Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Electric Chainsaws

Posts

Electric Chainsaws

#1

Electric Chainsaws

Jennifer Indy.USA

I'm thinking about buying an electric chainsaw (not cordless). Any tips on which ones to look at and which ones to avoid? All your help would be appreciated!

Thanks,

Jen

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#2

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Charles Watson

I have a Makita and it works great!

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#3

Re: Electric Chainsaws

John K Jordan

Jennifer - I've had a couple of cheap electric chain saws. I finally bought a Stihl electric. There is NO comparison between the quality of construction, power, and cut. Sorry I don't remember the brand names of the others. The Stihl is expensive (about like a gas-powered saw) but I think it is worth it. I use it in the shop and outside when I don't want to a) bother the family with the noise and b) mess with gas/oil/starting. It is SO easy to plug and play.

JKJ

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#4

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Marvin Ewing

I Like My Husqvarna 316E Bought it from a company called ALAMIA FOR 249.00 with no charge for shipping.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#5

Re: Electric Chainsaws

GaryG in MD

I bought a cheapie (well under $100) several years ago, and it's still working fine -- never failed me or been worked on after about 750 total "cutting" minutes on it. I don't try to cut trees down with it -- just size and round up blanks, instead of using a band saw. Maybe it isn't quite as fast as an expensive one, but it cuts just fine if you keep it oiled and the chain sharp. I'm a hobbiest, so I don't care if a cut takes 6 seconds instead of 3 seconds. ...Gary

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#6

Re:I went thru several cheapos- Craftsman, .....

Jamie Donaldson

....Remington, Poulan before buying a Makita on Amazon, and it's a beast!When shopping in person, be sure to check that the drive gears and sprocket are real metal and not plastic.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#7

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Galen Vetterick

Just got the cheap Lowes Poulan 18" electric chain saw for cutting split log ends and cutting for bowl blanks this year. Zips right through 14" and 16" logs on crosscut. When cutting log in half the long shavings start to bind up around the sprocket and has to be cleared. A lot of the chain saws might do this as they all seem to be open and wide gap to pull them in this area.

Think this is listed as 14 amp by Lowe's but nameplate is 13 amp. List it as 4.0 peak HP ( the mythical HP ratings system). Metal sprocket, auto lub system works but you need to use a light chain oil as I used some older thicker from my gas saw and it did not feed well.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#8

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

I had a cheap Remington. Loaded it down cutting a log. Finished the cut and put the saw down. Noticed smoke coming out of the motor vents. That was the last time it worked.

If you get a cheapie, be really easy on it. Keep it sharp, touch up the chain regularly and don't load it down so the speed is reduced.

I doubt I'll ever buy another electric!

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#9

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Carole Valentine

Jen,

I have a 14" McCulloch (or however you spell it) and think it's a piece of crap. Have really not used it at all since I tried it out after I first got it. Besides the fact that it doesn't cut very well, it also oozes oil constantly. I think it is going in the next yard sale. I would not even consider another electric unless it was a Stihl or Makita. I have to admit that some of my dissatisfaction MAY have to do with the fact that I am just used to whipping through wood with my Stihl gas saw and am spoiled.

In the time it takes to get out the saw, run the cord, put in oil to replace all that had leaked out, secure the wood to something in the shop, etc. and do the actual cutting I could have had it already cut, lathe mounted and half turned if I had used my gas saw.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#10

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Barry Irby

I too went through several cheap Remington saws from Lowes. They only lasted a few months. Loews replaced one or two under warranty, but after that they said, "We have already honored the warranty". (They had). I replaced the plastic ring gear and some needle bearings, maybe more than once. This class of saws was about $89. Went to Sears and bought a Craftsman Which appeared to be extremely similar and was clearly made by Remington. For $12 bought the extended warranty with the assurance that if I brought it back, they would just hand me a new one, until the warranty ran out. The saw lasted just long enough to get out of the warranty. OTOH, if it was the $12 that made it last, it was much better spent than the $89. I just replaced the plastic ring gear in that saw for about $16 and it seems as good as new.

I never oil it. I generally cut wet wood with it and often in the shop. When I got it I filled it with bar oil. Apparently it just drools on the chain. If you set it down it continues to drool and you will have the contents of the oiler on the shop floor. I have never seen any adverse effects of not oiling, but, I am treating this saw as a disposable and will trash it when the time comes. I would not have replaced the ring gear except that it appears to be the only damage to the saw.

