I have the Delta variable speed grinder w/ the Norton 3x blue wheels from CSUSA & I've added the Oneway wheel balancer to the mix as well. It still seems like my wheels are bouncing around a bit, especially the fine one. Yesterday & this morning, I took it apart, re-balanced the wheels and was putting it back together when I looked at those quick-change nuts it comes with and thought to myself "no way those things are balanced!" So, a quick trip to Ace later I had some regular nuts to put on there, but all in all it still seems to be kind of a bumpy ride. (And I had to put the quick change nuts back on because the regular ones were too thick - couldn't fit the wrench over the flange on the arbor anymore).
The arbor seems to be running true and smooth w/o the wheels, so my next stop will probably be something such as the Geiger device to ensure the wheel is truly concentric, but that may have to wait till next payday. Does anyone have any ideas to help improve performance in the meanwhile?
What the problem is; the wheels are not concentric to the axle. You have probably counter balanced irregularities in the surface of the wheel- not corrected the cause of the problem. In that case, you need to use a wheel truing system (not just a wheel dresser). The wheel truing system at: www.geigerssolutions.com will solve this problem.
Keep in mind that once the wheels are trued (made concentric to the axle- as they are mounted) the weights you've so carefully positioned will be improperly distributed. My suggestion is to first remove the weights and the nuts (located in the slot), re-mount the wheels, true them and everything will be fine. Don't bother re-balancing the wheels.
The center arbor from the balancing system will serve the purpose of keeping the wheels fairly perpidicular to the axle so I would suggest keeping them in place.
Thanks, Don - I've had an eye on your truing system for a while now, I think you'll have an order coming your way soon. Thanks for the tip about taking the weights off but leaving the arbor flange, I will give that try too.
A simpler and cheaper solution to dressing grinder wheels with single point diamond dresser. I use a Grizzly H5891 single point diamond dresser to dress my grinding wheels. I drilled a hole in a block of wood, inserted the dresser. I simply slide that assemble along tool rest to dress the wheel.
You can get single point dressers from many sources.
I understand your skepticism because you haven't tried it.
The differences are that the depth of cut is controlled in very minute advancements of the 1/2 ct. diamond can be made. Utilizing the tool rest as a guide ensures you will have a smooth flat surface and the aggregate of the wheel will be very level. The benefits of this is the bevel and the cutting edge will be smoother. I have 80 grit wheels on my primary bench grinder (I have four) and I also have a sharpening system on my Tormek with a 220 grit wheel. When I sharpen a gouge on my 80 grit wheel and compare it to an identical gouge sharpened on the Tormek it's hard to tell the two apart. There is a slight difference on the amount of burr simply becausre of the differences in grit. My eyes are pretty good, but I have had to mark them so I don't mix them up.
The system is designed to make the wheels absolutely concentric to the axle. This is a task I thought I was able to do with my hand held dressers until I first compared the results to the GWT&DS.
The total mass (it weighs 1.75 lbs)of the GWT&DS and the close fulcrum point eliminates virbration of the tool when used.
I have had many people(literally hundreds)that were using hand held wheel dressers that when they had the opportunity to use the GWT&DS were suprized at the difference it made. The results were better, the grinder vibration was eliminated and their tools did not bounce on the surface. When your tools are on the surface of the wheel it's alsmost as though the wheel isn't turning
Time and success has provien this product not to be a gimmick. It was first introduced to the machinist's market in 1975 (not a typo!)and I re-designed the product to address the large platform rests used by most woodturners in 2006. Thousands of these dressers are used around the world every day. We still offer both models (short; 1" & 2" tool rests and long; 3" tool rests measured front to back).
Do a search on the Wood Central, Sawmill Creek and the AAW Forum using the word "Geiger" and you'll see what everybody on the turners on these forums are saying about it.
A good tool is an investment. Unlike many things we've spent money on in our shops, the GWT&DS will be used onced or twice every day you turn. You will be happier about your sharpening and the results will be better.
I have done both and have had success. I built a jig to hole my T dresser. It worked but was hard to adjust so you even though it trued the wheel it took of more than was necessary. Then I built a single point dresser using wood and then a single point lever type dresser similar to the Oneway. Both of mine worked more or less but because of being hand built had a little slop.
The Geiger Dresser is a large step up from these. It's like using a top of the line hand plane vs a craftsman. Both work and more or less get the job done but the work is so much more pleasurable and accurate with the good tool.
I'll admit, I'm cheap. I try all the alternatives first (and probably waste a lot of time and money). I do learn a lot from trying the alternatives but I've never regretted spending the money on a good tool after the purchase. There's just something about working with fine equipment that makes the whole project go better.
"There's just something about working with fine equipment that makes the whole project go better."
This is the best piece of advice that anyone could receive, preferably from an independent source. Tool stores should make these words into a poster an hang it in their stores.
Far too often, I have seen woodturners buy a cheap lathe, or other machine or tool, and then whine about the problems they are having.
I am not in any way knocking Geiger�s Wheel Turning & Dressing Solution in my previous post.
When bought my Oneway Sharpening system added �Wheel Dressing Jig,� too. Only use the bar piece to sharpen skew chisels. While dressing bar holds the diamond point at correct angle found it more a PITA than help.
Back then still used the single point dresser bought from Woodcraft that came with instructions for building your own jig. Took years of abuse before wore out that dresser. Expect my new jig will last me a long time as well.
The Geiger Wheel Truing System is wonderful. My wheels run true and vibration free! No, I do not work for Don Geiger, I am just one very satisfied customer.
I am for sure not an expert in all this, but measuring the shaft for running true with a dial gauge or some such would seem to me a basic first step to provide a foundation for next steps described in the earlier posts. A cheap grinder like Woodcraft or Delta is surely subject to some vagueness in quality control of the shaft and bearings. But the alternatives are very pricy. I know the Woodcraft grinder has varied in this regard, and when swapped out with a replacement sometimes much of the problem has gone away. I have heard similar concerns about Delta.
There are really two issues to be managed it seems to me: Out of round and side to side wobble. I have found that the Oneway machined washers and carefully balancing has made a huge difference in my Woodcraft grinder. As a cheap alternative Kirk Deheer of Craft Supply recommends using a neat, non-overlapping circle of masking tape between the plastic inserts in the wheel. and on the shaft, to firm things up. Also a spot of tape as/where needed on the washer to stop side to side wobble.
I find that a quality dresser held firmly against the table, and kissing the wheel does the job just fine for me once the other issues above are attended to.