Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

AAW 5%

Posts

AAW 5%

#1

AAW 5%

Brian George

My name is Brian George and I AM a member of AAW and proud of it, even though recent events raise questions. A group of us started a chapter here in Eau Claire, WI about 1 1/2 years ago and are 62 members strong. One third of our membership are AAW members and many of them are VERY upset.

I am starting a "5% Committee" to get to the bottom(or top) of this ASAP.

I have already sent an email to 35 AAW members that posted on the "Mary Lacer" thread on the AAW website and am getting positive responses back.

I have NO interest in being on the AAW BOD. My only interest is openness, fairness, clarity, and equity to all of us members. If you are interested email me at: "captainbg.gmail.com

It only takes 700 members of AAW to cause some action to take place.

If you are interested in being part of the "5% Committee" send me the email with the simple phrase, "include me in the 5%!"

My goal is to have AT LEAST 1200 signatures.

Brian George

AAW member #34307

President and Founder

Chippewa Valley Woodturners Guild

1.715.834.8749 (home)

1.715.559.0073 (studio/shop)

Re: AAW 5%

#2

Re: AAW 5%

Brian George

Yesterday afternoon, I sent an email to 35 AAW members that had responded to the "Mary Lacer" thread on the AAW website. The list was in no way intended to be secret or limiting. It simply was the approach to creating some positive input from the vast AAW membership to those responders of that thread.

I have NO, I repeat, NO agenda, other than to bring to the forefront answers to many of the angry frustrations that this abominable situation has created for our excellent organization.

I seek nothing other than openness, clarity, and involvement in the process as a responsible member of AAW

and the turning community in general.

Re: AAW 5%

#3

Re: AAW 5%

George Guadiane

You can count me in, from what I understand, some (most?) of that 5% can send their proxy voting rights to a person closer to the meeting and have it count!

If we can't get the board to make substantive changes as a result of their handling of this situation then we should take it upon ourselves to figure out what needs to be changed in the bylaws and get er' done.

Re: AAW 5%

#4

Re: AAW 5%

Ken Grunke from SW Wisconsin

In my opinion, the bylaws are the most important thing to change, or as Mark Mandell points out, the Articles of Incorporation, to give due power to the members the way other organizations of this kind do (as Alan Lacer points out in his AAW forum posting).

I quote Mr. Lacer from that posting:

"Did you know that the AAW is the ONLY major craft organization in North America that allows board members to remove duly elected or appointed board members? See the risk for politics and corruption? Same is true of the AAW bylaws: the only major craft organization in North America that allows boards to change the by-laws: the norm is that ONLY the members can change the bylaws. It would be as if the US Congress could readily change the constitution as they see fit�boy, would we be in even deeper stuff if that were the case. Both of these situations need to be rectified. "

I believe this should be a first priority, and the logical course of action seems to me to be to petition the current BOD towards this end first before attempting a recall. I don't feel that demonizing them right off the bat is a good approach, this whole mess can be worked out in a positive and pro-active way or at least an attempt made to do so before going for more drastic measures.

My two cents, since I didn't renew my AAW membership this year.

Re: AAW 5%

#5

It's Good To See You!

George Guadiane

I saw a post of yours on WOW, before that, it was like you moved to a mountain top in Borneo. I hope to see you around often, and I couldn't agree more.

Re: AAW 5%

#6

Re: It's Good To See You!

Ken Grunke from SW Wisconsin

Well, about a year ago I came to the conclusion that I spend too much time looking at the woodturning forums, as my interest in woodturning had been on the wane for a while before that. It's starting to come back to me now, but I promised myself I would try marketing the creations I already had on hand from previous years which have just been sitting around gathering dust, before I get too enthusiastic about creating new stuff. The ol' Jet has been dusted off and oiled, I have a good stockpile of raw wood to play with, and I need to make my hobby pay for itself so I'm giving Etsy a try:

http://www.etsy.com/shop/naturalrotations

So far, not a lot of encouragement from sales but I'll give it time and keep it going for a while since the Etsy shop doesn't cost me much other than my time for making the listings.

Good to see you too, and thanks!

