Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Articulated hollowing systems

Posts

Articulated hollowing systems

#1

Articulated hollowing systems

DC Powers

Has anyone used the Vicmarc hollowing system? I'm wondering how it compares to the Monster

articulated system.

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#2

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

Bartimmo

I am interested in hearing everyones feedback as well. I have been flirting with getting an articulated arm tool, such as Monster. I didn't even realize that Vicmarc made a articulated hollowing tool. Based on pictures both systems look similar in design. I know there are a number of owners of Monster system here. Has anyone ever play with the Vicmarc system?

It seems that the weak point of any articulated arm as compared to a solid boring bar is the potential for vertical fluctuations/play in the joints, which would result in chatter. I would appreciate any feedback from owners on this. Do you experience any noticeable play at the joints of the tool while turning?

Thanks,

Edward

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#3

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

Cyril Griesbach

No noticeable play in the joints of my Kobra hollowing system.

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#4

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

Doc Green

I have the Monster system and love it. There is no slop in the articulating arm that tends to contribute to chatter.

However, there is a disadvantage to the articulating arm compared to the solid, captive D-ring, when you are hollowing deep within a hollow form. With most of the bar inside the vessel, you run out of a place to grip the bar when you reach a depth of 10 or 11 inches or so. This is with the standard bar supplied.

Of course, this is not an issue for shallower vessels.

~Doc

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#5

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

v

The Kobra has a rear handle and its no problem with a 15 in. bar.

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#6

Re: How timely! I have been hollowing....

Jamie Donaldson

...a chunk of red maple burl(dry!)today, and questioning whether the person who gave it to me was friend or foe. The Monster is a beautiful piece of work in both appearance and function, and I have several different straight and angled tools that I use with it, including a set of the large Jordan hollowers. I also have a Jamieson D handle system, but much prefer the easy set-up of the articulated Monster on my short bed Stubby("Studly"). The straight shafts of 18" and 20" give plenty of grip length for the 12" deep vessel, and my surgically repaired R elbow was thanking me for the Monster purchase rather than my now seldom used Stewart handle. I had never before attempted such a gnarly piece to hollow with the Monster, and it took the abuse in stride.

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#7

Link To Vicmarc's

charlie belden

Haven't seen anything up to now about a Vicmarc Captured Hollowing System. I'd like to add it to the compendium of hollowing systems I put together - just to keep the info up to date. Anyone have a name for the product to search for - or a link to a web page about it?

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#8

Re: That should have been "red oak burl".....

Jamie Donaldson

....rather than red maple! What has happened to my edit function- it's gone?

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#9

Re: Link To Vicmarc's

Don Wilcut

The system is called a Hollowing Tool Support. I just went to Vicmarc.com

Don

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#10

Re: Link To Vicmarc's *LINK*

charlie belden

Should have checked first - the Vicmarc "Hollowing Tool Support" is already in the hollowing system compendium.

Thanks for responding (and not saying "dummy, you already have it in the compendium."


Compendium of Hollowing Systems

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#11

Bill Blasic

Re: Link To Vicmarc's

Bill Blasic

Randy has an adapter for the Monster that allows you to use 3/4" tools and using the 3/4" Keltons gives good reach to greater depths along with the updated laser support that he recently made available. All my 3/4" boring bars are now in play.

Bill

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#12

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

George Guadiane

Like others, I have the Monster setup and am delighted with it. On deeper vessels, I do notice a bit of flex in the articulated part, which may cause chatter if you are trying to hog everything out in five minutes (like I TRY :b )... Otherwise, I haven't a problem in the world with this unit. I use my Rolly Munro hollowers, almost exclusively and I really like the way they work in conjunction with the Monster.

Two things that I'm using to get deeper and/or wider without chatter or grab:

1) I got Randy to make me a longer thicker bar for my oldest Munro hollower.

2) I got a long tool rest, curved on the end (from JoHannes Michelsen - he uses them in making his beautiful hats......gotta take his class some day soon)

I stick the rest inside the hollow form - for big pieces like this, I use a 2 1/2 to 3 inch opening and with the heavy shaft for the Munro, I'm able to get deep and smooth. There are still limits, but I stretched them by at least 6 inches.

