By the time this is all said and done, we're all going to be coring experts...
I just checked the "manufacturing quality" of my coring rig. Not sure what the tolerances should be, but here is what I found:
1.) the knives fit only one space between the pins in the gate, so I assume that it's the right set of pins to be between. There is a gap that is roughly the thickness of two standard business cards (which were handy, so I used them as a feeler gauge) Is that "a lot"?
2.) The knives are all pretty close to a circular section, but none are perfect. I thought about this, and I don't understand why it would have to be? The knife doesn't pivot on a point like the Oneway, but it follows a path that is determined by how you position the gat and the shape of the knife. That's what makes the system so versatile.
Would it be possible to contact Kel to answer some of these questions? Seems like he's the man with the plan?
Kel is a very nice guy. I'd strongly encourage you to ask him your questions. Your success and happiness as well as his service are the only things that truly matters here. My opinion, or anyone's, is just that-ours. Kel does respond to the emails from their website's "info@" email.
The pins allow different spacing for the different sizes of knives. So fitting between just two of them is nomal. You want some space between the knife and the pin. The knife must be able to slide freely.
Obviously if the gap is too small, the knife will not fit. But, if it is too wide, the motion of the wood will cause the tip of the knife to rotate. Since the blade is curved, the tip may dig in. This is the problem that I had. The further the blade is extended past the rest, the worse this problem becomes.
I lift the handle and twist it counterclockwise when starting the cut. Seems to eliminate the initial dig-in problem I experienced.
Harry, you state that "The further the blade is extended past the rest, the worse this problem".
It was my impression that some folks like to extend the blade an inch or so when starting out because the blade is wider at that point and thus less likely to be twisted. ??
The greater the space between the blade and the posts, the more the blade can twist. And the more it sticks out, the more curved blade is beyond the posts. I don't always start cutting with the blade perpendicular to the bowl.
I found this when I was trying to figure out why the tool was catching so violently. I fed the tool into the wood while turning the wood by hand. As soon as the tip of the tool touched the wood, the tool twisted clockwise and the tip of the tool dropped down and dug into the wood.
My problems seemed to have been solved when I started twisting the handle counterclockwise when starting the cut. It worked for me, but as Robo says, it may not work for you.
The Mark 8 has 4 gates, for the 4 sets of blades. There is a step up for each set of blades, and the gates are all different sizes, to match the different blades. Ideally, one stop collar under the tool rest will work as a height setting for all the blades.
When first entering the wood, the gates keep the blade up right. Most of the time I will have the gate up pretty close to the wood, and the high part of the blade isn't in the gate. There is a little twist, and I used to fight it, but found out that the lathe and torque are stronger than I am. When I tried to twist counter clockwise, it would kind of slam back to where it was supposed to go in the first place. I am used to it now, and it twists a little at first, but as the tall part of the blade gets into the gates, it stands up right. I would think that if you are getting too much tipping of the blade you might be in the wrong gate. If it is too tight, you again might be in the wrong gate. The clearance should be like Steve said, about 2 business cards.
This same type of slam will happen if you don't have the blade up against the top of the older T bar, or the newer Mark 8 square piece. This is another thing that I fought when I first started coring. Being up against the tool support takes a lot of work out of coring.
As to the shape of the blades, they need to be a perfect arc of a circle. Think of trying to cut with a J shaped blade, or one shaped like the big inside bowl tool rest from Oneway. A little radical on the shape, but you could go in for a short distance, then the blade would bind because you have more than one curve in the blade. Part of the diversity of the McNaughton comes from the flatter blades, which are better for coring shallow plates (you can actually turn a cylinder and then core a bunch of plates/platters out of it), or for getting into deeper vessels. The medium and small curves are more standard bowl blades.
there is a huge amount of helpful information and reviews on the use of the system done by many of the members of this forum .I am sure that the likes of John wouldn't have contributed if he didn't believe the system works
I have contributed on other tools for the same reason
I have the older system and have saved 100s of bowls
I tend to pick up the bowl saver to even save a bowl when I normally wouldn't because its quicker to save a bowl than cut it to cut to waste
I stage a run of similar sized bowls with this
method my record is 29 bowls in 2 hours
I often smack my blade or place in the vise so it is fact not round so that it enables me to cut out an odd shape
I just set the blade at Center wind the stubby up and go for it
Having re sharpened the cutters like the new system has helped immensely
This is helpful on a nice burl that I may struggle to get a uniform curve out of
I am sure the problem that most are facing is because they may only drag out the bowl saver and save a couple of bowls every know and then
Like everything practice makes perfect
If anyone wants I am only to happy for them to spend a day in my shop saving bowls . Id like that as id get heaps of bowls and you get to save them l.o.l
When I started the initial thread (many threads back), I think my initial point was:
Hey, the instructions that came with mine are pretty weak, and i think it would be a great idea to include a short video (on the kelton website) to show all of the things you need to do to become an expert.
If I am the manufacturer, odds are I know how to use it. Heck, if I wanted to keep my bandwidth costs down, I would post it on Youtube and just have a link to the embedded video on the Kelton website... but I digress.
What spawned were all kinds of threads and sidebars about the manufacturing quality at Kelton (I have no doubts that mine are perfect, but I am not), the customer service (I've never tried contacting Kel, so I have nothing to say), and so forth and so on...
I will reiterate that I believe my issue is simple: I cannot get the silly things to work consistently, and I know its me, since the knives don't change. It has to be me. I just wish it was obvious so I could fix it. There have been a number of great suggestions here that I believe will increase my odds of success, so I will make another go of it, and report back when I have news (success or failure...)
Steve, My email address is jtfleming@san.rr.com. I have a coring tutorial that I wrote for More Woodturning years ago. Send me your email and I'll send you a copy.
Whoops! I mentioned earlier that I twist the handle counterclockwise when starting to cut. I don't know what I was thinking. I put some clockwise pressure on the handle before it touches the wood. I also hold the handle up against the cross brace. Don't lift too hard! These are metal-to-metal surfaces so the tool can only go so far before it stops. If you lift too hard, it is difficult for the tool to slide in the gate.
Also, I always give the cutter a couple stokes with a diamond hone and put a couple shots of WD-40 on the blade of the tool (Bill Grumbine's idea) before starting the cut.