Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

McNaughton Coring System Issues

Posts

McNaughton Coring System Issues

#1

McNaughton Coring System Issues

Dick Strauss

I tried to contact KM about the issues with my coring system. Kel responded by saying that he didn't have any record of my emails to him from a few years ago (no great surprise). After being somwhat insulting in his opening, he suggested the system should work right based on the basic dimensions I provided to him. He was not willing to work with me based on the basic data provided.

I politely responded that I was still hopeful given the specific dimensions provided below. I also provided some additional information that I thought he might find informative. He has yet to respond over the last 3+ weeks so I assume it is a dead issue.

I'm posting the dimensions of my set here so that others aren't stuck in the same boat with knives that are hard to control without modification. I'd suggest you measure your system right away upon receipt if possible. Regardless of what the manufacturers spec is, I would immediately ask for replacement knives/blades for any gaps bigger than 0.010" on the standard set. It may not be your technique that needs fixing but rather the tools themselves!

The thickness of the standard knives vary along their lengths from tip to handle as follows:

smallest radius...0.220, 0.221, 0.223"

middle radius..... 0.234, 0.231, 0.234"

large radius....... 0.228, 0.228, 0.227"

straight blade.... 0.231, 0.233, 0.229"

Turret post gap width (standard opening)... 0.241"

As you can see, there is not much consistency to the thicknesses of the knives. Hopefully this has improved over time. One knife has as little as 0.007" in the standard gap while the other has at max a 0.021" gap. The 0.007" gap feels quite secure while the 0.021" feels very sloppy. This 0.021" gap allows for the knife to rock a few degrees in each direction while"captured".

You can simulate this with a 1x4 board with 1/4" rounded corners (just like the coring knives). Place the board in a vise with an opening that is 1.1" wide (or roughly 10% wider than the thickness). You can tilt the board a few degrees to one side or the other. This blade tilt translates into one side or the other of the scraper tip hitting the wood first and will make it very difficult to core smoothly while not getting catches.

My solution is to use a piece of thin metal and wrap it around the turret post when coring with certain knives. Don't put yourself in my position... return anything in question before it is too late to reolve the issue.

Take care,

Dick

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#2

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

Dick, you don't have to fool around with shims or worry too much about the thickness of the blades. As you are starting to cut, lift the handle up lightly and twist the handle clockwise. Once the cut is started, the force of the wood coming down on the tip of the cutter will hold it in the correct position.

On my system, the turret has four pins in the blade is constrained with a T-Bar. I think it is more important to adjust the height of the cutting tip to be right on center when the cutter is fully extended. In addition, I give both sides of the blade a shot of WD-40 before starting to cut. I also touched up the cutter with the diamond hone before starting each cut.

Attached is a picture of three cores that I made today.

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#3

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

robo hippy

Dick,

I am not up on 0.00 type measurements. I have enough trouble with 1/16. I wouldn't want it to be tight, there is always some pitch/sap/wood chip build up on the blades, and the turret tends to twist, so a tight fit would make it difficult to slide through the turrets. I would want at least 1/16 gap with the blade in the turret.

robo hippy

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#4

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

Wilford Bickel

Dave,

I am no expert metal worker but have to do it here on the farm and can tell you that when you bend metal (hot or cold) it will stretch and/or compact in the bend. This is the nature of the beast. I really don't see any problems on the numbers you give for coring wooden bowls. If these were parts going into an engine - there might be a problem but for our use they look fine to my limited knowledge on metal bending. Unless we all wanted to pay Kel to set up to mill the blades after bending you are going to have some of this variation but it does not cause a problem rough coring bowls. Like Reed says you must have some clearance between the posts and the blade or you will bind while coring. Not sure where you are located but if near Alabama let me know - I teach lessons here at the shop and can get you going on this system in one day. The main thing to keep in mind is DON'T drop the handle and raise the tip - keep the blade up against the back bar on the turret at ALL times when cutting.

Wilford

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#5

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

Wilford Bickel

Dick,

I apologize - don't know how my mind got your name as Dave. The gray hair kicked in again!!

Sorry,

Wilford

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#6

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

dick strauss

All I ask is that you measure your knives at three points along the curve (beyond the cutter tip cutaway) and report your findings here. Please also include your gap measurement as well.

Thanks,

Dick

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#7

Steven Antonucci

Bending metal

steven antonucci

Certainly, I am not an expert, but I do occasionally hang out with the blacksmiths at Peters Valley, so I have learned a couple of things.

When you bend metal, you are compressing it on the interior of the curve, while stretching it on the outside of the curve. Imperically, the more radical the bend, the greater I would expect the variance from the initial stock. In addition, most steel from the mill has some variances "built in"- the specs are within a certain tolerance and not meant to be perfect to "zero thousandths".

I don't know what Kelton's manufacturing process is, but I can tell you that the kerf that the knife cuts more than accomodates the variances in the cutters. As for "slop" in the gate, even 20 Thousandths variance (1/64th) wouldn't allow the tool to rotate enough to matter.

Steven

P.S. Spent my Saturday night with these guys smelting iron into high carbon steel...


Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#8

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

Carole Valentine

This whole thing about splitting hairs on measurements is ridiculous. When I first started coring I had a some problems. Saw some posts about blade shape, gap, etc. and thought "Ah ha! Has to be the tool, not me!" Well I hate to burst anyone's bubble or bruise anyone's ego, but it WAS me and my technique, not the tool. I am not going to go through measuring everything again but I can assure you that I have plenty of gap and wiggle room, my blades vary a thousandth of an inch in various places and if they ever followed a perfect curve from the factory, they don't now and I have had no need to tweak them.

Most people learn the system just fine with practice. Some never do. Put on your big boy pants and move on for goodness sake!




Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#9

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

Dick, the only measurements that are important is that a) the blade be thinner than the tip, and b) the blade move freely between the posts. That's about it. We ain't building a watch, we are hacking a chunk of wood out of another chunk of wood. This is not a precision operation here.

Re: McNaughton Coring System Issues

#10

WhoooHoooooo

Barbara Gill

You go girl; it looks as if you have the "evil tool" tamed with that one handed technique.