Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

Posts

Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#1

Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

John Lucas

This is a continuation of the critic's to see if we can learn something. This is a piece of the maple tree that Vicki and John had cut down. It's about 3 1/2" across and tall. I thought this shape would fit the piece of wood well. This is a case where I could use all of the wood and still get a nice shape. I tried to get it pretty round but missed. If you look at it carefully you will see that it starts off nice but as it gets around 1/3 way down the curve changes a little more sharply. Sort of a Maxwell Smart kind of thing. I missed it by that much.

I think the foot is just hair too large and maybe too thick for this size bowl even though I took it down twice. Because of the way the bottom rounds over I might have been better off if I had removed the foot entirely. I say this because of the way the curve goes flat on the bottom.

I like the lip. On this type of vessel it seems to set it off. Since it was cut well away from the pith the rim doesn't distort like in the other two vessels.


Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#2

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

Stephen Mushinski

Excellent project John. Very nice bowl also. It is pretty hard to argue with your observations but I do like the foot and I do not think the size is wrong either. Looks like you are having a fun which is all that really matters!

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#3

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

Dinyar Chavda

Hi John:

Agree with you about the foot.

Re the part where the curve becomes steeper---what if you sanded down to reshape the part above where the steep slope starts. Would that reduce the visual impact of that change in the curve?

Love the lip.

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#4

Steven Antonucci

So, now what?

Steven Antonucci

I agree with everything you said, and that begets the above question- what are you going to do about it?

I don't know if there is enough material to recut the lower curve, but that would be my first thought. If it was "just any old wood", I'm sure you would too, but given the provenance- what do you do?

Steve

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#5

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

Matt Overton

I'm not sure the foot fits for me. I agree with the curve, Sorry Chief! Love the lip.

Matt

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#6

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

John Lucas

Dinyar it probably would change it but would have to be done by hand now. I'm sure the bowl has warped because it was quite green when I started.

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#7

Re: So, now what?

John Lucas

Steve Not much I can do now. It's too thin to change anything and probably warped by now. This is just a learning experience. I'm sure you do the same thing. If you try and analyze what is wrong hopefully you won't make the same mistakes again.

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#8

do nothing is correct

bob davis

have you ever produced anythin that in hindsight might be a little different. anice piece enjoy it.. :) :)

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#9

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

John Jordan

You better get Vicki a picture of that. :)

John

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#10

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

John Lucas

John When I finish the other pieces I'm making she will get all the photos. I'm having a ball with this stuff. It's good to take a break from the normal routine every now and then.

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#11

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

david

John, like others I agree with your self-assessment. I think the 'bump' in the curve 1/3 from the bottom can be taken down enough to make the line more flowing to the base. Re-mounting does not necessarily depend on the piece being true if you are working just on the bottom area. Hard to say for sure, but it looks like you have enough wall thickness there. I would have left out the foot, but that is just my preference in most cases.

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

#12

Steve Kubien

Re: Vicki Jordan Maple bowl critic

Steve Kubien

I just received my box of Jordanian Maple today. Got a show this weekend but will get into it next week, I hope.