Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Current Board Controversy

Posts

Current Board Controversy

#1

Current Board Controversy

David Ellsworth

As the senior advisor to the AAW Board, I have been asked to reflect on the recent and difficult transition of our Executive Director, Mary Lacer, as announced by our President, Tom Wirsing.

Let me be clear that I am not a member of the AAW Board and I do not speak for the Board, only for myself. I am also good friends with the people on both sides of this awkward aisle, so it is not my position to take sides, but rather to inform and hopefully clarify what I feel are important aspects in this matter.

I will begin by saying that the AAW provides for most of us a club-like atmosphere at both the national and the local chapter level, so any time someone in our club becomes injured, we all feel the pain in one way or another. The AAW is also a corporation that operates under very strict rules � by-laws � that allows it to function, sustain itself and grow with the ultimate purpose of serving the needs of its members.

One of these rules is that we elect rather than appoint people from our own ranks to the nine-member Board of Directors. It would be too cumbersome for all 13,000+ of us to vote on issues ourselves, so we trust these elected individuals to carry our interests forward when creating policy and opportunities that benefit our needs within the woodturning community. Put another way, we trust them to do the heavy lifting for us, to ask the tough questions, to make the tough decisions.

What many members may not know is that the President is not allowed to vote on any motion unless there is a tie among the remaining eight board members. And when it came to the decision of retaining or dismissing Mary as our ED, the vote was 6 to 2 in favor of dismissal. This was a very decisive vote, not a tie.

Still, this issue is obviously complex. There will always be questions as to whether this situation was properly handled or could have been handled differently. That is not for me to say. Mary has been well known and well loved for the many years of her employment with the AAW, so there are strong emotional overtones to this issue that will take time to heal.

The most important thing is that a decision was made by a majority of people who took action when they felt action was necessary. That�s their job. That�s why we elected them. To that end, Mary�s temporary replacement, Linda Tacke, is highly qualified, already in place and a search is underway to locate a new ED; our journal, our committees, our local chapters, our educational programs, our scholarships, and our bank account (your money) are all intact and functioning at the highest level ever. Collectively, these elements represent the Board working in our best interests.

Tough times, sure. Hurt feelings, of course. But now is the time to show our strengths not our weaknesses, to jump back on the lathe, to walk the high road and let the healing begin. This we can do!

Sincerely,

David Ellsworth

Re: Current Board Controversy

#2

Did you ever hear the maxim

Ron Sardo

"A camel is a horse designed by committee"

I was not going to respond to this "Controversy", but after reading what you had to say makes me wonder even more why YOU want us to buckle under.

Why do you want to sweep this "Controversy" under the rug and have the members of AAW forget it ever happened!

Why do you not want the members to question the Board of Directors?

Why do you not want the members to find out the facts?

You said, "show our strengths not our weaknesses, to jump back on the lathe, to walk the high road and let the healing begin".

Our strength is finding out the facts, our weakness is letting others tell us we should just ignore what happened and just "jump back on the lathe"

Re: Current Board Controversy

#3

Steven Antonucci

Change management issues

steven antonucci

Certainly appreciate your insight on the matter and respect your individual contributions and perspective. I like Mary, and I believe we all were shocked moreso than anything else. Perhaps it was a necessary move made by a strong BOD. Time will tell.

The issue at hand is mostly being created by change management. The first step in any major change is education (why). Once you figure out why, folks have the decision to get on the bus or not. None of us understand why at this point, so this change is difficult. All change is difficult, and requires communication (clear, accurate, and open) to make sure that people are with the new direction at every step of the change. Otherwise, you run the risk of losing a sense of belonging.

We all chose to be in the AAW because we want to be in the family of woodturners who share, openly and honestly, what they know. All we ask is that the Board is accountable to the same standard. Whatever the truth is, it will eventually come out- so why not lead with it?

Respectfully

Steven

Re: Current Board Controversy

#4

Walt Bennett

Re: Current Board Controversy

Walt Bennett

I'm sorry, but while you may be a founding father of AAW and a truly respected and renowned turner, your response to this true catastrophe of leadership is lacking in substance and only desirous of the masses continuing onward and ignoring the entire thing. The AAW is a mostly volunteer organization (and I've years and years of experience in those) with a few paid positions. Mary had one of those and was extremely liked by the members that knew or even only met her. There may have been valid reasons for the six members of the board who wanted to oust her to do so - BUT why in the world would they do so in such an underhanded and vicious manner? She'd been interviewed on radio just a few days before and obviously knew nothing of the upcoming firing! Where is the LEADERSHIP in this board that can stand up and explain what they are doing and why?

Re: Current Board Controversy

#5

Re: Current Board Controversy

Carole Valentine

Well, that told me a lot...in fact I found the the "Now, now children - go back to your playground" tone to be rather condescending. Better off to have said nothing. We WILL find out what this was all about eventually.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#6

Re: Change management issues

Bill Neddow

Boy, do I ever agree with you, Steve. Unless we have valid reasons for the change, I can only see this as a subversive coup and I can have no trust in the new Board of Directors. This seems to be another attempt to sweep the whole thing under the rug and hide whatever is going on behind a wall of secrecy.

Healthy organizations cannot operate this way.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#7

What has the world come to?

George Guadiane

I agree with Ron Sardo!

Re: Current Board Controversy

#8

What Steve Said!

George Guadiane

Re: Current Board Controversy

#9

Steve Kubien

Sadly...

Steve Kubien

...Carole, I think you are mistaken on this. I see us getting the, "we are not at liberty to discuss this for legal reasons" line of bull that so often accompanies backroom dealings. Some may say I am a pessimist. I prefer to think of myself as a realist.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#10

Obfuscation!

