Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Current Board Controversy

Posts

Re: Current Board Controversy

#26

Re: Current Board Controversy

Dave Moore

Yikes David,

You got off to a bad start in my book when you chose to refer to Ms Lacer's canning as a "transition".

Further, your suggestion that we all just get busy on our lathes as a means to "walk the high road" is pretty darn offensive.

I have no clue what went down over the last few days, but I suspect that you perhaps do. Your suggestion tastes like you think we should all go play with our toys and let the grownups deal with it all.

If Malcolm and Bill's account of the events are even halfway true, including Ms Lacer being accompanied to her room to pack her stuff and surrender her AAW materials, and if it is true that her severance package was linked to her signing a document requiring her silence, then at the very least something has been handled very badly indeed. At the very least.

So far the only communication from the BOD is Wirsing's letter, which begins with a statement that both Bill and Malcolm assert is completely untrue; she did not "step down", she was ousted.

Not very encouraging. It may indeed be that the BOD made the right call in light of the circumstances, but the circumstances have been so badly handled at this point that what is needed now is some clarity as to what exactly this is all about. If there has been malfeasance then we should know about it ..if there has not then we should know that too. If it's just a matter of egos banging into each other, then let's get it out in the open.

Whatever.

We're adults too David, and you are addressing us as if we are not.

Snap out of it, brother.

Disappointing. I have enormous respect for your work, it is stunning. Maybe you should go back to your lathe?

Re: Current Board Controversy

#27

Re: Current Board Controversy

George Guadiane

I'm assuming you are talking about John McCain?

Re: Current Board Controversy

#28

Re: Now wait...

Sean Troy

The truth was kept from the members last year about the AAW logo, what makes you think they would tell the truth about this? This is exactly the same thing, they just wait until it blows over and then go on there merry way as if nothing ever happened knowing no one will do anything about it.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#29

Re: Current Board Controversy

Frank Ford

I don't think Bill was talking about McCain. I did see through the "smooth talking, slippery tongued fellow" about a year ago - and it wasn't McCain. I'm not ashamed of my vote. But let's not go down that road.

But on a point of agreement, I think the board needs to provide an explanation. Mary deserved more respect.

Frank

Re: Current Board Controversy

#30

Re: Now wait...

Barbara Gill

I don't know about illegal activities. I do know that there was the lie that Mary resigned posted right on the front page of the AAW site. I also know that at the very least there is a lot of immoral activity by the way Mary was treated. I have no inclination to believe what the Board says nor do I have any inclination to trust them.

Most of us vote blind for the Board members, depending upon personal recommendations, etc. I am pretty definite about my feelings toward people who lie to me.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#31

What Barbara Said!

George Guadiane

Re: Current Board Controversy

#32

Re: Current Board Controversy

Adrien

"majority of people who took action when they felt action was necessary. That�s their job."

But this whole secrecy thing is eerie. And to make Mary's whole separation package contingent on her not explaining why she was fired certainly makes one wonder what the BOD is hiding from the membership. Obviously it is NOT to protect Mary.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#33

Re: Now wait...

Stuart Johnson

I was involved in a similar termination where over 40 million dollars was involved. This was over 25 years ago. After one in depth investigation, one court case and two books written that included the issue the details have yet to be revealed. So no the details might not every be known by anyone but Mary and the BOD. Plus those details will be interpreted by those involved.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#34

Re: Current Board Controversy

bill crommett

Regardles of whom I was specifically referring to, There are enough slippery tongued, smooth talking people out there to supply everyone's needs. And for some reason that remains a bit clouded most of them get into politics for either self aggrandizement, greed, or altruism. To define the difference is another clouded issue. Please don't regard this as a political issue, for it is more of a study in psychological pathology with a specific emphasis.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#35

Re: Current Board Controversy

Jim Rutten

OK. I agree that something certainly unethical and possibly illegal has ocurred. Are we the members of this organization powerless? Are there procedures in the by-laws for recalling the current members of the board? (i.e. petition, majority vote, etc.) Where can we even read the by-laws? Someone above talked about writing letters or e-mails, but I don't think it will accomplish a thing. Let's get rid of the current board if possible.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#36

Re: Current Board Controversy

David Walser

[T]his whole secrecy thing is eerie. And to make Mary's whole separation package contingent on her not explaining why she was fired certainly makes one wonder what the BOD is hiding from the membership. Obviously it is NOT to protect Mary.

At the risk of getting my head bit off, please allow me to try and point out that it is NOT obvious that the silence does not protect Mary. Years ago, when I worked for a large bank, I had to fire one of my subordinates. My superiors gave me no realistic choice in the matter. While I disagreed with their decision and felt we should retain my subordinate, their decision was not a "moral issue" (he wasn't being fired because he was the wrong race, gender, religion, etc.). My superiors wanted to go in a different direction with our department and felt my subordinate was too specialized in his skill set.

So, I fired him using basically the same method the board used with Mary. Someone from HR sat in on the whole process. He wasn't given any advance notice nor a chance to face his accusers. He was escorted to his office to clean out his desk and then to his car to go home. He was offered a generous severance package on condition of his agreeing to a non-disclosure/non-disparagement agreement. We were bound by the same agreement. It was really rough on him. It was rough on me, too, but I never deceived myself into thinking it was harder on me than him.

