Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Finish Test Stage 2

Posts

Finish Test Stage 2

#1

Finish Test Stage 2

George Guadiane

I have a nice piece of Norfolk Island Pine that I want to give that transparent finish I see on many Hawaiian pieces.

One of the important things to getting that translucence is to get good penetration of the oil finish...

I had this idea:

I thought that a vacuum might better get the oil to penetrate into wood.

I wondered if the Bush Oil finish that I use would damage those big vacuum bags that you can use a vacuum cleaner or hand pump with...

So I cut the corner off of one small bag and soaked it in the finish for a couple of months to see how the bag would hold up.

I just took the bag out of the finish and it looked GREAT. So I got another (quart) bag and picked a small piece I did with my beta Nano Revolution tools. It didn't have much finish (oil)

I filled the piece with little glass marbles (to reduce the volume of liquid I would need) and then filled the little HF with the oil I had soaked the bag corner in - with me so far???

The first picture is of the filled HF in the vacuumed bag in front of the "safety can" that I'll use to hold the bag, in case the bag doesn't act the same under a vacuum.

The second is in the can open and in the can closed.

In another couple of months, I'll take the piece out and empty out the marbles and finish then let it drip out, wiping off excesses till it gets dry. If this process works, I'll try it on a bigger piece. Eventually, I'll try some of the BIG bags to see if THEY will hold the finish and not break down... If I have success, this MIGHT be a good way to apply finish more quickly and deeply to provide a better finish.

I'm hoping to hear comments and suggestions on this

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#2

Richard Allen

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

Richard Allen

Most finishes cure in the presence of air. If the oil finish soaks in deeply you might have a problem with the finish curing. This might not be an issue for you. I mean who cares if the oil in the wood cures?

I mention this because I recall a story about a oil finished turning was ship by air to a gallery show. The air pressure of the flight appears to cause some of the oil contained within the turning to be forced out onto the surface of the turning. A woodturner who was local to the gallery show was contacted and asked to "fix" the finish.

Good luck with the experiment.

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#3

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

George Guadiane

Thanks for the heads up Richard.

I had not thought of that particular issue, and I don' have any gallery waiting for my stuff, but from what I understand, part of the translucent "thing" is penetration... If the oil doesn't get in on the first try and a "hard" surface forms, it seems like additional applications might not get the result I want, so I'm trying this. From what I understand, they submerge the finished bowls anyway, this just adds a bit more incentive for the oils to get into the wood... It's a test, the worst thing that could happen is that it doesn't work - I have more wood.

After I'm done finishing it, perhaps I'll put the piece back into another bag and vacuum it after I think it should be dry, just to see what happens.

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#4

Ellis Walentine

Need a quicker procedure

Ellis Walentine

Most vacuum impregnating processes I've heard about involve placing the object in a vacuum chamber, pulling a vacuum to get all the air out of the pores, and then flooding the chamber with whatever you want to fill the pores with. It's almost immediate. I wouldn't have the patience to wait months for the oil to soak in.

I'm wondering if you couldn't rig up some kind of alternative vacuum chamber with the appropriate check valves and an oil injection device of some sort. Maybe Schedule 80 components would do the job.

Ellis

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#5

Re: Need a quicker procedure

George Guadiane

Thanks Ellis,

But I'm only planning on doing this on one piece. If I were to decide to do a quantity, I might consider bells and whistles, but not at this time.

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#6

Re: Need a quicker procedure

Don Orr

As Ellis has alluded to, it's really not the vacuum that pulls the oil into the wood. The vacuum pulls air out of the wood and then the release of the vacuum pushes the oil into where the air used to be. Clear as mud? I've not done it, but have worked with some extreme vacuum in my time. This is the way penturners stabilize their blanks I believe. This whole process should not really take longer than how long it takes to pull a good vacuum.

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#7

Actually makes perfect sense!

George Guadiane

So, by releasing and rebuilding the vacuum I might get better penetration faster?

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Actually makes perfect sense!

Brad Vietje

George,

What Don Orr wrote makes sense, so I want to think on it a bit...

I can relate how a different form of vacuum embedding works, which may have wood finishing applications:

I used to do a lot with electron microscopes, and one method of tissue preparation that allows cutting extremely thin slices (500 angstrom to 5 Nm) is probably a lot like impregnating wood with stabilizing resins so it will cut smoothly on the lathe.

Completely over-simplifying the process, the tissue was embedded in epoxy by being submerged in the polymerizing resin (an epon-araldyte epoxide that's a lot like West System epoxy), and as the vacuum was applied, any air bubbles in the tissue were essentially "inflated" by the negative pressure, which helped them bubble up, out of the liquid resin, and the volume would be replaced by the liquid. Then the heat could be applied to polymerize the resin, before or after the vacuum was reduced or released.

With woody material like, say, um, wood or pine needles, etc..., there can be a lot of trapped air that can interfere with complete impregnation. As it turns out, most soft tissues (brain, kidneys and such) don't have much trapped air, and might be stretched and distorted by expanding air bubbles, but there were many times when I used a vacuum embedding process for certain tissues.

It's pretty darned amazing how many little techno-geeky parallels there are between turning wood and my medical research/histology/anatomy background (sectioning with various microtomes and such is much like getting the perfect finish cut with a skew), and my optical & telescope making hobby (abrasives used for grinding and polishing optics are the same ones used for wood finishing).

Hope that helps in some small way...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#9

karl jr

Re: Actually makes perfect sense!

karl jr

Brad, please expand on this. It seems your knowledge of vacuum impregnation may be useful. According to my scary scientist friend, anyway. Maybe we can use this with DNA? BTW my buddy Pinky really likes the AC. She doesn't huff and puff like the big bad wolf when we chill out.

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#10

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

Juergen

I've had good luck with using diluted WATCO, 50/50, in a sealed container for 3-5 days. Capillary action is adequate to totally infuse the turning. As noted by Richard it takes a while, a week or so, for the piece to cure.


Here another piece using the same technique


This one was done the hard way turned to 1/64" thinness top to bottom, but it took only one coating of WATCO.


Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#11

Finish Test Stage 3

George Guadiane

Thanks for the images and info. I don't know, but the vacuum may just take the days of soaking down to hours or minutes... Like I said, it's just a test.

I took the vase out of the oil and am letting it dry. I'll post another picture when it cures.

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#12

Vacuum aided penetration is one thing...

david

but may not be the only process bringing out the translucence. Ron Kent has remarked that he feels that it is the drying process after the immersion that causes polymerization of the Norfolk Pine and the resultant translucence. He felt more polymerization occurs each time the process is repeated. It may also be that he wet sands after each soaking--at least I got the impression that he did. Of course it helps if the walls are very thin, but then handling of the piece gets to be an issue. In the end, I think you need to have all the elements together--a great form, technique to achieve a certain level of thinness, spalting over a certain time period, and a minimum of about 5-6 immersions.

Re: Finish Test Stage 2

#13

Re: Vacuum aided penetration is one thing...

George Guadiane

Thanks for the additional information.

I'll core the piece I have and try stuff on the smaller pieces, in hopes of getting that classic result.

G