Re: AAW 5%

#7

Re: AAW 5%

Dave Moore

What Ken is saying sounds like a good direction. I'm not interested in any revenge nonsense, or any spitefulness, there's too much of that in the world already.

But certainly I would support any movement toward transparency and accountability.

The idea that any portion of the AAW Board can initiate the hiring of "transition" consultants and get a strategy rolling like the one we've just seen executed without all the BOD being in the loop is simply wrong.

For the BOD, any BOD, to work as intended all the BOD members have to be involved in the entire process, and complete and detailed minutes of the meetings should be published in timely fashion. That way everyone knows the score and there are no dark corners for rumor mongers and angle-shooters to ply their trade. Part of the BOD seems to have simply navigated around another part to get done what they wanted to get done, which means they disabled those members from effectively representing those who voted for them. Not good.

If it's the by-laws that have to be modified, or the Articles, whatever is necessary either way. The BOD has to have some lines that can't be crossed with regard jacking folks around like we have just seen.

Sure the AAW is incorporated, but it's an incorporation of woodturners, and we tend to be justifiably proud of the fact that we just don't do to each other like that.

Incorporating as a nonprofit doesn't mean we have to embrace the kind of disagreeable baloney that is so commonplace in much of the competitive business world.

I'd be open to other changes I haven't thought of too, if they make sense and they're not mean-spirited.

The sign in my shop says; "Be nice, or be gone."

There you have it. ;)

Re: AAW 5%

#8

Re: AAW 5%

Bill Youngblood

Morning Brian,

Can you please give better directions to your post? Was it on the AAW web site or the AAW Forum site and if so under which title? There are a dozen or so related to "Mary Lacer". I am definately interested in your movement, but I really don't have time to read through all the posts ... again. Thank you and I will be waiting to hear from you.

Re: AAW 5%

#9

Re: AAW 5%

Cyril Griesbach

Brian,

What I see from a quick reading of the By Laws of the association is that the Board has far too much power to introduce changes without input from the membership.

They can remove and replace elected members without membership approval. This being the case, why have elections at all?

They can change the by laws without membership approval. A recent look at the by laws shows, at the end of the document, that they have been changed several times in the last four or five years and I, for one, was unaware of such actions and the changes made are not noted.

They are not held accountable for promptly publishing the minutes of their meetings. Only this recent outcry regarding Mary Lacer has caused the minutes of the last few years to be made available. To say that the minutes are lacking in detail is a gross understatement. It has been said that minutes need not be made available until they are approved at the next meeting but I find that unacceptable as well. The minutes of the meeting are the minutes of the meeting whether they have been approved at the next meeting or not. If the next meeting results in some changes to the minutes then they can be revised with the changes noted.

I believe that it can be said that we, the members, have trusted our BOD over the years with little membership oversight. Recent events indicate that we should not be so casual in this regard. Having said that, I'm also of the opinion that an outright removal and replacement of the directors would be disastrous. Let the elective process take it's course in this regard.

I do believe that the membership needs to move forward to correct the sections of the by laws that address the removal and replacement of board members without membership approval, that changes to the by laws can be made without membership approval and the timely and complete posting of the board meeting minutes. I would also suggest the addition of a member committee to oversee the actions of the BOD. I'm not exactly sure how this can all be done but the "5%" provision is the likely process if the board is unwilling to take such actions itself. The president and others have, on various internet turning forums, called upon the membership to stand by them and let this current dilemma settle. However, they could, in the interim, go a long way toward restoring some membership confidence in the board by taking action to make the changes I've outlined above without the membership taking such action on their own. Count me in the 5% willing to make these changes if the BOD is unwilling to do so on their own.

Re: AAW 5%

#10

Re: Transparency

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

As you all rush headlong into this, you'd best get some real (paid-for) legal advice. For instance, in many states, a company meeting concerning severance of an employee is required to be "closed door" and the minutes and notes as required to be sealed so as not to prejudice the employee's search for a new job. The same principal applies to gag a former employer from disclosing details, even really "bad stuff," in response to subsequent employer's inquiry.

Consequently, your quest for this prized transparency on every BoD meeting may actually be illegal where you propose to enforce it.

