McNaughton Coring System Issues
Dick Strauss
I tried to contact KM about the issues with my coring system. Kel responded by saying that he didn't have any record of my emails to him from a few years ago (no great surprise). After being somwhat insulting in his opening, he suggested the system should work right based on the basic dimensions I provided to him. He was not willing to work with me based on the basic data provided.
I politely responded that I was still hopeful given the specific dimensions provided below. I also provided some additional information that I thought he might find informative. He has yet to respond over the last 3+ weeks so I assume it is a dead issue.
I'm posting the dimensions of my set here so that others aren't stuck in the same boat with knives that are hard to control without modification. I'd suggest you measure your system right away upon receipt if possible. Regardless of what the manufacturers spec is, I would immediately ask for replacement knives/blades for any gaps bigger than 0.010" on the standard set. It may not be your technique that needs fixing but rather the tools themselves!
The thickness of the standard knives vary along their lengths from tip to handle as follows:
smallest radius...0.220, 0.221, 0.223"
middle radius..... 0.234, 0.231, 0.234"
large radius....... 0.228, 0.228, 0.227"
straight blade.... 0.231, 0.233, 0.229"
Turret post gap width (standard opening)... 0.241"
As you can see, there is not much consistency to the thicknesses of the knives. Hopefully this has improved over time. One knife has as little as 0.007" in the standard gap while the other has at max a 0.021" gap. The 0.007" gap feels quite secure while the 0.021" feels very sloppy. This 0.021" gap allows for the knife to rock a few degrees in each direction while"captured".
You can simulate this with a 1x4 board with 1/4" rounded corners (just like the coring knives). Place the board in a vise with an opening that is 1.1" wide (or roughly 10% wider than the thickness). You can tilt the board a few degrees to one side or the other. This blade tilt translates into one side or the other of the scraper tip hitting the wood first and will make it very difficult to core smoothly while not getting catches.
My solution is to use a piece of thin metal and wrap it around the turret post when coring with certain knives. Don't put yourself in my position... return anything in question before it is too late to reolve the issue.
Take care,
Dick








