Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Does It Matter HOW?

Posts

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#26

Well I've Learned A Few Things *LINK*

charlie belden

I asked the question hoping to learn something I didn't know or hadn't considered when I asked. And as I'd hoped, I have learned several things from the discussion.

I've learned that some, perhaps many, put a high value on manual dexterity and skill levels that are difficult, to very difficult, to acquire - in addition of course to the creativity involved in getting to the finished piece. And I think many who use this value system already have those manual skills levels, along with the creativity to utilize them - to make pieces they sell.

I've learned that Supply and Demand Curves apply for some, perhaps many. If there's only one of something and ten people want to have it - "it" has a value greater than if there were ten of "it" and only one person who wants to have one of "it".

I've learned that the mere fact that something CAN be used to make duplicates/copies/multiples is a real concern to some, perhaps many. Tools and techniques that CAN be used to make many, and by implication - less expensive - items COULD result in a competitive advantage - in a Mass Market. Probably a valid concern - if - price point is the deciding factor in a purchasing decision. However, the market craftsman usually are after is one whose clients don't make many purchases at WalMart or Ikea. This market values creativity, uniqueness and quality associated with fine craftsmanship much higher than Price Point.

These first three are market issues. Those issues are interesting. But since I'm not selling anything or competing with anyone I can understand the concerns expressed - though they don't apply to me - at all.

I've learned that some, perhaps many, put a high value on their relationship with the maker of a piece. This is an intangible which can't be affected by new tools or new techniques. People will always make things and if they are appealing to friends and family - there will always be a "market" for their work. In some cases, the piece results in a friendship between maker and owner. That's a wonderful thing. Old and new friends are always valuable.

I've learned that there are subtle things about "hand made" objects which some, perhaps many, can perceive - and that they are significant to those folks. One of those subtle things is that If something is perceived as "too perfect" its value diminishes. This is in keeping with the Wabi Sabi values system - the value of imperfection.

There is a belief held by some, perhaps held by many, that the use "technology" MUST result in something that's "too perfect". This concern assumes that designs created using a computer with computer software and computer accessories (tablet and pen) - but guided by a human hand - MUST BE "too perfect", especially if a �computer controlled� has anything to do with the final piece.

That doesn't HAVE TO BE the case. If YOU "draw" the design with a tablet and pressure sensitive pen, the lines YOU draw will show changes in pressure on the pen, with some set ups even the angle of the pen, the speed of the pen stroke and direction of the pen stroke - just like a pen or pencil has on paper - or on a surface of wood. The medium is different - but the action of the hand can be the same. Note that the hand, mind and �eye� are still required to create the designs � even if done using new tools.

On that point I tried, and try, to provide objective factual information that may or may not affect those folks' impressions of a tool or method. The reader decides if the information has an affect on how they view the tool or method.

Humans are tool users and tool makers. Tools leverage our existing physical and mental capabilities and enable us to overcome many of our physical and mental limitations - the "Give me a long enough (and strong enough) lever - and a fulcrum - and I can move the world" thing. And because we are tool users and tool makers, we can do today what couldn't be done earlier. So if I come acrossed a "lever" that enables me to do something I couldn't do, or was unwilling to spend the time and effort that would otherwise be required, I share what I've found and maybe it will help someone else get their idea from just an idea to something real - that others can experience. Head over to the Articles section and type in my last name in the search box. I didn't submit the articles - I was asked if they could be put on this site - because someone here found them on my personal woodworking site and thought they might be of interest to WC participants. I said �Sure � use the stuff however you want - no strings attached." I'd never heard of WoodCentral at the time. I put them together on my site in part because I thought they might help another woodworker. Having some of it accessible to folks here also � is fine with me.

For some reason, some folks think that writing (or "diddling with their fingers on a computer keyboard") precludes actually making anything, let alone making anything that requires any talent, craftsman's skills or creative ability. Head over to my web site, look around, at either the "shop furniture" stuff or scroll down and go through some of my turning stuff. Then you decide if "Them That Writes Can't Do And Them That Do Don't Write" is true - in my case.

(Apologies for not responding sooner - had a hundred mile round trip taking a kid to get her to and from three hour doctor's appointment to have her new Sclera (I thought it was called a Glass Eye) fitted - and then was turning a spalted wood pedestal for the Wishes Box piece I posted some stuff about earlier. It's a Mother's Day present for one of my daughter in laws I didn't finish on time. Fortunately my kid picked a very understanding woman to marry ; ) Will post pics of the finished piece before I get it to DIL)


My WWing Site

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#27

Steven Antonucci

You've missed the point

steven antonucci

Simply put, some vale the entire creative process as a whole. It is not something that we say a computer can do better so I'll give up that part of the process...

Design is everywhere. It is a commodity to a certain extent because as "consumers" we make choices to what we like and don't like based upon cost and convenience. I have a bunch of ugly bowls from Walmart just liek everyone else because I need to store left over food. I don't really care what they look like, they fill out a function I need to fill out.

When it comes to things I care about, I want to know that there was craftsmanship involved too. Whether its a workbench, a wooden bowl, or a painting, part of the value I assign to it is the notion that someone (not something) made it. I consider that it will have to be handed down to my children and how they will fight over it, not put it in the greatest garage sale ever. I want them to connect with the thing so that it becomes more than just another thing... Machine made objects typically never get that status in my household.

It's not that PC's/lasers/CNC are evil, bad, negative, but very similar to the way that Arts and Crafts rebelled against the ornamentation of Victorian Era. You will always find someone who values a hand cut dovetail. A well turned form. A hand knit sweater. Some people realize that the value of these objects is not the object itself, but the fact that there are still people who CARE enough in this world to spend their lifetime developing the skills to produce these objects.

And they will pay extra for it.