Re: AAW 5%

#11

Re: Transparency

Dave Moore

Yes Mark, that's correct.

BOD's can, and should, go into executive session for discussions relating directly to employee performance matters, and the minutes of such meetings are not released publicly. It is, as you say, the law most everywhere and that's as it should be. There is a duty to protect employees privacy, and that's good.

Having said that, if the BOD meets to discuss hiring an outside agency to give legal and/or tactical advice for future planning for the organization, that is not a personnel matter directly, though any recommendations received from any such agency could certainly have personnel implications included on down the road.

No reason for a decision like that to be taken by anything other than the full board, and no reason for that decision not to be recorded in the regular BOD minutes, neither of which seem to have been done in this instance.

The other points raised above regarding the authority to change the by-laws are entirely valid concerns also. It makes no sense for a small group of folks to have the authority to change the rules by which they are supposed to operate any time they feel like it. May as well not have any by-laws at all if that's the way it's set up.

I don't think anyone thoughtful is advocating going in there like Genghis Khan and cleaning everybody out, I'm certainly not interested in that. I'm not even wanting to insist that the decisions just made are voided even, though if it turns out that the manner in which those decisions were made was irregular enough to violate existing rules they might have to be, I'm not a lawyer so I don't know.

What does interest me is exploring ways to ensure that the BOD is required to be accountable to the membership for its actions. Excluding Board members from any decision making process disables that member from properly representing those who voted for them, and that's no good, it should never happen, and if it does the membership should have the means to discover it and hold the responsible parties accountable.....

I agree it's complicated, and a cautious and thoughtful approach will be needed. You know, babies and bathwater and all that.

The AAW is not perfect, and can't be everything to everybody all the time, but it's been of value to me in many ways and to many others, so it's worth it to me to give a little time to leveling things out. If that's possible.

That's just how I see it right now of course.

Re: AAW 5%

#12

Re: Consultants

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Dave,

I just went through the AAW By-Laws, and there appears to be no provision in them that requires Board action to retain a consultant (or search co., or lawyer, etc.). Thus the President could do so on his/her own initiative, pursuant to that office's rights, authority, and obligations, and you, loyal dues-paying member, would not see that retention reflected in any BoD Meeting Minutes until, and unless, the consultant made a formal presentation to the full Board.

It seems to me that a number of people, perhaps only the several "fora" members I see posting angry messages, are pushing for changes, but nobody seems, as of yet, to have any detailed idea of what to change and how such changes will effect all the other parts of a large organization's operations.

People complain about the BoD minutes. Would they wish such minutes to be stenographically taken down by a certified court reporter and then posted? Do people really want 5-10 THOUSAND dollars [$4-7 per page] of their dues spent just so they can slug their way through committee reports etc.? The result may, instead of "transparency" be suppression of honest debate and new ideas if Directors will be subjected to every word they say being dissected or quoted out of context or cross-examined on some Internet forum. In fact, you might find it rather hard to find anyone who would be willing to serve as a Director in such an atmosphere. You, for sure, would get me in that boardroom!

The old saw applies here, "Be careful what you ask for. You might just get it."

Re: AAW 5%

#13

Re: Consultants

Dave Moore

Mark, hey I don't disagree with the points you raise...it would be all too easy to mess things up even worse by making it impossible for an intelligent BOD to do its job, and then as you say nobody in their right mind would even want the job ...

Like I said, baby and bath water. But it does seem to me that for a Board to have complete control of the by-laws under which they must operate is asking for trouble, and we sure got some of that.

Look, I'm not foaming at the mouth here, I'm just looking at what is, to the degree that any of us can see what is, and wondering aloud if some fine-tuning might be in order.

The other alternative is simply to forget the whole thing and hope it always plays out for the best.

The problem is, or one problem anyway, that in any dues paying organization the members generally like to feel assured that the folks with the purse strings are behaving in accordance with certain understood rules, and if those rules can just be changed anytime its convenient to do so then we get a bunch of members feeling that all they get to do is write a check and the leadership does whatever it wants.

