Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Honey locust box...

Posts

Honey locust box...

#1

Mike Stafford

Honey locust box...

Mike Stafford

Here is a box turned from some honey locust sent me by my buddy John K. Jordan. It is the first time I have used this wood for a box and I am certain it will not be the last.

I found the wood to a little splintery and chippy but once I got used to how it cuts it worked fine. I love the fact that this piece is so straight grained and resulted in perfect grain alignment at the join. The grain has lots of visual interest and has been commented on by all that have seen it.

The box finished at 2 1/2" tall and 2 1/2" in diameter. All comments welcomed...

Re: Honey locust box...

#2

Re: Honey locust box...

Matt Overton

Now I am even more upset that I can't make it to your class. I have to take 20 boy scouts to scout camp. I so want to learn to make boxes as elegantly as you do. Someday!!!!

Re: Honey locust box...

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Honey locust box...

Mike Stafford

Matt, saying that you would like to take my class is a wonderful compliment. Thank you very much. Taking and teaching boys to become good citizens is a more important task than anything that I can possibly teach you.

Maybe you can come next year. I will be teaching next June at approximately the same time.

Re: Honey locust box...

#4

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Honey locust box...

Barb Siddiqui

Beautiful again, Mike. My eyes are playing tricks on me.. is the top slightly domed?

Re: Honey locust box...

#5

Mike Stafford

No tricks, Barbara....

Mike Stafford

The top is slightly domed and inset into the lid. The little bead is slightly higher than the outside edge of the dome but the top of the dome is higher than the bead.

Make sense?

Re: Honey locust box...

#6

Beautiful

Greg Haugen

Very nice. Beautiful box to showcases locust's wonderful grain.

Honey Locust is a excellent wood and one that I think isn't used enough. There are some really beautifully grained domestic timbers.

Nicely Done.

Re: Honey locust box...

#7

Beautiful box....... also

Ruth Niles

It never ceases to amaze me that you can make such a beautiful object out of wood that is considered junk wood in my area. Guess I'll go raid my firewood. : )

It's sort of like "the grass is always greener".... people up north pay anything to get Norfolk Island Pine while turners in FL are sick of it. I used to live in a town called Black Walnut.....guess what everyone used for firewood, aka junk wood?!? Then go to TX and tell the locals you covet Mesquite!

Re: Honey locust box...

#8

Bob Moffett

Re: Honey locust box...

Bob Moffett

Very Nice Mike. I have turned some Honey Locust and also like it.

Re: Honey locust box...

#9

Re: Honey locust box...

John Lucas

Mike those are both sweet boxes. Don't you just love straight grain.

Re: Honey locust box...

#10

Re: Honey locust box...

bill crommett

Which is the Locust that has all the nasty spines ?

Re: Honey locust box...

#11

Re: Honey locust box...

nick

Nice. I used to get a lot of locust. nice wood to turn. finishes nicely.

Re: Honey locust box...

#12

Re: Honey locust is the big thorn wood.

JamieDonaldson

Re: Honey locust box...

#13

Re: Not only is honey locust wood an.....

JamieDonaldson

...attractive and useful turning wood, but the thorns can be used in an artful manner as well. I have used a variety of sizes for different projects over the years, and some of my favorites have been these "Flowers with Attitude."

Re: Honey locust box...

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Honey locust box...

Mike Stafford

Why, yes, I do love straight grain. It seems obvious I suppose but if you select nice straight grain when you are selecting your box material half of the job is done as far as maintaining the grain alignment. All that you have to remember is that the end grain should also provide some visual interest as it is also prominent.

Wild and extremely curly grain can also be used for boxes as long as the box design helps disguise the misalignment that can occur.

I don't know why it took me so long to learn these facts....

Re: Honey locust box...

#15

Barb Siddiqui

Re: No tricks, Barbara....

Barb Siddiqui

Yes, and I admire its subtlety. I see so many things 'overdone.' And it is hard, many times, to know where to stop with such details.

Re: Honey locust box...

#16

I may have another piece or two of that around...

John K Jordan

Re: Honey locust box...

#17

Barb Siddiqui

A semi-related question

Barb Siddiqui

I love Mike's box, but it makes me curious. In all the design discussions I've read, proportions are advised against this 2-1/2" x 2-1/2" squareness. Mike's box Works, and is attractive, but why does it work for small boxes and not for tables, breakfronts or even urns? Is it because it Is A Box? Squareness accepted?

Re: Honey locust box...

#18

Re: A semi-related question

John K Jordan

Barb,

I think one reason it looks good is the orientation of the grain. Imagine the same shape painted a solid color, then with horizontal stripes. Vertical stripes make a person look thinner.

I think another reason is some experts who like to give proportion advice are occasionally a tiny bit less than completely open-minded. Some of my favorite pieces break the "rules".

JKJ

Re: Honey locust box...

