I've seen so much about only using the "golden rule" for proportions. I've never been a slave to rules and apparently neither was a very prominant scientist/thinker/philosopher/etc. Comments on the quote (following) would be appreciated.
There is no excellent beauty that hath not some strangeness in the
I see no reason to stick religiously to the golden rectangle or any of the other design lectures. I do think it's important to know what they are and understand why they work. Then if you want to break them it's up to you.
The Golden rectangle was simply a mathematician trying to put numbers to shapes that the majority of people found pleasing. These shapes are duplicated in nature so you can argue that we like these shapes because subconciously we relate them to our natural environment.
Because we work with a material that has a figure and maybe a texture that changes the way your eye sees things the golden rectangle formula may have to be adjusted to compensate for our perception.
The "golden rectangle" and other proportional ratios are only guidelines - slavishly adhering to them in all cases can produce some strange looking pieces.
. . . which gets us back to the Sir Francis Bacon quote.
"There is no level or straight in the eye. It is all that we see at the same time that makes things seem correct. "
Actually, our eyes, specifially the receptors in them, are brain cells that begin the processing of visual information - before it gets to the optic nerve on the way to the rest of the brain.
And our visual information processing system has some built in "hardwired" functions - like detecting and identifying vertical, horizontal and diagonal features of the thing being seen. We also have built in Edge Detection - that probably let us see the sabre toothed tiger lurking in the bushes, the spear we threw and missed the target and now out there in the grass somewhere.
Our eyes are also able to pick out and notice RED - handy if you're leaking blood. WE also evolved from hUunter/gatherers whose survival depended on "spotting" danger and distinguishing things that are edible from things that are not. Gourds and fruits have shapes that are distinctly different from rocks, logs and sticks - and they usually also have a color that make them stand out - for us.
I suspect that much of what goes into "aesthetics" are based on primitive, instinctual "hardwired" features of our evolved brain - where perception resides.
I think Rules For Proportions are useful "filters", helping us get through a lot of ideas that probably wouldn't fit the "hardwired" pattern recognition built into our senses.
An infinite number of monkeys using word processors might produce the complete works of Shakespeare. But a few humans, given and outline of a few of those works, and maybe some examples - would get a lot closer - a lot faster.
I agree that it is not necessary or even desirable to stick fastidiously to Golden Mean proportions, however forms which deviate significantly from this are often perceived as 'out of balance' or not "natural"... ...if this is what the artist desires, then the form is successful.
In my demonstration on turned vessel design, I do suggest that those turners who struggle with defining pleasing forms in their work begin with sticking to the "shape rules" at first until they get a sense of the kinds of shapes and forms that work for them. Not only does the Golden Mean Ratio tend to work well for overall proportions of many vessel designs, but other general suggestions about ratios of foot size (1/3 max. diam.), faired/smoothed curves, etc. are helpful to allow beginning turners to get away from some of the "boxy", straight-sided bowls that they tend to produce when starting their journey into woodturning.
This does not mean that all turned objects MUST conform to the 1.618:1 ratio. This is where the creativity and innovation of the artist comes in. If one can deviate from this 'natural' proportion in the piece's design and still produce a pleasing form, the piece may be aesthetically successful without having "Golden" proportions. If turners are having an issue with making their pieces "look right", then the Golden Mean might be a good place to start in the series of improvements they should negotiate through successive changes until their work is pleasing to them.
... should be educated in the "Laws of Art" as foundation for their endeavors. Then when so fortified they are allowed to break the Laws with reason, and we call such heresy "creativity!"
What you get is a mountain of 1x1.6 boxes and the world is unendingly boring.
Such "perceived truths" are, however, of great comfort to hackers, dilettantes, and dolts as they may take refuge in the sure knowledge that what they have done looks good because it conforms to The Rule.
If you know how to use a gouge, but have no concept of proportion, what good is that?
I can sand bad technique into submission and end up in a happy place, but I think it was Keats that said " A thing of ugly is a mess forever."
The rule is just another tool to be learned and applied at the lathe. Like various gouges and grinds, I have many rules that I use in the right situations.
I agree with Jamie. The "artist" doesn't need rules, and we call that "creativity". For the rest of us, the rules are there if we need them, and we are free to ignore them if we can.
I use "the Rules" because I have to. There was a significant improvement in the appearance of the stuff I make at the lathe when I started using "the Rules"; and I have never stopped using them.
I have written an article on how I use "the rules" for my woodturning.
I find it amusing that such a lively and interesting discussion on art and beauty could be started by quoting someone who was not noted for his artistic ability. Unless I'm wrong he was a lawyer, politician and a not so successful inventor who sponged a living off the government, relatives and friends.
In any case the discussion has been interesting... way over my head, but interesting.
There has to be a starting point....especially if the turner knows nothing about design. In that case, the golden rectangle and other formulas can help give a good understanding and working knowledge of design. Problem is, formulas alone cannot guarantee success; there are other factors to consider. After all, we've all seen perfectly proportioned dog dishes that adhere strictly to the golden mean, while they ignore any other design criteria.
I'll be demoing in Hartford, one of the topics is "Design for Beginners". It will involve no set formulas, instead I'll show how each piece of wood can be turned to its best advantage using a few simple techniques. For example, a perfect cube has little visual interest, yet an attrractive form can be turned from it...defying the "golden mean" myth. I think adhering strictly to such rules can stifle creativity and imagination.
I like the mean as a guide, but I'm finding a lot more beauty in the curve.
I hate to say "like a woman," but for me it's true:
Like a woman, ideal proportions are nice and all, but there is something about a "perfect" curve that draws my attention more than that other "perfection ."
I think the same is true of our turnings. If the flow of the line is good, the sense of ideal proportions shifts to what is in front of me as opposed to what "should" be.