Hard for a craft organization to operate like that; it causes too much time wasted just stamping out fires..... Sure there are always folks who would be unhappy even if the Board bought them a new lathe every month, but most folks are pretty mellow and happy to let their elected reps do the best they can, just so as they're not totally free-ranging, y'know? Most of us know it's tough duty ... it takes up a ton of time and you get to spend a lot of it fielding complaints from the incurably unhappy.

I suppose part of my point here is that, right now and as you say, the by-laws do not currently require full Board approval to engage outside consultancy, legal or otherwise, but here's the rub ...even if the by-laws did require that, the Board could simply change the rules at the drop of a hat and it would be as if the rule had never been there. Ever.

Too many rules and you get paralysis, too few and you get chaos, just like right here on Woodcentral ..Ellis has to find the balance between letting folks speak their mind, which he wants, and letting folks run wild without consideration for anyone else, which he doesn't want. We all know the rules, and we can join or not join, that's the deal. But if Ellis was elected to his position, rather than being the proprietor, he would have, and I bet he would feel, a responsibility to check in with those who elected him before moving the goalposts.

I would like the AAW Board to have the freedom to navigate into the future without being micromanaged to death, but not free to jack anyone around unpleasantly while they go about it.

It's tricky, I agree. Worth talking about though, in my view.

Re: AAW 5%

#14

Information

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

To those contemplating all if this is the key to my posts, not argument. It's all too easy for well-meaning but uninformed people to go charging into the fray to slay the perceived dragon, only to get chopped up by the windmill's blades.

For instance: Some are now seizing on the 5% rule in the By-Laws. "Hey, all we need is 750 bodies out of 13,000 and WE can make the GREAT CHANGES that WE WANT." Hmmm, sound like a small minority taking control from duly elected representatives to you? Are you replacing the "Gang of 7" [or 6] with the "5% Gang"?

Obviously, this s**tstorm was created by the ham-handed procedure employed by the Board, likely on the recommendation of the consulting firm, when far easier means to change the ED were readily available that would have preserved not only reputations, but also friendships and, quite possibly, the AAW itself. But those options were either ignored or never raised, and they're gone now. The Board having committed itself to the present course will not be able to reverse itself without a mass resignation and the individuals involved being personally vilified. That scenario tends to put people in a rigid posture, if for nothing else, self defense. The more pressure is brought to bear, the worse the situation will get until something breaks. I certainly hope what breaks is not the whole organization. Far too many good people have poured their hearts and hopes into the AAW over the last 25 years to see it trashed by overreaction to ignorance.

Re: AAW 5%

#15

Re: AAW 5%

Brian George

Bill,

The only posting I have done is on Wood Central under "AAW 5%."

The original 35 names that I sent the original email to was taken from the first posting about "Mary Lacer," which I beleive was on Friday morning, if I recall correctly.

I am including that original email to those 35 for your perusal.

Also, read Cyril Griesbach's comments on Wood Central in that same thread I just mentioned.

Here is that original email I sent out:

All the discussion and speculation going on about the recent BOD action raises the question if we invoke a 5% membership petition to bring out the answers.

Someone has to be willing to step up to the plate and start the ball rolling to see if there is interest.

I am willing to start pushing for such an action.

If you have interest in being part of a group that is willing to sign a petition, whatever the makeup will be, I am willing to help move in that direction. If someone else wants to do it, fine with me but, let's start.

I have NO INTEREST in being on the BOD but, do have interest in keeping AAW moving forward.

If there was malfeasance, so be it. The board acted correctly. If not, then the BOD is suspect.

To me, it is clearly a real set up and people were blind sided in a very underhanded fashion. I do not want to think that AAW is like that.

Who instigated this and for what reason(s)?

Once again, If you have interest in being part of a group that is willing to sign a petition, whatever the makeup will be, then let me know by sending a new email with "Include Me in the 5%."

- Hide quoted text -

He who hesitates loses!

If It Is To Be It Is Up To Me!

It only takes 700 signatures to make this happen

Let's Just Do It!

