Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Posts

Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#1

Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Hi All,

After seeing a couple demos and reading a brief tutorial I built a jig for the table saw to cut the splines to make a turning with a Celtic knot.This piece was just a test of both the jig and my turning.As you can see it didn't quite work out.


I set the height on the table saw to leave 1/32" of material on the top of the blank and filled the area with the spline.Rotated the blank 90 deg and did the same cut,gluing,trimming and sanding each time for the remaining sides.

When my cuts were finished I had a reversed "z" on each face of the blank,just as what was in the You- Tube video "The Homework Ultimatum" which is where my inspiration to make this style turning came from.


The woods used are curly maple and walnut.I had some down time today as I ran out of pen kits after using the first 5 I bought : ( Gotta get more

Thanks,

Andy

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#2

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Allen Neighbors

I haven't got the slightest idea what went wrong. But, if I tried it, it wouldn't look that good. That's why I haven't tried one.

Isn't that little Lesniak kid, a hoot? Homework ultimatum.... good show!

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#3

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Jeff Willaford

Make the first cut...rotate 180 degrees then 90 then 180 for four rings. Think of a square with sides 1,3,2,4 where 1 and 2 oppose each other as do 3 and 4. Looks cool though. More like electron orbit interrupted than celtic knot.

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#4

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

jimmy edwards

Andy I like your deal better. Looks like an Iranian nuclear device type of thing. Making the blank is 1,3 then 2,4

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#5

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Brian George

This is the first I have heard of 1,3,2,4 for a Celtic knot. I make many pepper mills and boxes and boxes and have always go 1,2,3,4. After gluing and allowing to dry, rotate 90 and do it again until all four done.

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#6

Maybe you had ORANGE tools? ;-)

Adrien

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#7

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

john lucas

Andy I've only done one celtic knot. it came out fine. I like yours very much. If you could tell us the steps you did it might help solve the problem. I used the technique of making one cut, glue up, rotate 90 degrees and make another, etc.

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#8

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Grant Wilkinson

Andy: It looks like you haven't turned it down enough to clear away the 1/32 you left to hold the piece together. I've done many celtic knots pens and any time the knot didn't look complete, I just needed to turn away a bit more.

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#9

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Scott Hurley in N VA

I've had some luck with Celtic knots. One thing I learned is to make sure the thickness of the insert is the same width as the saw blade. By following that advice, the knot usually lines up nicely at the intersections.

Scott

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#10

add a comment

jimmy edwards

After thinking about it it seems the blank was put on the lathe a little off center. That will expose more of one side quicker than the other.

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#11

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Robert Nelson

Grant is correct, you just need to turn the dia. down until the gap disappears. It looks it will be just fine with a little more turning.

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#12

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Thanks to all for the comments and suggestions.I will try and put it back on the lathe very soon and trimm it down further and see if the full knot appears.If not it will give me cause to try again and with the suggestions listed above I feel confident that I will get a better result on the next one.

When I has my table saw set up I cut several pieces of spline material so I can try,try again.

Thanks,

Andy

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#13

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

You didn't gauge the diameter of the vessel correctly to the turning speed/feed of the saw. No big thing, I think it's looks nice ;)

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#14

UPDATE:Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Hi All,

Thanks for the comments ,suggestions and encouragement.I was able to re-mount the sample to the lathe and re-turned it down to a diameter just over 1/2" and the knot became whole.I think I could have stopped a little sooner but some of the walnut was jagged on the edges.

Those who had suggested the turning just needed to be smaller/turned further were spot on.


Thanks Again,

Andy

Re: Celtic Knot,What went wrong?

#15

Barb Siddiqui

Very Nice Andy!

Barb Siddiqui