After it was all over, I arranged to have lunch with him so I could apologize for the impersonal and harsh manner in which he'd been fired. He asked if he could use me as a reference in his employment search. I said that would be fine and that I'd do my best to find him an opening at another firm. He asked what I would say if I was asked why he left the bank. I said that I'd say, "I don't think it'd be fair for me to discuss all the circumstances surrounding Bob's resignation, but I can say he was a valued employee and I was sorry to see him leave."

Who was protected by my "silence" about the reasons behind Bob's leaving the bank? In truth, both the bank and I were protected. Bob had no reason to bad mouth me or the bank if I was going to be a reference source and if were going to try and find him a position somewhere else. But Bob was protected and helped by my silence more than anyone else. It wouldn't have helped him find a new job if I told the reasons he was let go.

My point is that the fact Mary's been asked to sign a non-disclosure agreement proves NOTHING. The board could be acting nefariously or they could be acting in good faith. In either case, best practice would have required a non-disclosure agreement. I'm afraid too many commenting have little to no experience with how terminations of senior executives are handled in the business world and that, out of ignorance if nothing else, they are putting too much weight on factors that do not convey any information.

By the way, I helped Bob find a new job. We still see each other at professional functions and we are fairly close.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#37

Re: Current Board Controversy

Frank Ford

Agreed Bill.

I was responding to George's response to you, not to you. I appologized if you took offense. There was none intended.

But that's what I get for breaking one of my life rules: Keep my woodturning and politics separate! (except with close friends of course)

Re: Current Board Controversy

#38

Re: Current Board Controversy *LINK*

Ed Davidson

Jim,

AAW by-laws can be found through the General Info page on the AAW website, and in the hard-copy Resource Directory. Here's the direct link (below).


AAW By-Laws

Re: Current Board Controversy

#39

Thank you, David. That's helpful.

Adrien

Re: Current Board Controversy

#40

Re: Current Board Controversy

bill crommett

Frank: I am not offended by anything any more. I have lived long enough that I can take anything that anyone can give out to me personally. I have trouble with what some people want to do to my country, but as far a being offended by anything or anyone, my perennial response is "Grow up and get over it".

Re: Current Board Controversy

#41

Re: Current Board Controversy

Jim Rutten

Thanks, Ed.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#42

Re: Current Board Controversy

Frank Ford

To All:

I wasn�t sure on which thread on which forum to post this, so I just picked this one.

Many of the people who say we should all calm down and not form opinions because we don�t have all the facts, in the same breath tell us that the BOD acted properly and that we should just trust them. But they don�t provide any facts supporting that the BOD acted properly or why we should trust them and not demand an explanation from them. I remind them they while they�re entitled to their opinions and speculations, so is the rest of the membership.

Some defend the BOD�s silence by saying they legally can�t reveal any details. But then others (non-board members) say they had �conversations� with �people� and now that they have new facts, they understand why the BOD acted as they did. But they can�t share these facts with the rest of us. Why not? These new facts are obviously outside the BOD circle. Someone is talking. So why not share this insightful info and enlighten the rest of us. Or are some members more equal than others?

Based on reading multiple forums on this topic, these are public facts as far as I know:

FACT #1: Mary was fired and escorted to her hotel room to surrender AAW property - a fact no one has disputed. Some may want to split hairs and say she resigned. Rubbish! You don�t escort someone to clean out their desk when they voluntarily resign, but you sure do when you fire them.

FACT #2: Tom�s letter on the AAW front page says she stepped down. If you don�t want to call it a lie, it is surely misleading.

FACT # 3: Two well respected board members resigned over this incident and expressed their disdain for what happened and how it happened. These people deserve no less trust than other members we�re being asked to just trust.

FACT #4: Malcolm, Bill and Mary were blindsided on Monday (unless Malcolm and Bill are lying).

The last fact raises some questions in my mind.

Who hired the consulting firm Transition Guides (TG)? Who entered the AAW into a contract with TG? Did the AAW solicit proposals from various consultants? Were ALL the board members involved with the selection process? Was the Executive Director aware of the contract or involved in the selection process?

To whom did TG report? Did TG report to the entire board or only to some board members? How often did TG and the BOD correspond? Was all of this �transition planning� done behind the backs of Mary, Malcolm and Bill?

The smoking gun in my opinion is that there were documents ready BEFORE the vote Monday�s. How were these documents prepared? Was the entire board involved? As board members, did Malcolm and Bill have a real opportunity to review documents entering the AAW into an agreement with Mary? If not, why not?

It appears that the BOD anticipated the resignations by having their replacements waiting the wings. Based on the facts I�ve seen, notwithstanding any possible justification to fire Mary, the process was poorly handled and the membership should continue to demand an explanation. If the BOD followed the advice of TG in this matter, perhaps the BOD should have another meeting and fire TG, because this is a mess.

To those who claim to have the real facts, but say they can�t share them; either pony up what you know or stop telling the rest of us just wait.

Frank

Re: Current Board Controversy

#43

Walt Bennett

Re: Current Board Controversy

Walt Bennett

Read Alan Lacer's posting on AAW "Mary Lacer's Conflict of Interest" and you'll see what a trumped up smelly thing this is. Anyone hearing unofficial words of wisdom from board members (insert 'innuendo', 'lies', 'slander', or whatever word you'd rather see) has not heard all the facts at all, just what the board wanted to put out as rationale. I've been trying to hold off until real information got out, and I believe it came from Alan (AAW member #300).