Brian George

Member # 34307

President,

Chippewa Valley Woodturners Guild

1.715.834.8749 (Home)

1.715.559.0073 Studio)

captainbg@gmail.com

Re: AAW 5%

#16

Re: Information

Brian George

[For instance: Some are now seizing on the 5% rule in the By-Laws. "Hey, all we need is 750 bodies out of 13,000 and WE can make the GREAT CHANGES that WE WANT." Hmmm, sound like a small minority taking control from duly elected representatives to you? Are you replacing the "Gang of 7" [or 6] with the "5% Gang"?]

I include the above quote from your earlier post, Mark. By putting quotation marks around that statement you are, in essence, quoting verbatim what the writer(me) is supposed to have said.

In a response to Bill Youngbloods query this morning right here on Wood Central,I have posted the EXACT email that I sent to 35 members of AAW. Nowhere in that email does it say what you quoted me as saying. That email list is comprised of those individuals on the original AAW "Mary Lacer" forum thread that I was able to get their addresses from their profile. There were about 1/2 dozen that chose not to post personal email addresses, therefore not being included in the above referenced email.

Facts, not innuendo. Openness, not blind siding. Full disclosure, not info for some and forget others.

Transparency, not BS cloak and dagger, corporate crap. Fairness to all, not for just a certain group.

Re: AAW 5%

#17

Re: Information

Brian George

Please, Read and then re-read once again, the earlier comments by Cyril Griesbach in his earlier post under this thread.

Makes definite sense to me.

I have received emails from some, in my opinion, very respected contributors to this forum, as well as being early members of AAW (Charter members in some cases) who have misconstrued what the intention of the AAW 5% committee suggestion is.

At NO TIME has anyone, myself included, to the best of my knowledge, ever suggested that the BOD be "Booted Out."

Accountability and transparency? YES!!

Including ALL the elected members of the Board to be FULLY informed as to a pending action and motion of this magnitude? A resounding YES! YES!! YES!!!

Re: AAW 5%

#18

Re: Information

Brian George

Let's bring in out of the closet. After only three years in this wonderful organization known as AAW, I have realized that there are two major groups that seem to be at loggerheads over direction of our future. I am part of the less than artistic side, however I applaud that other side and what they bring to the party. They are no better than the other group but, just have different desires and needs, perhaps. In my opinion, there needs to be tolerance for all of us in this wonderful community of craft people and artists. In some eyes I may not be as artistic as they desire but, they cannot deny that I am an artisan.

No one can be effective swimming with the fish if we are outside the bowl looking in, or for that matter in another bowl casting stones. Differences are healthy for any thriving organization. That's what helps keep us on our toes to do the best we can possibly do. However, secretive divisiveness has no healthy outcome; rather it is corrosive, debilitating, and eventually destructive to all concerned.

Re: AAW 5%

#19

Re: AAW 5%

Bill Youngblood

Thank you very much, Brian. I am just a simple country boy who enjoys woodturning. I am by no means a politician or lawyer; however, I do know when I'm being hornschwaggled. The AAW definately needs some adjustments to it's bylaws. A board that can hire and fire, make changes to the bylaws, and not only not keep the membership in the dark, but lie to them, needs more control. Most of the people running the AAW are very inteligent and hard working volunteers. Of course, any time you get a group as large as this, you're going to get a few bad apples. I am certainly willing to help where I can in getting the necessary changes accomplished. Thank you for your efforts in getting this started. Bill

Re: AAW 5%

#20

Quote Me Qouting You

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

At your own risk, Mr. George.

I haven't seen your e-mail, and don't need or care to read it. I was paraphrasing a number of public posts here and elsewhere where people have been extolling the perceived "5% Solution."

However, as you've now apparently formed the AAW 5% Committee, I'll welcome you to the political arena and caution you that in a true representative democracy, if you want to claim legitimacy, you'd better have more than 50% of the AAW membership actively supporting your agenda. At last count, that would be MOL 6,501 people.

Anybody who believes in their heart that their goals are right, their cause just, and their method honorable can have a lot of trouble even thinking that they might be wrong or the result of their effort harmful.

Make no mistake, I don't care one way or the other what you or your Committee do or don't do. Having been an AAW member, formed some personal relationships with dedicated members, and seen some of the organization's accomplishments over the past 25 years, I'd hate to see the whole thing trashed because a small group overreacted. What my post said was to suggest that people take a few deep breaths and put some real time into detailed considerations of what they want to do, get proper information about what the results will be, and then proceed in a manner that has the best result for the organization, rather than pleasing to a relative few, in clear view.

