Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

Posts

I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#1

I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

Brian George

and he was just finishing up a doctors appt at Mayo Clinic in Rochester. Apparently he had some shoulder injury that needed attention.

I told him that I had taken a few arrows myself lately.

My entire purpose in AAW 5% was to create discussion and visibility to the (IMHO) shortcomings of the By-Laws and need for transparency.

To that end, it has been successful, not that the discussion would NOT have taken place anyway.

Names continue to come in.

I have searched and searched for an email that I sent to the BOD much earlier (many months ago, actually) about the make up and content of the American Woodworker.

In essence I stated that as our chapter continued to grow, we were getting more and more members that necessitated us having a "school" to help them get up to speed. Many beginners.

In that letter I expressed that as current members of AAW, we were encouraged to explain and pitch the value of AAW membership. I also expressed my sense that the journal did not do enough for the beginner to intermediate turner.

Not one BOD member, NOT ONE, bothered to even acknowledge that they had received and read that email. Maybe, in hindsight, it was addressed to the wrong people. However, not because of me personally but, because as a club president I had expressed a concern, there should have been some response.

Frustrating, to say the least.

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#2

Betty Scarpino

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

Betty Scarpino

Brian,

All emails sent to the AAW board, whether they be positive, negative, and in between are answered by someone. In the past two years, I have witnessed various board members' faithful attention to responding to every email. And if a message concerns the journal, I am informed of the contents and I also reply.

I am sorry that you had a negative experience. I'm guessing that your letter was not received because I sent you an email yesterday and I have had no reply. Perhaps your email provider has a filter? Or perhaps you have just not responded to me yet?

BTW, picky point, but the title of the journal is American Woodturner.

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#3

Re:I keep hearing rumbles from AAW ....

JamieDonaldson

.....chapter members that the Journal is too artsy in orientation, that the little guys want more basic subjects published. No magazine can be all things for all people, and I think Betty is doing a good job of mixing material subjects so that everyone has some of "their stuff" represented. This is an open ended subject for which there is no definitive answer.

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#4

Walt Bennett

Re:I keep hearing rumbles from AAW ....

Walt Bennett

I did have a long conversation with Betty earlier today and brought up this same topic. She pointed out that there are in fact articles for beginning wood turners in every issue (true), and that she puts some in that give tips for them in her articles on more complex things (true).

There is a kind of give and take on this. How many articles on basic skills are there? How many can be in the Journal before they get repetitive? If someone becomes a member, they can go through the online issue database and find all kinds of them.

I agree that more focus needs to be made for the beginner and the hobbyist/ intermediate level turner. I'm not certain how that needs to be made though.

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#5

Steven Antonucci

I know the answer: someone has to write them!

steven antonucci

And the infamous someone is: well, you (all).

If nobody writes a 'beginner' article, or a 'how to', how can anyone expect to read it? The membership provides the material we all read. If you think it's missing something, then get out your wooden turned pen and write the article!

I have one in the queue and two more that need to get done...

S

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#6

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

Brian George

Betty,

That was an unintentional error on my part calling the journal the ...Woodworker instead of the ....Woodturner.

I did receive your email requesting to be added to the AAW 5% list.

I am behind in replying to all who have asked to be listed. It is good to know that the journal is trying to keep an historical record of the goings on.

Th email to the board WAS sent. Of that I am certain. Two things have happened since that email was sent. My machine crashed necessitating a new purchase and I have started using a new os(Linux) and browser/email with the new machine.

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#7

Betty Scarpino

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

Betty Scarpino

Brian,

I intend to be transparent about my request to be part of the 5% club. I am sure you know that I support the decision and actions of the AAW Board. One of the complaints about the board's actions, however, is that six board members worked together without informing two other board members until the proposal was put on the table for discussion and voting. Your group has the right to work in that fashion, too. I am simply interested, for the record, of knowing that whatever you do is done in a manner in which you suggest the AAW board ought to operate.

I appreciate that you and the others care about the AAW. It is not my intention to present arguments, simply to observe. You have the right to exclude me from your group, but doing so will send me a clear message. Even so, I respect your decision.

Re: I talked with Alan and Mary a couple days ago

#8

Right ON STEVE.

John Lucas

If you don't feel your writing skills are up to par don't worry. That's part of Betty's job, editing to make it more clear to the readers (and better english than I just used). If you need help on the photos just ask. I'll be glad to offer any help I can.