Ed Moore in SW VA

David, your condescending tone and suggestion that we all march along like good boys and girls is offensive to the highest order. No way will I let a group of dishonest people treat a lady like Mary Lacer this way.

It isn't clear whether the artsy-fartsy group has staged a coup or the sexual-orientation group is flexing its muscle. In any case I have lost any respect for members of the Board, or their supporters.

Ed Moore

Re: Current Board Controversy

#11

Re: Did you ever hear the maxim

Sean Troy

The Board knows and is banking on this will just all blow over because members are not going to do anything about it. Just like last year and the journal lies, people got all bent out of shape, ranted and raved for a few days but in the end did nothing. The AAW Board is not the members Board, it's their own and has been for quite awhile. Either accept that and do nothing or do something about and earn the right to complain. By doing nothing, you have not earned the right to complain.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#12

Re: Obfuscation!

Barbara Gill

Good word Ed.

I felt as if hip boots were required to finish reading David's post.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#13

Barb Siddiqui

Now wait...

Barb Siddiqui

My first reaction was to condemn the Board of Directors for how this was handled, too. But I'm wondering if it isn't true that they simply cannot, legally, discuss the situation until Mary Lacer decides whether or not to sign a non-disclosure agreement and accept a separation package. If she decides not to do that, wouldn't we be hearing from her in defense of herself? If she decides to do that, she will have her reasons, and we should respect them.

I'm glad David Ellsworth put up a letter here. Knowing he is not formally on the BOD, yet must be 'in the know' as to what is going on, it sounds like he himself has confidence in the recent decision. I'm asking, why? And I'm concluding, for now, that all this uproar is based on hearsay and little known fact. I think we are going to have to wait out the thirty days Mary Lacer has been given to make her decision, and then perhaps we can all expect the facts to come to light. I'm very sad this "was necessary," and I'm hoping the BOD has valid reasons for their decision. AAW members deserve an explanation eventually, regardless of legal maneuvering.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#14

Re: Did you ever hear the maxim

Ron Sardo

Sean Troy said:

Either accept that and do nothing or do something about and earn the right to complain. By doing nothing, you have not earned the right to complain.

I'm not sure if you are talking in general or directly to me. I'll answer as if you are talking to me.

Today there are many alternatives for woodturning. AAW is no longer the only game in town. I'm very involved with one of those alternatives. I am doing something.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#15

Mike Stafford

Re: Now wait...

Mike Stafford

Barb, holding a severance package in abeyance for a promise to be quiet is not a very good way to end a 25 year relationship. What do they want her to be quiet about? What might she say that is so damaging? It is becoming increasingly obvious that they removed Mary without cause.

There is something terribly disturbing about the way this was done. First of all it is now quite obvious that 6 of the board members were in on this prior to the board meeting. Not only did they plan to remove Mary but they also foresaw that 2 other board members would resign in protest. They had a contingency plan in place for this as they had already contacted and obtained an agreement from two individuals who obviously were in on this plan to replace those who resigned. Lots of scheming and machinating here. The real question, yet to be answered, is to what end? What is to be gained from all of this?

And now we are told to just place our trust in those who lead us. And the pied piper....

Re: Current Board Controversy

#16

Re: Now wait...

Barbara Gill

Barb, even if there was good reason for the action it doesn't change the underhanded methods employed. Two board members were not even included in the events before the vote.

We are not children to be told to run along and play and let Big Daddy take care of everything.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#17

Re: Did you ever hear the maxim

Sean Troy

Ron, I wasn't talking directly to you. I'm sorry if it seemed that way. I should have replied to the original poster. I was reading your post when I thought to reply to the original. My apologies, Sean

Re: Current Board Controversy

#18

No apology necessary

Ron Sardo

I always thought you where one of the good guys.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#19

Ditto: What Carole Said

Deb_WB

Re: Current Board Controversy

#20

Re: Change management issues

Bill Youngblood

During 40 years in the corporate world, I have seen this type of management change many times. It usually is a surprise, but that's the way it has to be in most cases. However, I can't remember one instance that it was not with some sort of explanation to the employees. In this case it would be the membership. We will probably never know all the reasons behind this, but I think some indication of the Board's thoughts would certainly help to ease tension.

Terminating one's membership is not the answer. Persistance in the form of letters to the Board would be a good beginning.

I have been an AAW member for 10 years and chapter president twice. I have met Mary many times and she always had time to stop and talk to the little guy. Mary, if you see this, I want to thank you for your years of dedication to the organization and for your support in my chapter business and wish you the very best in the future.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#21

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Now wait...

Barb Siddiqui

Mike and Barbara-

I have read those points and I understand them. But don't you think we should wait to judge, waiting to hear from Mary herself? Because of not knowing enough facts, I am cautioned by David Ellsworth's statement implying that he has confidence in the Board's decision. I hope to heaven nothing illegal has gone on. I'm just for waiting the thirty days and then expecting to hear from the organization, and hopefully Mary herself. And I hope too, that the Board can justify its actions.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#22

Re: Current Board Controversy

Larry In Lima

The way this "seems to have happened", her being "gone", just reeks like rotten fish - no matter how you slice it - or what the reason.

Sad to say the least.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#23

Re: Now wait...

Ron Sardo

Barb Siddiqui wrote:

But don't you think we should wait to judge, waiting to hear from Mary herself?

Do you really think Mary is going to risk her severance by speaking up?

The BOD will say it is a personnel matter and insist that they can't say anything to the public.

The silence is deafening.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#24

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Now wait...

Barb Siddiqui

Well with all this demand for accountability, the answers have to come out eventually.

Re: Current Board Controversy

#25

Re: Current Board Controversy

bill crommett

I thought that Davids letter was as smooth an operation that I have read in a couple of days. I remember voting for a smooth talking, slippery tongued fellow a year or so ago -- for ever to my shame.