Of course, if you view any comment outside of your own plan for ACTION as argumentative, opposite, and hostile, I'll leave you to the funny hat and secret handshake crowd.

Re: AAW 5%

#21

Simple Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

On the subject of "disclosure to the entire Board" that you demand.

Given that the vote was 6 vs. 2 for dismissal. And given that such discussions involving an employee are required by law to be closed door and not disclosed. If you wish to see the notes of those "meetings", get used to the idea that you, a "mere member", have no right to do so.

It is also apparent that most of the issues had been discussed at prior Board meetings, so, other than the decision to terminate, very little, if anything, was done by way of the secret "cabal" as some have characterized the BoD.

That said, what possible difference do you think it would have made for the other two Directors to be included in the predicate considerations? That's a trick question, because the obvious answer is nothing. Those two Directors were precluded from disclosing such matters, so they were not in a position to go to the membership to rally "troops" to their opposing view, and their dissent would have made absolutely no difference in the final result. That said, were I in their chairs, I too would have seriously considered resignation because, as a elected Director, I would have been entitled to full disclosure and participation in all such discussions.

As I have said before, the handling of this whole thing was, in my view, at best poor.

Re: AAW 5%

#22

Re: Simple Question

Brian George

"As I have said before, the handling of this whole thing was, in my view, at best poor. "

Touche'.

Just an aside, Where can one find a truly representative democracy of 50+%?

Re: AAW 5%

#23

Re: Quote Me Qouting You

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Mark: I was one of the early posters to this whole MANURE pit. I have calmed down some as the week has progressed. You mention that it would be a shame for a small group to destroy this fine organization. Would it not be much better for a small group of � 750, than a small group of six to force change? The bylaws have been exposed to be seriously lacking. The board's actions were very weak, poorly carried out, and maybe illegal. Some would say they were mean spirited, certainly not well planned. Some changes are necessary. Since the board is supposed to be for the best for the AAW, they should start the changes for the vast improvement of the AAW. How about a focus group of normal members to advise the board on these changes? They can still win back our respect, if they start NOW, not in the years to come. After a week of all this junk, the BOD should know that, They must change. Supposedly Mary lacked professionalism and communication skills. Where is the board's professionalism and communication skills? Much of the speculation on these many forums could have been prevented with some real communication from the BOD. What small percentage of our colonists really stood with the small group of signers to the Declaration of Independance? I refuse to be labeled as a TORY!

Bill Turpin

Re: AAW 5%

#24

Barb Siddiqui

Has Anyone Even Considered

Barb Siddiqui

as a First Step, simply Asking the Board of Directors to work on changing the articles and by-laws?

'The Board of Directors' are people too, with names, faces and brains. They are reading/watching all this member upset over their actions. And I'm betting they may be regretting at least part of their procedures, such as hiring the conuslting firm and following its advice blindly. No one wants to see this mess permanently damage the Association. If, after being politely asked to change the rules under which the board operates, they refuse, Then would be the time to consider the steps being described here. Someone please stand up and consider Peaceful Negotiations before legal action. If you want this large, non-profit corporation to act more as a 'friendly club' because 'that's the way we do things,' then start there.

Re: AAW 5%

#25

Tories & Rebels

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I'm certainly not attaching labels to anyone here or elsewhere, Bill.

I also doubt that there would have been a ripple if the ED were someone other than Mary Lacer. As Andi Wolfe pointed out, there was no outrage when Larry Sommers, the ED for 6 years, was shown the door.

I wonder how many people who are pounding the table as outraged AAW members have ever attended a general membership meeting, let along gotten 'involved' in the discussions. At the last such meeting I "stuck my head into" at the Richmond symposium, there might have been more than 50 people present from the membership, but I doubt it, even though there were nearly 2,000 members at the convention.

I'm not arguing the merits of anybody's position here, merely suggesting that things are much more complicated than many seem to think, and that those who purport to act for change understand and be willing to take responsibility for the changes they want to make.