At other times, I have read posts here about electric saws, and like this time Stihl, Makita, and Husky rate high and several others rate as crap. The crap is in the $100 neighborhood and the much better saws are three to five times as much. I am thinking of upgrading to one of the better saws so I am reading the responses with interest. I would like to buy my "last" electric saw, not the next one. I live in a housing development and while I will whip out my Stihl gas saw on the weekend to avoid upsetting the neighbors I try to keep it to reasonable hours. (And besides, when you power up a chainsaw, wood turners show up from miles around and beg for wood.) The electric saw is easy, quick and quiet and I can use is indoors in winter, without dying from CO. Highly recommend an electric, either a good one or a Sears one with an extended warranty.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#11

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Terry Quiram

Jen

Buy from the people that make chain saws. STHIL. Keep the chain sharp. A gas powered saw will be a little forgiving with a dull chain but an electric will be misery to use. Besides its safer.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#12

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Chuck Engstrom

Hi folks -- I'd certainly agree that Stihl, Makita, Husky are the best of the lot and lesser brands are just that -- lesser all around. On the other hand, the lesser brands often show up in yard and moving sales at hard-to-beat prices, and I now have three of them for less than $50.

Best--

Chuck

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#13

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Doug

I have a Stihl and it is very good. Don't use it much, but I have been very pleased with its performance.

Doug

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#14

Re: Electric Chainsaws

-e-

Hi Jen:

The two brands of electric chainsaws that are considered for 'professional use' are the Stihl and Husqvarna:

I use the Husqvarna 316E: great little saw that I use to make little cross-cuts and cut corners off blanks, as well 'adjust' wood mounted on the lathe. However, it has to be used GENTLY, will stall out in difficult woods, and really can't be used to rip. And when it finally burns-out, the next electric will be the Stihl.

Stihl makes 3 models: the model that is really made for the woodturners use is the MSE 220. It's a lovely little saw that can hold up to the use, has significantly higher cutting speeds, has all the features that will protect the saw and help to maintain long-term use. Everyone I know who uses this saw is extremely pleased with it and it seems to last much longer than any other electric.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#15

Re: Electric Chainsaws

Bill Neddow

I agree with -e-. Buy a Stihl or Husky and enjoy your hobby. Other saws (and I have had them) are just going to frustrate and disappoint you. I have a Stihl 220 with a 16 inch bar on it and it is as strong as a gas saw capable of handling that size of bar. It is a joy to use.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#16

Thanks Everybody!

Jennifer Indy.USA

Thanks for all the input here. Much appreciated. I'll be looking at some of the lower priced ones. Probably the Poulan if it has the metal sprokets. We have a big Stihl for the majority of stuff but I'm wanting something for cutting dead limbs in the 3-4" range. I'm starting to work on some larger scale Fiddle Stix. The chainsaw is over kill but my bow saw is killing me! I'm even toying with just using the darn sawzall for this.

Again thanks for the input!

Jen

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#17

Re: Thanks Everybody!

John K Jordan

You didn't mention your application before, but the sawzall might not be a bad idea. I use a couple of 18v Dewalt reciprocating saws and usually keep a long pruning blade on one for just that - easy to handle and cuts fine. The thin blade binds more easily than the chain saw but it's OK if you take care with the cuts.

If you ever want to cut limbs that are a bit off the ground, another option is a small trimming chain saw on a pole. I have one on an extension pole powered by my weedeater motor. It will easily cut a 4" limb 10' up in the tree.

The Stihl electric is probably way overkill for what you need - it's a real chainsaw for bigger wood.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#18

Re: JKJ- my Stihl pole saw is a .....

Jamie Donaldson

... wonderful gadget for trimming trees here on the golf course. We have many mature trees with dead branches, and cutting them before they hit the ground during storms saves much wear and tear on the fairway drum mowers.

Re: Electric Chainsaws

#19

Re: Don't forget the Milwaukee.

Russ Fairfield

With all of the talk of Husky and Stihl, don't forget the Milwaukee. It has been around longer than any of them and is still a good saw. I have a 16" Milwaukee chainsaw that I bought almost 30 years ago. No problems with it ever, but it is starting to show its age. The 15-Amp motor is enough for most of my sawing and shop needs, but needs a big extension cord and a 20-Amp breaker. I also use it ouside because it keeps the neighbors happy.