I think I must be doing something wrong when I apply the white diamond and I don' have with any of the other steps. Whenever I use the white diamond the white power is spread around on the smooth finish making it look hazy. If I apply more WD to the wheel and go back over the bad spot it looks great but I have a hard time believing I need to re-apply WD to the wheel every 20 seconds or so. I do not have this problem with the trip. compound, in fact it almost looks better before applying the WD
It's been my experience that too much white diamond is the culprit.. I barely touch the wheel with the WD before I start buffing.... and often "unload" the wheel on some scrap wood before applying a tiny amount of WD and buffing a piece.
As Marc said you are overloading the wheel. What finish have you put on the wood. If you have a high gloss finish top begin with you will dull it slightly with any polishing medium.
Also, in addition to not overloading the wheel, use a very light touch; don't push the piece against the wheel, but let the fabric of the wheel just graze the surface.
Pressing the piece against the wheel can overheat the finish and make a big mess. ~Doc
Take the sharp corner of a board and hold it against the wheel. That will remove much of the excess white diamond. Do it several times if necessary. Then try buffing again. I think the others told you the problem just not how to solve it.
You can find instructions including videos from the company ath their site http://www.bealltool.com/instructions.php
As others have said, go light loading the WD on the wheeel. No more than one second touching the wheel with the bar whereas you may go about three seconds loading the Trip. Also, you don't press the work hard against the WD wheel. Finish must be dry. That means not being able to smell any solvent. For me, I generally wait a minimum of three days for AO or DO finish and usually a week.
It sounds like you are using too much of it, as others have said.
I have written instructions and several short videos on using the buffing wheels and the compounds on my website at the below listed link to my webpages.