Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Decentralize

Posts

Decentralize

#1

Decentralize

Brian George

I posted this on the AAW Forum yesterday. I would like to hear some feed back:

[A fantastic conversation indeed.

At the risk of having more shot(s) at me, let me suggest some more food for thought.

We have 9 members on the BOD. Six candidates are selected, chosen, blessed, or whatever for the next election to the Board by existing BOD members and committee.

We the dues paying members then have the obligation of voting for the three we wish to represent us. The top 3 vote getters then become BOD members with the fourth sitting in vitro.

Here it comes...

How about splitting the 326 clubs into 9 regions as per legal governmental boundaries? In other words, by state/province/territory/country. Each region then holds a vote for the person who will represent them on the BOD.

Decentralization of the so called power structure and giving more control to the membership as to who represents them.

If it ain't broke don't fix it but, if it is then decentralize giving back involvement to the membership.]

Re: Decentralize

#2

Re: Decentralize

George Guadiane

Having regional representation is probably a good idea. I need to think about it a bit.

Re: Decentralize

#3

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Decentralize

Barb Siddiqui

Me too. Don't want no 'Electoral College,' that's for sure.

Re: Decentralize

#4

Re: Decentralize

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

So the Southwest "representative" with 500 members in his voting block will have the same say as the rep from the Northeast who has 7,000 members?

"Wait, we'll even things out by drawing "districts" so that the reps have equal constituency." So who determines the districts? How often are they adjusted for population shifts? Does the term "gerrymandering" ring any bells?

Can AAW dues be used for campaigning? Can candidates form committees for fund raising or accept contributions to themselves by members supporting them?

Should the AAW Director candidates be selected by way of primary elections in each 'district'?

How about a 2-party system? Artists vs. Crafters sound about right?

Shall we just move the AAW offices to Washington, DC?

True to my role here, I'm not throwing "Cold Water"; merely asking y'all to think about the consequences of what you propose.

Re: Decentralize

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Decentralize

Richard Allen

There are all kinds of ways to nominate board members. There is an AAW committee for that. The members of that committee currently are:

Dale Larson (Chair)

Frank Amigo

Malcolm Zander

You can e-mail the committee atdale@woodturner.org about criteria you would like to be considered.

BTW look at the current board members distribution. NY, IL, OR, CO, TN, NC, SC, AZ and Canada

Re: Decentralize

#6

Food for thought

Ron Sardo

Mark Mandell Said:

Should the AAW Director candidates be selected by way of primary elections...?

Re: Decentralize

#7

Re: Decentralize

Cyril Griesbach

Mark, in my pre-retirement life I was a state co-director for the Airborne Law Enforcement Association and our regions and regional directors were set up just that way and it worked just fine. If memory serves, and it doesn't always, the ALEA is/was about the same size as AAW.

But, be sure that your point was not lost on me.

Re: Decentralize

#8

Re: Decentralize

Art Liestman

For what it's worth, the AAW studied the question of decentralizing in 2004, that is, whether the idea of regional representatives on the board would be preferable to the current system. I know this because I was on the committee of 6 that did the study. Several members of the committee were initially in favor of the change. After two months of soliciting and obtaining feedback on the idea from individual members and from chapters, the committee unanimously recommended that we not make the change. That, of course, doesn't mean that it shouldn't be reconsidered, but I just wanted to let you know that such things are thought about from time to time. The AAW actively seeks ways to improve.

Re: Decentralize

#9

Re: Decentralize

Brian George

BTW look at the current board members distribution. NY, IL, OR, CO, TN, NC, SC, AZ and Canada


I have no problem with the current candidates and their geographic distribution but, it seems to me that if there were regions, there would be a greater opportunity for involvement at a more local level.

Re: Decentralize

#10

ROTFLMAO

George Guadiane

In spite of all the reasons you managed to think of showing that it would be difficult and might even just not work, I have to say in my own defense that I was thinking it might make things better.

I also have to say that when I got to the Artist V Crafters part I had to stop and get a tissue.

I'm "SURE" that your "mean spirited" post was intended to "break the back of the opposition" (whoever that is), but on this one, I guess I surrender... (maybe this is why I put the idea on the back burner?)

Re: Decentralize

#11

But As Mark Points Out

George Guadiane

It might almost take Jerry Mandering to do it.

Or a House and Senate?

Re: Decentralize

#12

Always

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

happy to entertain, George.

With so much material being passed around the forums, it'd be a shame to ignore the opportunities.

I'm actually a little surprised (but not disappointed) that somebody didn't take me seriously. "Yo, if t'was go enough fer Washington and Jefferson and the US of A, it'll be good enough fer the AA of W!"

I'd be waiting for the election challenge to get to the Supreme Court with Scalia repeating his "You lost, get over it!" response.

The Lacers' issues aside (which are really private matters), the temperature of collective bloodstreams over what amounts to a largely trivial situation is amazing. People getting wildly exercised, choosing up sides, busting up friendships over what? Corporate by-laws? Every one of those dues-paying members got a copy of those very provisions every year; didn't hear anybody pounding the table then. And they all renewed their subscriptions, er, sorry, mem-ber-ships, and didn't say a word about who has power to do what and why. For 20 years those bylaws have been there with very slight changes, and nobody said "boo!"