#19

Re: A semi-related question

clay foster

Mike's box is visually appealing because the line dividing the top and bottom is about 2/3 to 1/3. If the dividing line had been halfway, it would have had less visual interest.

Re: Honey locust box...

#20

Re: A semi-related question

John Lucas

I think it is a combination of what John and Clay said. The grain visually makes the box look taller. However it would still be a little distracting if not for the line between the lid and bottom. This line placed on the 3rds makes the bottom look heavy and the top appear lighter. This makes it work.

Re: Honey locust box...

#21

Dick Hines

Re: A semi-related question

Dick Hines

Mike's box is visually appealing because Mike turned it and he knows what he is doing and what looks good.

Re: Honey locust box...

#22

Re: A semi-related question

charlie belden

Perhaps because of a Dale Larson demo Sunday, and maybe John Jordan's demo a month or so ago, I'm more aware of the importance of the wood -its orientation and appearance.

Most discussions about what makes a really nice piece are about form and proportions as well as turning techniques and maybe finishing. If the wood is mentioned it's usually about its working qualities and how well or poorly it takes a stain, dye or finish. Only when the wood has a very prominent grain or some unusual visible pattern is it sometimes brought up in a discussion on design.

It's understandable that much of the characteristics of a chunk of wood we've put on the lathe is overlooked. Most turners don't start at the tree, choose which pieces to cut out/off, decide how to process the selected pieces from those logettes - with a particular form in mind - nor pay a lot of attention to how the growth rings are oriented when mounting for roughing. Get it mounted and roughed out so it spins without shaking the lathe - and beating up the turner. THAT'S the immediate objective.

Once roughed round, the emphasis is on hogging out what we don't want in order to get to the shape and size we're after. AFTER the piece is pretty much turned will how the grain and growth rings affect the appearance of the the piece may become a concern. By then it's too late to do anything about it anyway. So we forget about it - and repeat the "oversight" that prevented a NICE piece the last time - and make the same mistake again and again and again and again . . .

Given that most turners don't own or use a chainsaw - and usually don't start with a logette - let alone a tree - we work with what we can get - a piece of firewood, a piece of a branch, a half logette someone gave us or maybe a bowl blank someone else cut and made available - for free or for purchase - that probably has at least the end grain sealed in wax or maybe the whole thing coated in wax. But even then, with so many important decisions having been made BEFORE we get our hands on it - we CAN consciously try to exploit the best features of the piece of wood.

This piece violates one of the cornerstones of "good proportions" - yet still works - BECAUSE it uses a feature of THIS piece of wood to its best advantage.

Maybe putting up a sign that says IT'S THE WOOD STUPID! on the chainsaw case, or bandsaw might help?

Re: Honey locust box...

#23

IT'S THE WOOD STUPID!   New T shirt Ruth?

John Lucas

Re: Honey locust box...

#24

Mike Stafford

Re: A semi-related question

Mike Stafford

Decisions about a box start for me when I examine the grain before rounding up the blank. Then I have to really study the grain orientation so that I can decide where best to make the parting cut so that I can achieve the best grain alignment after removing wood. Once I have an idea where that point is I can then measure from that line and determine which proportions that I want to maintain. A general rule of 1/3-2/3 as Clay says will work but so will 2/5-3/5 depending on the shape of the box. The shape of the box determines a lot in how it is going to be perceived with regard to proportions.

The vertical grain helps disguise the fact that the box is squarish in its dimensions. I think it is helped by the same rule that if one is pleasantly plump wearing clothing with vertical stripes has a slimming effect. Me I gotta wear lots of vertical stripes...

Thanks for the nice comments.

Re: Honey locust box...

#25

Re: A semi-related question

Russ Fairfield

Barb, good question, but my answer got lost so I will repeat it again.

One of the reasons it looks good is that you are looking at a 2-D image that is close to the "golden" proportions.

But, this little box has 4 things going for it. Some of them have already been said, but are worth repeating.

1- Simplicity

Most of our minds prefer simplicity, and there is nothing more simple than the square, circle, or equilateral triangle, and their 3-D counterparts. This little box represents that simplicity

2- Smallness

We prefer our simplicity in small doses. Architectural models often run into this problem where the model of the building on the table had a lot of visual appeal, and the real thing had none. That's when everyone stands around wondering what happened, and they start adding things to the building to correct the problem. This one would not be as appealing if it were 10' square and sitting in the middles of the street in front of our house.

3- The picture and the illusion.

The strong vertical grain makes the box look taller than it really is because of the simplicity of the form. It's the same as cloths with vertical lines make us look taller and thinner than cloths with horizontal lines make us look shorter and fatter. You can make a platter with a strong grain and rotate it to see the effect of grain on the appearance of a circle.

4- The break line between box and lid

This break is important to a this box. In this case it is the only extra feature there is, and its location becomes vital to the appearance of the box. In this case the break gives them somewhere close to the magical proportions, and it will remove the appearance of being "square"..