Steve

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#28

Re: You've missed the point

charlie belden

If I understand your point

Though I cut the piece of the tree, cut the resulting logette to get a piece to turn, chose the grain orientation for bandsawing to a starting point blank, mounted the blank, roughed it to shape - that I chose - then turned the parts for the piece that I designed using chisels and gouges - and yes - a MiniMonster, with laser - fit the "lid" to the opening in the "box", sanded the parts - by hand, hand applied the finish - that I chose and mixed - and finished the "finish" to the look I wanted

if

I then laser engrave or laser carve a design - that I drew with my own hands and from my imagination - and did the laser set up to put it where I wanted it - or - did ANYTHING else to the piece that my hands weren't controlling directly

then

the mere use of a computer controlled laser, or any other method not directly controlled by my hand(s), to add a surface decoration

therefore

dismisses all the other effort I put into the piece - with my own two hands (and a variable speed lathe, three or four turning chisels and gouges - and yes a captured hollowing system - with laser - and my imagination and my drawing skills and ability - and creative mind?

Up to getting the adddition of the decorative design onto the piece - all the criteria for "hand made" have been met. The resulting piece I created from a piece of a tree I cut and turned, sanded and finished - using "traditional" craftsman's tools and techniques operated by my hands is "hand made" and let's assume my effort shows craftsmanship and skills implied by the term. But if I then do ANYTHING to the piece that is not directly controlled by my hand - it's no longer handmade and isn't the result of craftsmanship - based on your criteria?

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#29

Steven Antonucci

Not what I said...

steven antonucci

Why stop at burning with a laser from a computer controlled pen? Why not have the lathe run a CNC routine to get your shape? Why not create a CNC hollowing system to precisely control wall thickness?

When does something "lose" the tag handmade? How much mechanization does it take to become manufactured instead of handmade? I don't know the answer, but I'll offer the following loose definition:

"When any part of the outcome that has a material value has been achieved by some automated system, it's no longer 100% handmade"

Take something like the Holland Bowl Mill. They turn wooden bowls in very large quantities (production). Their lathe has a McNaughton like coring knife that they swing through a log section. It determines the shape. They sand them. Even though their bowls are very high quality, turned using old lathe techniques (no lasers), I would not refer to them as "handmade" because something that matters (shape in this instance) was predetermined by the only path that the knife allows. In the case of laser engraving, your finished surface is automated (Yes, I have issues with rose engine work being called handmade too!)

Nobody is suggesting that you can't/shouldn't/won't be successful. You asked for opinions on the topic, and a lot of people think that lasers engravers are too mechanized to still be called handmade. These are opinions, not facts, and disagreement is good, as it broadens both sides knowledge.

Steve

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#30

Re: You've missed the point

George Guadiane

Charlie,

You wrote: "But if I then do ANYTHING to the piece that is not directly controlled by my hand - it's no longer handmade and isn't the result of craftsmanship - based on your criteria?"

Steve and I are not the only ones who has tried to present an alternate point of view, a sense of personal values, a way of describing why, FOR US, using a laser (at least until we see a finished product) is not something that WE think is for us.

You have managed to misinterpret and or misrepresent what we have said, virtually without exception... In reading what others have said, and how you respond, in fact, including your original post, where you started out asking for an OPINION "Does It Matter HOW?" you have had a position. You have made it pretty clear that you want us to agree with you that what you want to do is "good," and that we should like it.

See if you can grasp THIS:

In MY opinion, until I see something that impresses me, something that shows me that your ideas have more value than you have been able to convey by talking/arguing about them, I will be unswayed. I'm not going to try it. I don't care if you do or don't... If you DO try it, I hope you meet with RAGING SUCCESS and that I look at the finished product wishing that I had seen your vision before you did.

Until that point trying to make it SOUND better is a waste of time, as, clearly, trying to respond to your original question has been a waste of time for me.

If your first post had been something like: "I have this idea" and you just laid it out most of us would probably not have bothered to comment.

YOU asked for an opinion and then argued with everyone who bothered to give it... Or did I miss something?

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#31

Hand Made & Craft

charlile belden

Steve:

On first reading, your definition of handmade seemed to be pretty good.

"When any part of the outcome that has a material value has been achieved by some automated system, it's no longer 100% handmade"

So I consulted my Funk & Wagnalls Standard Dictionary - pocket edition - and couldn't find "handmade" or "hand-made" or "hand made". So I checked the dictionary that probably came with MicroSoft Office and found this definition

"made by hand, not by machine, and typically therefore of superior quality"

I'm not totally in agreement with "and typically therefore of superior quality" because I've seen some really poor stuff - done all by hand. Just being done by hand doesn't necessarily make the results "superior quality". Craftsmanship seems to be a better gauge of "superior quality".

craft

"an activity involving skill in making things by hand"

craftsman

"a person who is skilled in a particular craft."

So "hand made" and "craftsmanship" require that the results be done by hand. Not sure how variable speed lathes, indexing wheels, jigs with guides created "by hand" but when used are controlled by the jig and its guide - say a fluting jig, ornamental mills and segmented turning where part sizes and angles are calculated - say with a computer software spreadsheet - and cut using jigs - which the maker of the segmented turning may or may not have made - and might have been made by a machine, and a few other things turners sometimes use - fit in the scheme of things.

Guess I'll shoot for "artist" - LOTS more room to play in!

Re: Does It Matter HOW?

#32

Re: Money talks, BS walks

Russ Fairfield

Charlie, please give it up. You are taking up way too much bandwidth on an argument to nowhere. For all of your words, we have yet to see anything that you have made or decorated with the laser. You don't need our permission to do that. Make something, and either the market or the art community will tell you if you were successful with it. If you aren't interested in their money or their opinions, then do it for your own pleasure.