Damn, if you don't like the way the thing's being run, tell'em to stick their damn magazine (which you don't like either 'cause it's too damn artsy fartsy) and spend your $50 on something else worthwhile, like buying your wife her favorite flowers now and then when it's not a holiday. You can still go to your local turning club and get just as much out of that as you ever could. And who knows, if the AAW starts really losing membership, maybe those people who are really dedicated to it will take notice and get off their stumps and do something about it.

But enough already! The hostility, polarization, outright hate-speech, and wild hyperbole that's been plastered all over the AAW forum and spilled over here and other boards is ludicrous.

People have been acting like a bunch of small stockholders asserting some kind of ownership rights to the AAW. It's a total farse. Members pay $50 in dues and they get 4 or 6 rather thin magazines a year (if the postal service doesn't eat them, that is), a nice phone directory, and the chance to vote for people to act as unpaid managers who they don't know, and will never meet. That's it folks, that's all you get, and nobody promised you any more than just that. The AAW is a public charity. It belongs to nobody except itself. It's not your turning "club." It doesn't exist for your personal benefit even though you gave it money. Get over it.

But because these elected people made an unpopular decision regarding a popular individual and carried it out with a distinct lack of sophistication and tact, this is justification for the authorship of hate mails and demands for the opportunity to pillory those same managers who were presumptuous enough to think they might be doing some good for the craft? This is crap out of a bad "B" movie.

Ye gawds, people, get. . . . .a. . . . .life!!!

Re: Decentralize

#13

Barb Siddiqui

Off the tracks

Barb Siddiqui

Mark, I'm searching my mental files for an appropriate 'bad lawyer' joke to fit in here, but can't come up with one. :-) Maybe that's all the AAW is to you, but it rather matters quite a lot to me. I live in seclusion without any nearby turning clubs, woodworking guilds or local retailers for tool purchases. Yes, really, believe it or not, there are many places like that. Belonging to the AAW is a true benefit to my wood turning exercises. I'm proud to be a member of it, in spite of all this. And I want it to succeed, to improve, and to grow in respect among its members and the general public. Our little red wagon kind of crashed this month, but we'll get the wheels back on. And.. I do have a life. Methinks you need to relax, yourself.

Re: Decentralize

#14

Bravo!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Barb, you're right on track. And you should join with other responsible adults just like yourself, and address what you feel will be improvements in the AAW. But do so out of your own dedication, not out of overarching anger over what somebody did or didn't do, and leave the name calling out of it. You won't get anything done otherwise because people, wrapped up in charges, countercharges, and defense postures, will neither cooperate nor communicate effectively. The globe of frustration and blame will continue to feed upon itself until it finally destroys that which you value.

I see the AAW moderators moved all the threads to the defacto "back porch". Not a bad idea. People who, in fact, want to get something positive done, will still go there and communicate. Those who just want to ventilate and see their demands on a billboard, will fade away, and maybe you'll get something done. Good Luck, Truly.

Re: Decentralize

#15

Barb Siddiqui

Honey vs. Vinegar

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Decentralize

#16

As One Of The Small Stockholders

George Guadiane

Mark,

I don't NEED the last word, but I can't take the attack without putting up a defense. My response to your Artists V Crafters post was honest, whether you were serious or not and intended as an olive branch. I was hoping we could get back to turning stuff. Because you made me laugh didn't mean I "changed sides."

I take exception to much of what you just said. Morals and ethics are not a small thing. How my representatives treat other humans (in my name or in my supposed interest) is not a small or private thing to me.

It's not just about corporate bylaws, its about how they are used and/or circumvented to get an outcome, regardless of what is honorable.

You wrote "But enough already! The hostility, polarization, outright hate-speech, and wild hyperbole that's been plastered all over the AAW forum and spilled over here and other boards is ludicrous." then went on to further engage in it. Using words like small, farce, expressions like "Ye gawds, people, get. . . . .a. . . . .life!!!" show your disdain pretty clearly, I think.

I will, unequivocally agree with you about hate speech and what must have been pretty nasty emails to Russ. That kind of behavior is totally unacceptable.

Take a look at your post, see if you can find where you stopped responding to me and went back to selling your position (which I still don't buy).

G

Re: Decentralize

#17

Re: But As Mark Points Out

Brian George

George,Mark has pointed out a lot of things. Doesn't necessarily make them valid though, does it!

I wonder what the heck those guys back in the late 1700's had for cold water advocates.

It seems to me that going forward from here is fraught with unknowns and that can be good as well as bad.

Someone posted on the AAW Forum that the idea of 12 to 15 regions was suggested before. Didn't fly. Sorry for that. From the many posts about this whole fiasco, it seems to me that there would be more transparency and open communication with the membership if there was regional representation.

If there was regional involvement. If there was club involvement.

To the doubters I say, "Damn the torpedoes, full speed ahead!"

Re: Decentralize

#18

Last Word

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

is your, George.

Been away for a few days so late getting back here.

Don't, however, misunderstand me. My position is that the rhetoric in this whole thing has been inflamed all out of proportion to what actually 'might' have happened which, from all appearance, is pretty normally the way such thing happen.

So, amend those By Laws if y'all wish, but do so with eyes to the future in the bright light of what has past rather than by some knee-jerk set of provisions that will hamstring the organization.

And a suggestion: The AAD, as a NFP being dependent upon volunteerism as it is, needs a detailed Ethics Code to guide those in all levels of management.