Re: Transparency
Dave Moore
Yes Mark, that's correct.
BOD's can, and should, go into executive session for discussions relating directly to employee performance matters, and the minutes of such meetings are not released publicly. It is, as you say, the law most everywhere and that's as it should be. There is a duty to protect employees privacy, and that's good.
Having said that, if the BOD meets to discuss hiring an outside agency to give legal and/or tactical advice for future planning for the organization, that is not a personnel matter directly, though any recommendations received from any such agency could certainly have personnel implications included on down the road.
No reason for a decision like that to be taken by anything other than the full board, and no reason for that decision not to be recorded in the regular BOD minutes, neither of which seem to have been done in this instance.
The other points raised above regarding the authority to change the by-laws are entirely valid concerns also. It makes no sense for a small group of folks to have the authority to change the rules by which they are supposed to operate any time they feel like it. May as well not have any by-laws at all if that's the way it's set up.
I don't think anyone thoughtful is advocating going in there like Genghis Khan and cleaning everybody out, I'm certainly not interested in that. I'm not even wanting to insist that the decisions just made are voided even, though if it turns out that the manner in which those decisions were made was irregular enough to violate existing rules they might have to be, I'm not a lawyer so I don't know.
What does interest me is exploring ways to ensure that the BOD is required to be accountable to the membership for its actions. Excluding Board members from any decision making process disables that member from properly representing those who voted for them, and that's no good, it should never happen, and if it does the membership should have the means to discover it and hold the responsible parties accountable.....
I agree it's complicated, and a cautious and thoughtful approach will be needed. You know, babies and bathwater and all that.
The AAW is not perfect, and can't be everything to everybody all the time, but it's been of value to me in many ways and to many others, so it's worth it to me to give a little time to leveling things out. If that's possible.
That's just how I see it right now of course.