!! my thought, too :-)
Barb Siddiqui
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
!! my thought, too :-)
Barb Siddiqui
I'm learning a lot
Barb Siddiqui
This is interesting, to test its design. I wonder if Russ is right in saying the cut line is "the only feature" it has going for it, in its simplicity. I'm thinking maybe the inset of that slightly domed lid also lifts the eye upward, so to speak, fooling the viewer into dimensions of a taller perspective?
Mike, I have a feeling many of these effects are instinctive to you by now. Picking apart these details is revealing, at least for me. When you listed "2-1/2 x 2-1/2", I was somewhat surprised, because it fools the eye so well.
And I suspect Russ is dead-on right about Size being a major factor. Ten feet by ten feet would change the perception enormously, and comparing it to architecture is a good metaphor. Yes, I can see that being a problem between smaller model and larger edifice. Thank you, Russ.
Re: I'm learning a lot
Mike Stafford
The pronounced join line is there for several reasons. The first is to emphasize the proportions between the lid and the body of the box. The second is to provide a little purchase for opening a tight lid. And the third and most important is to provide a little shadow line to break up the stark facade presented by such a plainly simple box.
It is amazing what a difference an emphasis of the join line can make on how a box looks. Sometimes when I finish a box and it doesn't quite look "right" just creating that little step at the join makes all the difference. I think Pam Reilly taught me that when I was first turning boxes and asked her for an opinion. It could have been Ed Moore also as he provided a lot of guidance for me in design concepts. For that matter so did Mike Schwing. I have been fortunate to have received good advice from a lot of great turners.
Re: I'm learning a lot
Barb Siddiqui
and you do a good job of passing it forward. Thanks, Mike.
Re: Honey locust box...
John Veerkamp, Western Mo
Honey locust has big thorns & little leaves, Black has big leaves and little thorns.
Re: Honey locust box...
bill crommett
Thanks John and Jamie. I remember turning a beautiful chalice and salad bowl for a grand-daughters wedding present, but the most memorable part was the scars from harvesting the wood.
Re: A semi-related question
R Payne
I have to say one thing on the scale issue. Once you get to a level of bigness, our minds start playing tricks. Straight lines no longer appear straight, vertical columns appear to bend or lean. This was something the Greeks understood. There really are no straight lines in the Parthenon, for example, but when we look at it we see straight lines and perfection. I can't say how big a piece must be before such optical illusions start to ruin the simplicity of a design, I just know it is there.
ron