferred the one pistol earlier yesterday, and was at the range to make sure it went bang the way it was supposed to. It is a .45 ACP, and we were joking around in the store about the people who talk about how a .45 slug just has to pass near a person to knock them down. On this board people look at the tree and figure out what kind of chainsaw to use. On the gun board the guys are talking about how much ammo and of what type to cut it in half and get through.

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#6

Ellis Walentine

Which begs another question...

Ellis Walentine

...*Can* bullets or shot be used safely and effectively to knock off dead limbs that are too high to reach by climbing?

Ellis

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#8

Steven Antonucci

Watch Mythbusters for the answer

steven antonucci

There is an episode in which they pose the question: Can you fell a tree with a machine gun?

The answer is yes, if it is a 50 cal. It was on fire when it fell... :)

S

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#9

Ellis Walentine

Yikes

Ellis Walentine

At fifty rounds per second, I'd be raining bullets over the whole township. I had in mind one well aimed shotgun round. :)

Thanks for the eye-opener.

Ellis

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#10

Re: Which begs another question...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Ellis, your best bet would be a shotgun. It is extremely dangerous to shoot rifle and pistol bullets into the air. That means staying away from the heavier shot shells as well, like 00 buck. They have to come down somewhere. And even with a shotgun, you would have to be fairly close to the limb, close enough that you could saw it down anyway.

As has been mentioned, one can use automatic fire to cut down a tree. It is quite expensive to do so. I was invited out to a full auto shoot on Independence Day. A 30 round magazine dump out of an M-16 lasted about two seconds, and cost $12.00. Lots of fun, but something you can't do every weekend. And to cut off a small branch, you would need a lot more than one 30 round mag.

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#11

Re: Yikes

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Using the going price of 50 cents per round of .30 cal ammo, they spent about $1100 to cut that tree in half. That doesn't count the time spent to prep or maintain that mini gun before and after! :O

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Which begs another question...

Dick Hines

Did you notice ther was little or no recoil.

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#13

Re: Which begs another question...

John Lucas

Ellis when I was growing up we used to shoot Misteltoe out of the top of the tree using a 22. Of course that was out on the farm many miles from anything. One of our favorite sports was to put ballons on a kite and fly it and then shoot the ballons. Of course where I live now is way to populated and I would never think of shooting a bullet into the air. I would probably kill someone a mile or more away. Then again it might make my neighbors move.

We also used to shoot over trees with my uncles 8mm mauser. It took about 5 or 6 shots. You could barely see the holes in the front side of the tree but the whole backside would be blown out. Who needs a machine gun.

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#14

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

Bob Macgregor

Bill, did you try to drag the tree out of the way with your truck? On dry pavement, with 4WD and that heavy hook under the front bumper, I'd think a good pull with a chain would have been able to rotate it enough to drive out.

BOB

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#15

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Bob,I have a great chain, 5/16" links, and a 20,000 lb test nylon towing strap as well. They were both in the barn from use on the tractor. Even so, the root ball alone probably weighed almost as much as my truck, and it was hanging over the edge of the embankment in the air. I could just see me starting to drag the thing one way, and all of a sudden as balances shifted, it starting to drag me back the other way! :O

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#16

Steven Antonucci

Another episode covers 'Shooting up'

steven antonucci

If I recall correctly, the Mythsbusters team discovered that shooting straight up returned the round to the earth in a non lethal manner, since the round goes up, stops, and then gets all of its energy from gravity. I think the issue was that the bullet does not have enough mass to be lethal (they also disproved the 'death from a penny thrown from the Empire State Building' myth for the same reason)

However, if you fire the bullet at an angle, it flies in an arc, and returns to the earth with some of its initial momentum, and potentially lethally (depending on the angle).

Practical physics...

S

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#17

Just yell "hey bubba watch this" then your covered

John Lucas

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#18

Re: Another episode covers 'Shooting up'

Randy Gleckler

And..... I found out that the research they got from that was actually used by many different groups in regards to the results According to Adam from the show. (They just did a 2 hour staff favorite show and talk about the fact of how useful those results were)

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#19

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

Jimmy Edwards

Bill my Chevvy Silverado will jump or fly over large obstructions like the tree. Look for the lever or switch under the seat

Re: Giant tree, no wood...

#20

Re: Yikes

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Wow! Yikes is right! It was amazing how little kickback there was to that beast! They sure used a lot of lead to take it down, but it was very impressive.

Neat link! My two boys and I love that show, but we haven't seen that episode.

Mike

Sticking with the chainsaw in Apex, NC!