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#13

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

Gregory Whitney

Take a look at the Elbo Tool Hollowing System. It is very sturdy and it uses needle-roller bearings at all of the articulating joints for tight, friction free movement.

A nice feature is that it anchors to your existing tailstock quill so you don't have to buy an extra part to use as a anchor point. It is also reasonable in cost.

http://www.elbotool.com/products.html

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#14

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

robo hippy

I have had a Monster system for a couple of years. The articulated systems make hollowing smaller forms simple, and the laser pointer on the Monster is really nice. It really only takes finger tip pressure to hollow. If I wanted a more heavy duty system, I would opt for the Kobra. Much bigger joints. With the Monster, I can easily hollow to 6 inches. To get to 8 inches, I have to be rather delicate once I am beyond 6 or so inches. If I rough out first with my McNaughton hollowers in my coring tool handle with laser, free hand, then finish cut with my Eliminator in the Monster tool, I can go past 8 inches with little effort or problems. If I want to hollow with the Monster deeper than 6 inches, I need the smallest cutter on it. With the 3/4 Kelton hollowers in the Monster, I figured the lever is just too long, and I got a fair amount of chattering. Problem solved with the 1/2 inch hollowers, or was that 5/8 inch.

robo hippy

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#15

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

Terry Scott

I have seen it used but havnt used myself

The action of the arms overlapping seemed a bit restrictive with movement

I do wonder about all those joints and knuckles getting sloppy in time

After allot of research and recommendations from my woody mates here and in the states I recently invested in a kelton Rig ,Great fun and my body sure takes less of a beating on big hollow forms . Having the Laser attachement sure takes out the guess work as well

I also went the hole hogg and got the new colited handles . With the Er collets and the shock absorbing rubber on the handle my elbows are taking less of a hiding

Any other handle I have is a pour substitute as I can know use one handle on a multitude of tools I have

Just my View

Cheers

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#16

Don Geiger

Kobra user report

Don Geiger

I have two of the Kobra systems. One is the Green model designed for use on mini lathes and I had Jerry, at Kobra, build me a system to support it on my Stubby. I also have a Red model system that fits my Stubby (16" over the bed) and Jerry has supplied me with what I need to adapt it to lathes up to 24" for my demos.

The Kobra has a thrust bearing at each joint which, if I remember correctly, is rated at 1,850 lbs of torque. The tension of each joint is adjustable and there is no slop, vibration or noise even when it is full extended. The Red Kobra comes with a 1" i.d. receiver that has two set screws for securing the boring bar. I have the 1" X 15" bar and adapters for 3/4", 5/8", and 1/2" bars. Additionally, I use a set of Trent Bosch bars and several others. The 1" bar that is supplied with the Kobra is center drill with a 1/2" hole to accept their straight, 22.5 and 45 degree tool bit holders and two scraper bits holders. One thing I really like about their tool bit supports is they have square broached holes to accept standard tool bits without having to round them first!!! This is huge! I buy a box of bits from a machinist's supply and sharpen both ends of each so all I have to do when one gets dull is to flip it around and keep turning. Also, not having to pre-round or purchase pre-rounded bits saves time and money. I have the tool bit supports for 1/4" and 3/16" square bits. I even have carbide bits with square shanks that fit into the holders.

I asked Jerry to make me an 1/2" thick off-set plate to place the intitial pivot point behind the bed of the lathe several inches (about 6")which gives me more reach for getting under the lip of hollow forms. I can also attach the plate to the auxilary bed of my Stubby which gives me much more flexibility. This extension plate is now standard with all Kobras.

I couldn't be happier with the products or the service at Kobra.

Jerry called me the other day and they have some Kobras in-stock now and can ship quickly. He can be reached at jatooling@yahoo.com or 765-534-4437.

Don Geiger

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

#17

Re: Articulated hollowing systems

C. Hoiness, Phx

I bought an Elbo Tool about 3 or 4 years ago and I really like it.

By attaching it to the tailstock it's fast to set-up.

It's easy to use and the price was right.