Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic
John Lucas
This is a continuation of the critic's to see if we can learn something. This is a piece of the maple tree that Vicki and John had cut down. It's about 3 1/2" across and tall. I thought this shape would fit the piece of wood well. This is a case where I could use all of the wood and still get a nice shape. I tried to get it pretty round but missed. If you look at it carefully you will see that it starts off nice but as it gets around 1/3 way down the curve changes a little more sharply. Sort of a Maxwell Smart kind of thing. I missed it by that much.
I think the foot is just hair too large and maybe too thick for this size bowl even though I took it down twice. Because of the way the bottom rounds over I might have been better off if I had removed the foot entirely. I say this because of the way the curve goes flat on the bottom.
I like the lip. On this type of vessel it seems to set it off. Since it was cut well away from the pith the rim doesn't distort like in the other two vessels.



